Coronavirus: Is Bitcoin A Safe Investment Haven?

Bitcoin is a risky investment. It is highly volatile and prone to significant price swings, which can lead to substantial losses during economic uncertainty. It is also a speculative investment, lacking intrinsic value and the ability to generate income. However, it has been deemed a good investment by some, especially in the wake of the coronavirus pandemic, which saw a surge in the value of Bitcoin.

Bitcoin's high volatility and correlation to tech stocks

Bitcoins High Volatility and Correlation to Tech Stocks

Bitcoin is a risky investment with high volatility. It is prone to significant price swings, which can lead to substantial losses during economic uncertainty. In 2022, the price of Bitcoin dropped from almost $48,000 to lows of around $16,000. This kind of volatility can make crypto feel unsafe to new investors.

Bitcoin's high volatility makes it a speculative asset. It is often traded on price speculation rather than intrinsic value. It is also not a stable investment security. In fact, most financial advisors recommend keeping Bitcoin to less than 5% of your overall portfolio.

Bitcoin's price often correlates with high-risk assets, such as tech stocks, which tend to decline in a recession. The correlation coefficient of Bitcoin and the S&P 500, a benchmark stock index for the United States, was 0.36 for 2020-21, indicating that the assets moved more in lockstep, rising and falling together.

Bitcoin's correlation with tech stocks is also evident when comparing it to the NASDAQ 100 Technology Index (NDXT). The BTC-NDXT correlation often shows sharper peaks and troughs, indicating that Bitcoin may be more sensitive to tech stock movements than the broader market.

Bitcoin's speculative nature

Bitcoin is a highly speculative investment. Its value is determined by complex interactions between fundamental and speculative components, with episodes of price bifurcation and collapse.

The speculative nature of Bitcoin is driven by investor attention and off-chain activity. This includes the volume of transactions on crypto exchanges, which is often higher than on-chain transfers, and the attention that Bitcoin receives in the media and online. For example, Google searches for Bitcoin and Wikipedia page views are used as proxies for retail investor interest.

The fundamental components of Bitcoin's value are its on-chain activity and economic factors. On-chain activity includes the total number of active addresses and transaction fees, which reflect network usage. Economic factors include the supply of Bitcoins, which is totally inelastic and determined by a protocol, and the price level and supply of money in the wider economy.

The speculative and fundamental components of Bitcoin's value are both influenced by the stock market. For example, the price of Bitcoin often correlates with high-risk assets such as tech stocks, and it can be affected by interest rates and stock market uncertainty.

Bitcoin's value is also influenced by its anonymous nature, which makes it attractive for money laundering, and by its decentralised structure, which means it is not backed by a central bank or government.

Overall, the interplay between the fundamental and speculative components of Bitcoin's value makes it a highly volatile and risky investment.

Bitcoin's status as a safe-haven asset

Bitcoin is a decentralised, fully-fledged monetary network that is not controlled by anyone and has never been hacked. Its design, which resides on an estimated 18,000 nodes worldwide, means that there will only ever be 21 million coins in circulation. This absolute scarcity could be driving renewed interest in Bitcoin.

Bitcoin has outperformed gold and US treasuries, which are considered traditional safe-haven assets, in the past four years. During a volatile period marked by a global pandemic, supply chain bottlenecks, soaring inflation, and aggressive interest rate hikes, Bitcoin's value skyrocketed nearly 1,000%. In contrast, gold has risen by 33% and US treasuries have declined by 12%.

However, Bitcoin's high volatility makes it prone to significant price swings, which can lead to substantial losses during economic uncertainty. Its price often correlates with high-risk assets such as tech stocks, which tend to decline in a recession. During the market turmoil in early August 2024, Bitcoin dropped by 15%, calling into question its status as a safe-haven asset.

Some experts argue that Bitcoin is a risky asset with a positive correlation to stocks, and its price is expected to fall in a recession. It is also considered a speculative investment as it lacks intrinsic value and does not generate income.

In summary, while Bitcoin has shown impressive growth and outperformed traditional safe-haven assets in recent years, its high volatility and correlation with risky assets make its status as a safe-haven asset uncertain.

