Leveraged Etfs: Risky Investment Or Smart Strategy?

Leveraged exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are a type of security that uses financial derivatives and debt to amplify the returns of an underlying index or other assets it tracks. While they might seem like a great way to boost your investment returns, there are some important things to consider before investing in them. Leveraged ETFs are designed to provide 2:1 or 3:1 leverage on the daily performance of an index, but this leverage can work in both directions, leading to significant gains or losses. They are considered volatile and are generally only suitable for short-term traders as they are difficult to hold for long-term investments. Additionally, they have higher fees and expense ratios compared to traditional ETFs. Therefore, it is crucial to understand the mechanics of these complex trading instruments before investing and to carefully weigh the potential benefits against the risks.

Leveraged ETFs: The pros

Leveraged exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are a type of security that uses financial derivatives and debt to amplify the returns of an underlying index or other assets. While traditional ETFs track securities on a one-to-one basis, leveraged ETFs aim for a higher ratio, such as 2:1 or 3:1. This means that investors can potentially see significant gains that exceed the tracked index or assets. For example, if the underlying index increases by 1%, a 2:1 leveraged ETF would increase by 2%.

One of the main benefits of leveraged ETFs is that they offer traders the potential to generate outsized returns over short periods of time. For example, if a trader expects the price of oil to increase over a few days or weeks, investing in a leveraged ETF can greatly increase their returns if that prediction is correct. Additionally, if a trader expects a short-term decline in the price of oil, owning shares in an inverse leveraged ETF (which moves in the opposite direction of the underlying index) can provide a hedge against potential losses.

Another advantage of leveraged ETFs is that they mirror the daily returns of an index or asset with minimal tracking errors. This means that investors can be confident that the performance of their investment will closely match the underlying index or asset, at least in the short term. Shares of leveraged ETFs are also traded in the open market like stocks, making them easily accessible to investors.

Leveraged ETFs can be a useful tool for experienced traders who are looking for short-term gains and are comfortable with the associated risks. However, it is important to note that leveraged ETFs are not suitable for long-term investments due to the potential for significant losses and the impact of daily rebalancing.

Leveraged ETFs: The cons

• Amplified risk: Leveraged ETFs are designed to amplify the returns of a benchmark index, but this also means that they amplify the downside risk. A 2x leveraged ETF, for example, may double the daily return of a benchmark index, but it may also double the decline.
• Long-term performance: Leveraged ETFs are designed to amplify daily returns, but this does not translate to the amplification of long-term returns. Due to the compounded effects of leverage, long-term holdings in leveraged ETFs may not reliably mirror index performance.
• High fees: Leveraged ETFs require a higher degree of management than traditional ETFs, and therefore have higher expense ratios. They also have higher fees than non-leveraged ETFs because premiums, fees, and interest need to be paid on the derivatives and for margin costs.
• Not suitable for beginners: Leveraged ETFs are generally not appropriate for beginner investors due to their unique design, benefits, and risks. They are typically used by short-term traders or advanced money managers.
• Underperformance: In some cases, leveraged ETFs may underperform relative to the asset or index they track. This is especially true during periods of volatility.
• Risk of loss: The risk of loss is far higher with leveraged ETFs than with traditional investments. A leveraged ETF can lose most or all of its value.
• Less accurate tracking: Leveraged ETFs are less likely to closely track the underlying index or asset over the long term because they utilize derivatives to boost returns.
• Not suitable for long-term investing: Leveraged ETFs are designed for short-term investments and are not suitable for long-term strategies. The derivatives used for leverage are not long-term investments, and the daily reset means the fund can't build on itself.
• Market volatility: Leveraged ETFs can magnify major swings in the market, increasing overall market volatility.
• Regulatory scrutiny: Due to the risks associated with leveraged ETFs, they are subject to perennial regulatory scrutiny.
• Complex nature: The complex nature of leveraged ETFs, including the impact of daily rebalancing, makes them unsuitable for longer-term investments.

How do leveraged ETFs work?

Leveraged ETFs are a type of security that uses financial derivatives and debt to amplify the returns of an underlying benchmark index. They are designed to provide a higher level of investment exposure, typically aiming for a 2:1 or 3:1 ratio compared to a traditional ETF's 1:1 ratio. This means that for every $1 of investor capital, a leveraged ETF will maintain a $2 or $3 exposure to the index.

