Index Funds: Ethical Investment Or Unregulated Risk?

Ethical investing is an investment strategy that allows investors to put their money where their morals are. It involves using one's ethical principles as the primary filter for selecting securities to invest in. While the concept of ethical investing was initially driven by religious values, it has evolved to encompass broader social and environmental concerns. Today, investors, particularly younger ones, want to ensure their investments align with their values and support ethically and socially conscious business practices.

The rise of ethical investing is challenging the notion that investing is solely about maximising financial returns. Instead, it empowers individuals to allocate capital towards companies whose practices and values align with their personal beliefs. However, it is important to note that ethical investing does not guarantee superior performance, and investors may need to sacrifice financial gains for an ethical approach.

Despite this potential trade-off, ethical investing offers several advantages. It can improve personal satisfaction by allowing investors to support companies that institute positive change. Additionally, as more people invest ethically, it may pressure other companies to adopt more sustainable and socially responsible practices to remain competitive.

However, ethical investing also presents challenges. Designing an ethical investment portfolio can be time-consuming and expensive, requiring extensive research to ensure alignment with an investor's values. Furthermore, ethical investment funds may underperform the market and often come with higher fees due to the additional research involved.

Ultimately, the decision to invest in index funds ethically depends on individual values and priorities. While it may not always result in maximum financial returns, it can provide the satisfaction of supporting positive change and aligning investments with personal beliefs.

The historical performance of ethical funds

Ethical funds may also offer lower levels of market risk than traditional funds, even in volatile markets. During the first quarter of 2020, 24 out of 26 ESG index funds outperformed comparable conventional funds.

However, it is important to note that selecting investments based on ethics does not guarantee performance. The performance of ethical funds depends on various factors, including the specific companies and industries included in the fund, the fund's management, and overall market conditions.

Additionally, the definition of "ethical" varies from person to person, so it is crucial to understand a fund's methodology for selecting investments. Some funds may primarily focus on excluding negative-impact investments, while others may emphasise including positive-impact investments or use a combination of both approaches.

When considering the historical performance of ethical funds, it is also worth noting that the field of ethical investing has evolved over time. In the 20th century, ethical investments were largely influenced by social and political trends, such as promoting equality and workers' rights and moving away from companies involved in the Vietnam War.

In the 1990s, environmental issues gained prominence, with ethical investors favouring companies supporting clean and sustainable energy over coal and fossil fuel companies. Today, ethical investing continues to focus primarily on environmental and societal impacts, with investors increasingly demanding sustainable and responsible business practices.

While ethical funds do not guarantee superior performance, their historical performance has been comparable to traditional funds, and in some cases, they have outperformed their peers.

The pros and cons of ethical investing

Ethical investing is an investment strategy in which an investor chooses investments based on an ethical code, such as religious or social values, and financial returns. While the concept of ethical investing is subjective and depends on an individual's beliefs, there are several pros and cons to this approach.

Pros of Ethical Investing:

• Personal Satisfaction: Ethical investing allows individuals to invest in companies whose missions they support, aligning their investments with their personal values. This can lead to a higher level of satisfaction as they are supporting causes they believe in.
• Supporting Positive Change: By investing in ethically or socially responsible companies, individuals can back businesses that are making a positive difference in important areas such as clean energy, fair labour practices, and gender equity initiatives.
• Encouraging Broader Change: A broader shift towards ethical investing may pressure other companies to adopt more ethical practices to remain competitive and attract funding.
• Potential for Strong Returns: Research suggests that ethical funds can perform similarly or even outperform traditional funds. Some evidence indicates that ethical funds may offer lower levels of market risk, particularly in volatile markets.

Cons of Ethical Investing:

• Time and Research: Ethical investing requires significant time and research to ensure that investments align with an individual's values and beliefs. Building and maintaining an ethical investment portfolio can be a challenging and expensive endeavour.
• Potential Underperformance: While ethical funds can perform well, there is no guarantee of optimal returns. Investors may need to sacrifice financial gains for an ethical approach, and the fees associated with ethical investing can be higher due to the additional research required.
• Limited Impact on Unethical Companies: Boycotting unethical companies by not investing in them does not necessarily punish these businesses. The money from stock purchases goes to individual sellers, not the company itself, and a reduced pool of shareholders may even make the stock more attractive to less ethical investors.

How to build an ethical investment portfolio

Ethical investing is an investment strategy that allows an investor to choose investments based on an ethical code, such as religious or social values, and financial returns. Ethical investing supports industries that make a positive impact, such as sustainable energy, and often aligns with ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) investing.

