What's The Deal? Investment Managers And Broker-Dealers Explained

Investment advisers and broker-dealers are two distinct types of professionals in the financial services industry. While they both offer financial recommendations, there are important differences between the two, including how they are paid and regulated. Investment advisers are paid a flat fee or a percentage of assets under management (AUM) to advise clients on securities and manage portfolios. They are also held to a higher legal standard than brokers and must adhere to the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, which includes fiduciary duties. On the other hand, broker-dealers are individuals or firms that buy and sell securities for their clients or themselves. They are typically paid commissions based on each buy or sell transaction. Understanding these differences is crucial for investors looking to enter the stock market and deciding which professional is best suited to help them achieve their financial goals.

Investment managers advise on securities and manage portfolios

Investment managers are individuals or organisations that advise clients on securities and manage their portfolios. They handle financial planning, investing, and portfolio management activities, overseeing investments and acting on behalf of their clients.

Investment managers help both individuals and institutional investors. They devise strategies and execute trades within a financial portfolio, buying and selling securities and assets, and handling transaction settlements and performance measurements. Their fee is often based on a percentage of client assets under management (AUM).

They follow market activity closely to help dictate investment decisions for their clients, meeting with them individually or with relevant financial team members at a company. Client portfolios can include assets in market sectors such as technology, utilities, healthcare, or energy. Investment managers consistently strategise to expand client holdings.

In terms of skills and qualifications, investment managers commonly hold undergraduate degrees in business, statistics, finance, mathematics, or accounting, and may have an MBA or professional certifications. They must have excellent communication skills, the ability to obtain and sustain a client's trust, analytical skills to interpret market information, the ability to understand financial data, and the ability to work effectively under pressure.

Investment managers are a type of investment adviser, who are paid to provide advice about securities to their clients. Investment advisers can also manage investment portfolios, offer financial planning services, and provide licensed brokerage services to buy or sell stocks. Investment advisers are regulated by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and/or a state regulatory body.

Broker-dealers are paid commissions for executing trades or buying and selling assets

Broker-dealers are financial professionals who facilitate securities transactions for their clients. They are paid commissions for executing trades or buying and selling assets. Commissions are payments for connecting a client with another investor during a transaction, known as an agency transaction.

Commission brokers are employees of brokerage firms who receive payment for the number of trades they execute for their clients. They typically earn a percentage of the client's assets traded, meaning their earnings are tied to the volume of business that a client does. This commission structure can incentivise brokers to put their own interests above those of their clients to earn more money, potentially leading to unethical practices such as churning and bucketing. Churning involves executing multiple trades in a customer's account solely to generate more commissions, without any benefit to the customer. Bucketing involves buying or selling a security at a better price than expected but keeping the profit instead of passing the savings on to the client.

In addition to commissions, broker-dealers may also earn markups and markdowns. A markup is charged when a security is sold to a client from the broker-dealer's inventory at a slightly higher price than its market value. Conversely, a markdown is applied when a broker-dealer buys a security from a client at a slightly lower price than its market value. These markups and markdowns are similar to the practices of car dealerships.

Broker-dealers are not required to disclose typical transaction costs before a trade, but larger-than-normal commissions, markups, or markdowns must be disclosed and accepted by the client beforehand. While commissions are typically transaction fees paid to broker-dealers, in some cases, a portion of the commission may be shared with an affiliated investment adviser. This occurs when the broker-dealer and investment adviser are owned by the same parent company, allowing the investment adviser to retain a part of the commission.

Overall, broker-dealers play a crucial role in facilitating securities transactions and are compensated through commissions, markups, and markdowns. However, it is important to be aware of potential conflicts of interest and unethical practices that may arise due to the commission-based structure of their earnings.

Investment managers are paid a flat fee or percentage of assets

Investment managers, also known as investment advisers, are paid either a flat fee or a percentage of the assets under management (AUM). The fee structure is usually based on a percentage of AUM, which can range from 0.10% to over 2%. However, some investment managers may charge a flat fee, which is typically a set amount for each household, such as a yearly fee of $7,500 paid monthly or quarterly.

The flat fee structure is often more advantageous for clients with larger asset balances. For example, consider a client with $3 million to invest. A typical fee for an investment manager is between 0.8% and 1%, which would result in annual costs of $25,000 to $30,000. In contrast, a flat fee of around $10,000 per year would provide significant savings.

On the other hand, percentage fees tend to work better for smaller balances. A flat fee may consume a large percentage of a small account and may not be advisable. For instance, a $7,500 flat fee on an account with $250,000 in assets would result in an effective AUM percentage of 3%, which is higher than the industry standard.

The management fee compensates investment managers for their time and expertise in selecting stocks and managing investment portfolios. It may also cover other costs, such as investor relations and administrative expenses. Actively managed funds tend to have higher management fees than passively managed funds, but they don't necessarily deliver better returns.

Broker-dealers are regulated by FINRA, unlike investment managers

Broker-dealers and investment managers have distinct roles in the financial services sector. A broker-dealer is a firm or individual licensed to buy, sell, or trade securities for their clients or their own accounts. They are paid a commission for each transaction they execute. On the other hand, investment managers, also known as investment advisers, provide advice and consulting services to their clients on investment decisions and strategies. They are paid a flat fee or a percentage of the assets under management.

While both professionals play crucial roles in the financial industry, they are subject to different regulatory frameworks. Broker-dealers are regulated by the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA), a self-regulatory organization authorized by Congress to oversee the broker-dealer industry. FINRA ensures that broker-dealers operate with fairness and honesty, protecting investors and maintaining the integrity of the market. It sets rules and provides guidance to securities firms and brokers, mandating that anyone selling securities products is adequately tested, qualified, and licensed. FINRA also scrutinizes securities product advertisements to ensure they are truthful and not misleading.

In contrast, investment managers are regulated by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and/or state regulatory bodies. The SEC, established by the US government, is responsible for regulating investment advisers and enforcing securities laws. Investment managers must adhere to the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, which imposes a fiduciary duty on them to act in their clients' best interests. This legal standard prohibits advisers from defrauding their clients and requires them to exercise utmost good faith and full disclosure of material facts.

The distinction in regulatory bodies underscores the different nature of the services provided by broker-dealers and investment managers. Broker-dealers primarily execute trades and facilitate transactions, hence the focus on licensing and qualification oversight by FINRA. In contrast, investment managers offer advisory services, and the SEC's regulation ensures they provide honest and trustworthy advice while upholding their fiduciary responsibilities.

While broker-dealers and investment managers have distinct regulatory frameworks, there can be some overlap in their roles. In some cases, firms may register as both broker-dealers and investment advisers to provide a comprehensive range of services to their clients. Additionally, brokers may expand their services beyond trade execution to include personalized investment management, blurring the lines between the two professions.

Broker-dealers can be wirehouses or independent

Broker-dealers are firms or individuals licensed to sell securities. They can be categorised as wirehouses or independent.

A wirehouse is a full-service broker-dealer, which is sometimes synonymous with a "brokerage firm". Wirehouses tend to be more structured and are often owned by a parent company. They may also be referred to as "bank broker-dealers". Registered representatives working for wirehouses are often told what products to sell and how to conduct their business.

On the other hand, independent broker-dealers are independently owned and operated. They are not part of a large Wall Street firm or bank. They provide their employees with greater freedom in how they conduct their business, which is appealing to experienced investment professionals. However, independents often have higher commissions and advisors have to handle more business expenses and find their own clients.

Both wirehouses and independent broker-dealers have their own pros and cons.

Frequently asked questions