Oil Investing: Smart Move?

Oil stocks can be a good investment, but they are also risky. Oil is a crucial part of the global economy, and there are several large companies that dominate the market. However, the oil industry is highly volatile, and investors need to be cautious when choosing oil stocks.

The oil industry is susceptible to fluctuations in supply and demand, which can cause oil prices to skyrocket or plummet. For example, the COVID-19 pandemic caused a sharp decline in oil demand, while the Russian invasion of Ukraine in 2022 led to a surge in oil prices. Oil companies are also exposed to legal and regulatory risks, as accidents like oil spills can have devastating consequences and cause a company's share price to plummet.

Additionally, the world is slowly moving away from fossil fuels towards greener alternatives. Governments are increasingly pressuring oil companies to decarbonize their operations, and demand for oil and gas is expected to decrease in the coming decades.

Despite the risks, there are still opportunities in the oil industry. Some oil companies are focusing on going green, and investors can benefit from the high dividend yields that oil stocks often provide. When investing in oil, it is crucial to carefully research and diversify your portfolio to manage the risks effectively.

Oil stocks can be volatile

Commodity Price Volatility

The oil industry is susceptible to significant fluctuations in commodity prices, which can be caused by changes in supply and demand. For example, the industry experienced substantial volatility in 2014 and 2015 due to a supply glut, and more recently, oil prices collapsed amid the economic slowdown in 2020. These price swings can have a significant impact on the financial performance of oil companies and, consequently, their stock prices.

Cyclicality

The oil and gas sector tends to include cyclical businesses, which means that investors are likely to experience booms and busts. When oil prices are high, energy stocks often soar, but when prices drop, the market tends to punish these stocks. This cyclical nature can make it challenging to predict the performance of oil stocks over the long term.

Uncertainty in Exploration

Oil and gas exploration comes with a high degree of uncertainty. Companies invest significant resources in exploration blocks, testing, and drilling without any guarantee of finding viable deposits. This uncertainty can result in substantial financial losses for companies and their investors if explorations do not yield productive oil or gas wells.

Regulatory and Environmental Risks

The oil industry faces increasing pressure from governments and environmental concerns. As the world shifts towards cleaner energy sources, demand for oil and gas is expected to wane in the coming decades. Additionally, oil companies are exposed to legal and regulatory risks associated with accidents, such as oil spills, which can have devastating environmental impacts and lead to significant financial and reputational losses for the companies involved.

Geopolitical Factors

Geopolitical events and policies can also influence oil prices and the performance of oil stocks. For example, the oil price war between Saudi Arabia and Russia in 2020 caused global oil prices to plummet, affecting the entire industry. Similarly, the Russian invasion of Ukraine in 2022 led to a rebound in oil prices and a corresponding surge in energy stocks.

OPEC's Influence

OPEC (Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries), a cartel of oil-exporting nations, plays a significant role in oil prices. By adjusting supply, OPEC can cause substantial fluctuations in oil prices, which, in turn, affect the profitability and stock prices of oil companies.

Volatility Measurement

Volatility in oil prices is typically measured as the expected change in the price of oil in either direction. For example, if the volatility is 15% and the current oil price is $100, traders expect the price to change by 15% in the next year (reaching $85 or $115). Traders use this information to make informed decisions about buying and selling oil-related derivatives.

In summary, oil stocks can be highly volatile due to various factors beyond the control of individual companies. While investing in this sector can offer significant opportunities for profit, it also carries considerable risks that investors should carefully consider before making any investment decisions.

Oil companies are crucial to the global economy

The largest global oil producers are the United States, Saudi Arabia, and Russia, who together account for 43% of total world production. The industry is made up of three main segments: upstream (exploration and drilling), midstream (transportation and storage), and downstream (refining and marketing). Upstream activities are considered the most crucial as they involve the discovery and drilling of oil, without which the rest of the industry would not exist.

Oil and gas companies also have a significant impact on trade and politics. They control the supply and pricing of oil and gas, affecting the cost of energy and manufacturing globally. They can influence government policies, lobby for favourable legislation, and impact the stability of regimes through their investment decisions. Additionally, they contribute to GDP, tax revenues, and the creation of jobs, both directly and indirectly.

The economic weight of the oil and gas sector is further evident in its broad reach across industrial and financial systems. The sector demands significant capital investments in infrastructure, research, and talent development. It is also crucial for the stability of energy supplies, which directly impacts industrial productivity, utility services, and transportation systems.

In summary, oil companies are vital to the global economy due to their role in providing essential resources, driving economic growth, creating jobs, contributing to government revenues, and influencing trade and political dynamics. Their far-reaching impact underscores the significance of this industry in the modern world.

Oil stocks can be safe investments

Oil stocks can be a safe investment, but it depends on the company and the timing. The oil and gas industry is volatile, and there are several risks to consider before investing. However, some oil companies are safer than others, and well-timed investments in oil and gas can turn out to be very profitable.

The Benefits of Investing in Oil and Gas

Oil and gas stocks can produce significant capital gains and attractive dividend income during periods of high oil and gas prices. Fossil fuels remain in high demand because they are usually cheaper than other heating and transportation fuels, and they have a massive infrastructure advantage over emerging clean energy sources.

