Real Estate Funds Vs. Buying A House: What's The Difference?

Investing in real estate or stocks is a personal choice that depends on an individual's financial situation, risk tolerance, goals, and investment style. While stocks are a well-known investment option, real estate is also considered an investment. Real estate funds and investing in a house are two different ways to invest in real estate. Real estate funds pool money from multiple investors to purchase properties, providing diversification and lowering entry costs. On the other hand, investing in a house involves buying a single property, which may require a larger upfront investment. Both options offer potential benefits and risks that investors should carefully consider before making a decision.

Real estate investment trusts (REITs) vs. real estate funds

Real estate investment trusts (REITs) and real estate funds are both ways to invest in real estate without actually owning physical properties. However, there are some key differences between the two.

REITs vs. Real Estate Funds:

A real estate investment trust (REIT) is a corporation, trust, or association that invests directly in income-producing real estate. REITs are traded like stocks on major exchanges, and prices fluctuate throughout the trading session. They are required to pay out at least 90% of their taxable income as dividends to shareholders, making them a good source of passive income. There are three main types of REITs: equity REITs, mortgage REITs, and hybrid REITs.

On the other hand, a real estate fund is a type of mutual fund that primarily invests in securities offered by public real estate companies, including REITs. Real estate funds can be actively or passively managed, and they gain value through appreciation over time. They do not provide short-term income like REITs but offer broader asset selection and diversification. There are three types of real estate funds: real estate exchange-traded funds (REIT-ETFs), real estate mutual funds, and private real estate investment funds.

Direct Real Estate Investing vs. REITs and Real Estate Funds:

Direct real estate investing involves buying and managing physical properties, such as residential or commercial real estate. It offers the potential for substantial cash flow and numerous tax breaks but requires significant time, energy, and financial commitment.

Both REITs and real estate funds provide an alternative to direct real estate investing, allowing investors to access the real estate market without the same level of risk, time, or financial investment.

REITs and real estate funds each have their own advantages and are suitable for different types of investors. REITs are ideal for those seeking passive income through dividends, while real estate funds are better for long-term investors looking for value appreciation. Direct real estate investing may be preferable for those wanting more control over their investments and the potential for higher returns, despite the increased time and financial commitment required.

Returns: real estate vs. stocks

The returns of real estate and stocks are influenced by various factors, and it is challenging to make a direct comparison between the two. However, we can examine the historical performance and unique characteristics of each investment type to understand their potential returns.

Real Estate Returns

The average 10-year return on real estate investments has been around 10%, according to reports from several real estate research firms. However, it is important to note that returns can vary depending on the specific location and market conditions. Real estate investments provide a passive income stream through rents and the potential for substantial appreciation over time. Additionally, real estate offers leverage through mortgages, allowing investors to expand their holdings even without full cash payment.

Stock Returns

The stock market, as measured by the S&P 500 index, has historically provided an average annual return of about 10% before adjusting for inflation. It is important to note that stock market returns can fluctuate, with some years experiencing gains and others experiencing losses. Stocks offer the potential for value appreciation as company values increase and dividends. Investing in stocks typically requires less initial capital compared to real estate, making it more accessible to a wider range of investors.

Key Differences

Real estate investments tend to require more substantial upfront capital and are less liquid than stocks. Selling real estate can take months and incur significant transaction costs. On the other hand, stocks are more easily bought and sold, providing greater flexibility and lower transaction fees. Diversification is also more achievable with stocks due to the lower investment threshold, allowing investors to spread their risk across various companies and industries.

While real estate may provide a hedge against inflation and offer tax advantages, it demands more active management and comes with the challenges of repairs, maintenance, and tenant management. Stocks, on the other hand, offer higher liquidity and easier diversification but are subject to market volatility and potential capital gains taxes upon selling.

Risks: real estate vs. stocks

Real estate and stocks have different risks and opportunities. Here are some of the key risks to consider for each:

Risks of Real Estate Investment

• Lack of liquidity: Real estate is not as liquid as stocks, meaning it can't be easily converted to cash. It can take months to find a buyer for a property, and even longer to finalise the sale.
• High transaction costs: Selling property often involves significant closing costs, which can eat into profits.
• Lack of diversification: Diversifying a real estate portfolio by location and property type can be difficult and expensive, as it requires a large amount of capital.
• Research and management: Real estate requires extensive research before investing, and ongoing management if you are dealing with rental properties or property renovations.
• Appreciation is not guaranteed: While property prices tend to rise over time, there is always a risk of selling at a loss.