• Decide how involved you want to be: You can choose to build your portfolio yourself by selecting specific investments and monitoring them, or you can seek help from robo-advisors, which use algorithms to build and manage portfolios based on your risk tolerance, goals, and ethical preferences. Robo-advisors are generally cheaper than traditional advisors, but they may not allow you to add specific investments to your portfolio.
• Know your ethical priorities: Outline what an ethical investment looks like to you. Identify your values and causes you care about, such as climate change, social justice, or animal welfare. This will help you include or exclude certain investments.
• Find ethical investments: Open a brokerage account and start building a portfolio that aligns with your moral compass. Look for companies with transparent reporting practices and sustainable initiatives, such as reducing carbon emissions or promoting diversity. Consider investing in stocks, mutual funds, or exchange-traded funds (ETFs) that focus on socially responsible investing (SRI) or ESG criteria.
• Diversify your portfolio: Invest in a mix of asset classes, industries, and geographies that reflect your ethical priorities and risk tolerance. This helps manage risk and maximize returns.
• Monitor and rebalance your portfolio: Regularly review your ethical investment portfolio to ensure it remains aligned with your values and financial goals. Assess the social and environmental impact of your investments by reviewing company reports, ESG ratings, and other relevant information. Rebalance your portfolio as needed to maintain the desired level of diversification.
• Work with ethical financial professionals: Choose a financial advisor who specializes in ethical investing and shares your values. They can help you develop a customized strategy that reflects your values, risk tolerance, and financial objectives.

The different types of ethical investment funds

Ethical investment funds are a way to put your money where your morals are. While the term "ethical investment" covers a broad range of funds, they all aim to generate meaningful, measurable societal outcomes while generating healthy profits.

Socially Responsible Investing (SRI)

SRI funds allow investors to balance their desire for profitability with their concerns about the future of the planet and society. These funds typically focus on companies that promote environmental sustainability and social responsibility. Examples of SRI funds include iShares ESG Aware MSCI USA ETF (ESGU) and TIAA-CREF Social Choice Equity (TICRX).

Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) Investing

ESG investing refers to a set of standards used by socially conscious investors to screen investments. The ESG criteria include a company's environmental practices, social impact, and corporate governance. ESG funds rate companies based on these criteria and invest in those with favourable ratings. Examples of ESG funds include iShares Global Clean Energy ETF (ICLN) and Invesco Solar ETF (TAN).

Impact Investing

Impact investing is an investment strategy that aims to generate specific beneficial social or environmental effects in addition to financial gains. These funds may focus on areas such as clean energy, gender equality, or racial justice. Some impact investing funds include Betterment's Climate Impact portfolio and Wealthfront's socially responsible portfolio.

Faith-Based Investing

Faith-based investing involves making investment decisions that align with religious values and teachings. For example, Islamic banking shuns investments in alcohol, gambling, and pork. The Amana Mutual Funds Trust offers investment products adhering to these principles.

Sustainable Investing

Sustainable investing promotes investments in companies that follow sustainable and ethical business practices. These companies are often leaders in key sustainability issues that are financially material to their business context. Putnam Sustainable Leaders (PNOPX) is an example of a sustainable investing fund.

Racial Justice Investing

Racial justice investing involves investing in companies or funds that promote racial equality and diversity. These investments may focus on companies with strong diversity and inclusion policies and practices.

How ethical investing can affect returns

Ethical investing is an investment strategy that allows investors to choose investments based on their ethical code, such as religious or social values, and financial returns. Ethical investing empowers individuals to allocate capital toward companies whose practices and values align with their personal beliefs.

While ethical investing is a great way to support social and environmental initiatives, it is important to note that it may not guarantee performance. The performance of ethical funds has been shown to be similar to that of traditional funds, with some research indicating that ethical fund performance may be superior.

For instance, according to Morningstar data, sustainable funds outperformed their traditional peers in 2019, with 66% finishing the year with returns in the top half of their Morningstar categories. Additionally, 24 out of 26 ESG index funds outperformed comparable conventional funds during the first quarter of 2020, suggesting that ethical funds may offer lower levels of market risk.

However, it is worth noting that the question of whether ESG funds offer the same level of returns as other funds is still hotly debated due to the variety of ethical investment options available.

To make financially sound decisions, it is crucial to calculate the required returns on ethical investments to ensure they align with your retirement goals. While there may be divergence in returns over shorter periods, examining returns over a 10-year period can provide a clearer picture of the long-term performance.

In conclusion, ethical investing can be a powerful tool to create positive change while generating financial returns. However, it is important to conduct thorough research and carefully evaluate companies' commitment to ethical practices to make informed investment decisions.

Frequently asked questions