Some of the biggest companies in the world are oil and gas producers, including ExxonMobil, Royal Dutch Shell, Chevron, BP, and TotalEnergies. These "oil supermajors" have global operations and annual revenues of over $100 billion, so they are unlikely to go bankrupt anytime soon.

The Risks of Investing in Oil and Gas

The oil and gas sector tends to include cyclical businesses, so investors are likely to experience booms and busts. Oil and gas companies are also subject to factors beyond their control, such as the prices of oil and gas, which can cause stock prices to collapse when prices are low.

Oil and gas exploration is unpredictable and can result in large losses from investments that don't pan out. There are also environmental and safety concerns associated with the production and transportation of oil and gas, which are flammable and toxic. Accidents, such as oil spills, can cause a company's share price to plummet.

Timing is Crucial

Timing plays a crucial role in oil and gas investments. For example, in 2021, crude oil prices rallied by more than 50% in the first half of the year due to the reopening of the global economy after the COVID-19 pandemic.

However, energy prices have steadily declined in the second half of 2022 and into 2023, illustrating the volatile nature of the commodity's pricing. Therefore, investing in the industry may not be the smartest choice at the moment, but that could change if oil and gas prices start to rise again.

Diversification and Professional Advice

Direct investments in oil and gas projects can bring substantial tax advantages, while diversifying investments can potentially bring higher returns. However, it is essential to manage risk and seek the help of a professional financial advisor before investing in oil and gas.

Oil stocks can be affordable

Oil stocks can be a good investment, especially when prices are low. The energy sector is an active and liquid market that can serve as a portfolio diversifier and inflation hedge. However, it is essential to remember that investing in oil and gas carries significant risks due to the industry's volatility and cyclicality.

Dividend Yields and Free Cash Flow

Strong Fundamentals and Undervalued Stocks

Some oil stocks have strong fundamentals, such as high reserves, production growth, and increasing cash flow. These companies may be undervalued by the market, providing an opportunity for investors to buy at a discount. For example, in June 2019, Crescent Point Energy Corp (TSX: CPG)(NYSE: CPG) was trading at a significant discount to its net asset value, and the company authorized a share repurchase program to propel its stock price higher. Similarly, Storm Resources (TSX: SRX) has a history of successful value creation, with the same management team running three other companies with the same name and selling each at a healthy profit.

Large Oil Companies

Large oil companies, also known as "oil supermajors," such as ExxonMobil, Royal Dutch Shell, BP, Chevron, and TotalEnergies, are less risky than smaller companies due to their global operations, strong financial profiles, and investment-grade bond ratings. These companies are not going bankrupt anytime soon and can be a safe addition to an investment portfolio.

Risks and Uncertainties

While oil stocks can be affordable, it is important to consider the risks associated with investing in the oil and gas industry. Oil and gas prices are highly volatile and sensitive to changes in supply and demand. Additionally, oil companies face regulatory and legal risks, as well as the possibility of accidents, such as oil spills, which can have devastating consequences and cause a company's share price to plummet. Therefore, it is crucial to thoroughly research and understand the risks before investing in oil stocks.

Oil stocks can be sustainable

Oil stocks can be a sustainable investment option, but it depends on the company and the investor's risk appetite. While the broader energy sector has underperformed in recent years, oil stocks stood out as some of the best-performing assets during the 2022 bear market.

The key to sustainable oil investments is to focus on companies that can navigate the industry's volatility and cyclical nature. Here are some factors that contribute to the sustainability of oil stocks:

Diversification

Oil companies with diversified operations across multiple basins or regions are better equipped to withstand fluctuations in oil prices. Diversification can come in the form of operating in different geographical areas or engaging in various activities along the oil value chain.

Cost Structure

Investors should favour oil companies with low-cost structures, enabling them to remain profitable even when oil prices dip. For example, companies with access to low-cost oil reserves, such as those in the Permian Basin, can better sustain periods of low oil prices.

Financial Profile

A strong financial profile is crucial for oil companies to navigate market downturns. This includes having an investment-grade bond rating, ample cash reserves, manageable debt, and access to affordable credit. A robust financial position allows companies to continue operations and maintain shareholder returns during market downturns.

Transition to Green Energy

Oil companies that are proactively transitioning to green energy or investing in renewable energy sources are better positioned for the future. These companies are more likely to be sustainable over the long term as the world gradually moves away from fossil fuels.

Dividend Strategy

Oil companies that offer attractive and sustainable dividend yields can be a good investment option. A fixed-plus-variable dividend framework, where a portion of excess cash flow is returned to investors, can provide steady income and the potential for higher returns during periods of high oil prices.

Size and Scale

Larger oil companies, often referred to as "oil supermajors," tend to be more stable investments. Companies like ExxonMobil, Royal Dutch Shell, BP, Chevron, and TotalEnergies have global operations and substantial financial resources, making them less vulnerable to market downturns.

In conclusion, while oil stocks carry inherent risks due to the volatile nature of the industry, there are sustainable investment opportunities within this sector. By considering factors such as diversification, cost structure, financial profile, transition to green energy, dividend strategy, and the size and scale of the company, investors can identify oil stocks that align with their risk appetite and contribute to a well-diversified portfolio.

Frequently asked questions