Risks of Stock Investment

• Market, economic, and inflationary risks: Stock values are extremely volatile and susceptible to fluctuations in the market, economic cycles, monetary policy, tax revisions, and interest rate changes.
• Emotion-driven investing: Stocks are more accessible and easier to buy and sell than real estate, which can lead to impulsive decision-making by investors.
• Capital gains tax: Selling stocks may result in a capital gains tax, increasing your tax burden.
• Limited growth potential: Unless you have a large amount of money invested in the market, your holdings may not grow significantly.
• Dividend reliance: Relying solely on high-yield dividend stocks may cause investors to miss out on opportunities for higher growth.

Pros and cons of investing in real estate

Real estate investment can be a highly profitable activity, but it also comes with certain risks. Here are some pros and cons to consider before investing in real estate:

Pros of Investing in Real Estate:

• Steady income: One of the most appealing aspects of investing in real estate is the potential for a steady stream of rental income. Rental income can provide a consistent cash flow to cover expenses or reinvest in more properties.
• Appreciation: Owning property often leads to long-term capital appreciation, resulting in significant gains when selling.
• Tax benefits: Real estate investors can take advantage of various tax incentives and deductions, such as mortgage interest, property taxes, and certain maintenance expenses, reducing overall tax liability.
• Diversification: Real estate is an excellent addition to a diversified investment portfolio as it often has a low correlation with stocks and bonds, providing a hedge against market volatility.
• Control: Real estate allows for a more hands-on approach compared to other investments. Investors have control over property management, improvements, and the ability to increase the property's value through strategic updates.

Cons of Investing in Real Estate:

• High initial costs: Real estate investment typically requires a significant amount of upfront capital, including the down payment, closing costs, property inspections, and potential renovation expenses.
• Illiquidity: Real estate is not a liquid investment, and selling a property can take time. It may be difficult to access funds quickly in case of an emergency.
• Property management: Being a landlord can be time-consuming and stressful, dealing with tenants, maintenance issues, and property management.
• Market volatility: While generally less volatile than the stock market, real estate is still affected by market fluctuations. Economic downturns can lead to decreased property values and increased vacancies, impacting rental income and overall return on investment.
• Risk of bad tenants: Finding and retaining reliable tenants is a significant challenge. Bad tenants can lead to property damage, missed rent payments, and eviction expenses.

Pros and cons of investing in stocks

While investing in the stock market can be a great way to build wealth over time, it also comes with certain risks and challenges. Here are some pros and cons of investing in stocks to consider:

Pros of Investing in Stocks:

• Liquidity: Stocks are highly liquid, meaning you can buy or sell them quickly and easily. In contrast, real estate investments can take months or even years to sell.
• Diversification: It is much easier to diversify your investment portfolio with stocks than with real estate. You can invest in a variety of companies across different sectors and geographies, reducing your risk.
• Low Transaction Costs: While real estate transactions often involve high fees, buying and selling stocks typically incurs little to no cost, especially with the recent trend of $0 stock trading fees offered by many brokers.
• Fractional Shares: Many brokers now offer fractional shares, allowing you to invest in a company even if you can't afford a full share. This lowers the barrier to entry for new investors.
• Potential for High Returns: Historically, the stock market has delivered generous returns over time. The S&P 500, for example, has averaged an annualized return of roughly 10% since 1957.
• Dividends: Many stocks pay dividends, providing a source of regular income in addition to potential price appreciation.

Cons of Investing in Stocks:

• Risk of Loss: There is no guarantee of positive returns in the stock market. You could lose some or all of your investment, especially in the short term.
• Volatility: Stock prices can fluctuate significantly, which can be emotionally challenging for investors. It can be difficult to hold on during market downturns, but selling during volatility may result in losses.
• Taxes: Profits from selling stocks are typically subject to capital gains taxes. Even if you hold stocks for the long term, these taxes will reduce your overall returns.
• Time Commitment: Investing in stocks requires research and monitoring. You need to analyze companies and stay updated on market trends, which can be time-consuming.
• Competition: Professional and institutional investors have more resources, knowledge, and tools at their disposal, giving them an advantage over individual investors.

Frequently asked questions