Bitcoin's potential as a hedge against inflation

Bitcoin has been described as a hedge against inflation, but its effectiveness in this regard is debatable. Here are some key considerations regarding Bitcoin's potential as an inflation hedge:

Scarcity and Fixed Supply

Bitcoin has a fixed supply of 21 million coins by design. This limited supply safeguards Bitcoin from the inflationary pressures that traditional currencies face. Unlike fiat currencies, Bitcoin cannot be diluted through inflation, making it attractive to investors seeking an alternative to central bank-controlled currencies.

Volatility and Market Demand

The value of Bitcoin is primarily driven by market demand and supply, and it is not backed by any tangible asset. As a result, Bitcoin prices can be highly volatile, experiencing significant rises and falls over short periods. This volatility poses a risk for investors, especially those who may need to liquidate their holdings during market downturns.

Regulatory Landscape and Uncertainty

The regulatory environment surrounding cryptocurrencies is still evolving, and legal and regulatory uncertainties exist across different jurisdictions. Government actions, such as restrictions or bans on cryptocurrency use, can impact the value and liquidity of Bitcoin. This regulatory uncertainty adds another layer of risk for investors.

Short Historical Record

Bitcoin has a relatively short history compared to traditional investment vehicles like gold. Its performance over a diverse range of economic scenarios, especially during prolonged inflationary periods, is not yet fully understood. The longevity and stability of Bitcoin in various economic conditions are yet to be tested.

Independence from Government Authorities

Bitcoin's decentralized nature disentangles it from manipulation or control by central banks and governments. This intrinsic freedom provides an additional layer of security for investors concerned about government interventions. During the COVID-19 pandemic, Bitcoin's independence from government authorities was evident, as its prices did not decrease after policy uncertainty shocks.

In conclusion, while Bitcoin has characteristics that make it a potential hedge against inflation, it also comes with risks and complexities. Investors considering Bitcoin as an inflation hedge should approach it as part of a diversified portfolio, incorporating it alongside other asset types to leverage its potential benefits while mitigating associated risks.

Bitcoin's regulatory risks

Bitcoin regulatory risks are an important consideration for investors. There is currently no overarching regulatory framework for Bitcoin, and the regulatory landscape varies across jurisdictions. Some countries have imposed outright bans on cryptocurrencies, while others have partial bans or no regulation at all. This lack of consistent regulation creates uncertainty and potential risks for investors.

One key regulatory risk relates to the potential for increased government intervention and restrictions on Bitcoin. For example, in 2021, China effectively made it illegal for its citizens to mine or hold any cryptocurrency. If other countries were to follow suit, it could significantly impact the value of Bitcoin and the ability of investors to access and utilise their investments.

Another regulatory risk relates to consumer protection. As Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies gain popularity, there is a growing need for robust consumer protection regulations. Theft, fraud, and deceptive advertising are common issues in the crypto market, and only a third of the countries studied by the Atlantic Council had rules in place to protect consumers. The lack of consistent and effective consumer protection regulations creates an uncertain environment for investors, who may be left vulnerable to financial losses without recourse.

Additionally, the decentralised nature of Bitcoin and the lack of central authority or intermediaries make it challenging for regulators to monitor and control. This lack of regulatory oversight can lead to concerns about financial stability, money laundering, terrorism financing, and other illegal activities. Regulatory bodies are still catching up with the rapid evolution of crypto, and the effectiveness of their interventions remains to be seen.

Furthermore, the tax treatment of Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies varies across jurisdictions. In the US, for instance, the Internal Revenue Service has defined Bitcoin as property subject to capital gains tax. The lack of consistent tax regulations across countries can create complexities and risks for investors, particularly those operating across multiple jurisdictions.

Lastly, the regulatory treatment of Bitcoin as a security or a commodity also varies. While the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has ruled that Bitcoin is not a security, it has stated that Bitcoin assets or tokens can be defined as securities and are thus subject to its supervisory authority. This distinction has important implications for investor protection and market regulation.

Frequently asked questions