The use of derivatives and debt allows leveraged ETFs to magnify the daily returns of the underlying index, stock, or other tracked assets. Derivatives such as futures contracts, index futures, and swap agreements are used to achieve this magnification. For example, if the underlying index increases by 1%, a 2x leveraged ETF would aim to provide a 2% return, and a 3x leveraged ETF would aim for a 3% return.

However, it is important to note that this magnification also works in the opposite direction, leading to magnified losses. If the underlying index decreases by 1%, the leveraged ETF's loss would be exaggerated by the leverage. For example, a 2x leveraged ETF would decrease by 2%, and a 3x leveraged ETF would decrease by 3%.

The constant rebalancing and use of derivatives in leveraged ETFs result in higher costs, which eat into the investors' returns. These funds also have higher fees and expense ratios compared to traditional ETFs due to the costs associated with their operation. As a result, leveraged ETFs are typically used for short-term trading strategies rather than long-term investments.

In summary, leveraged ETFs work by using financial derivatives and debt to amplify the returns of an underlying index or other tracked assets. They aim to provide a higher level of investment exposure and magnify the daily returns, but this also leads to magnified losses. Leveraged ETFs are complex financial instruments with higher costs and are therefore more suitable for experienced traders and short-term trading strategies.

Are leveraged ETFs a good idea?

Leveraged exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are a type of security that uses derivatives and debt to amplify the returns of an underlying index. While they might seem like a great way to boost your investment returns, they are typically only suitable for short-term investments. This is because leveraged ETFs are designed to amplify the daily performance of a target index, and their returns can diverge significantly from simply compounding the underlying index's returns over time.

The main issue with leveraged ETFs is that they are subject to severe price swings due to their use of leverage, which can lead to significant gains but also significant losses. The mathematics of compounding means that leveraged ETFs often fall short of their target returns over longer periods. For example, a triple-leveraged ETF that aims to generate three times the daily performance of the S&P 500 Index may only return around 15% over a five-year period, rather than the expected 25%.

Additionally, leveraged ETFs have much higher expense ratios than average, and they are also less tax-efficient due to the shorter-term nature of their derivative holdings. They are also more complex and unpredictable than traditional ETFs, making them subject to perennial regulatory scrutiny. As a result, brokers such as Ameriprise, Edward Jones, and UBS have stopped offering leveraged ETFs to clients altogether.

However, despite all the disclaimers and risks, leveraged ETFs can still have a place in a portfolio if they are closely monitored. For example, financial planner Lee Munson has recommended inverse Treasury ETFs to some of his clients to hedge against rising interest rates.

In conclusion, whether or not leveraged ETFs are a good idea depends on your risk tolerance and investment goals. If you enjoy trading and can tolerate the increased risk of loss, then leveraged ETFs might be a suitable addition to your portfolio. However, if you are looking for a long-term investment strategy, there are myriad other financial products that are better suited for this purpose.

Leveraged ETFs: Short-term vs long-term

Leveraged ETFs are often touted as a great way to boost investment returns. However, they are generally not suitable for long-term investments.

How Leveraged ETFs Work

Leveraged exchange-traded funds (ETFs) aim to deliver greater returns than traditional ETFs by using financial derivatives and debt to amplify the returns of an underlying benchmark index. While a traditional ETF may track securities on a 1:1 basis, a leveraged ETF may target a higher ratio, such as 2:1 or 3:1. This means that if the underlying index goes up by 2%, a 2x leveraged ETF would aim to go up by 4%.

Short-Term vs Long-Term

The problem with leveraged ETFs is that they are designed to match a certain amount of the daily or monthly return of their underlying index, and this is where things get tricky. If the index goes up by 2% today, a 2x leveraged ETF would go up by 4%. However, if the index goes down by 3% tomorrow, the ETF will go down by 6%. Over time, this daily magnification of losses can eat away at returns, and the mathematics is simply not in the investor's favour.

For example, consider an investor who places $100 in a triple-leveraged fund. If the price of the benchmark index goes up by 5% one day and down by 5% the next, the 3x leveraged fund will go up by 15% and then down by 15%. After these two days of trading, the initial $100 investment will be worth $97.75, representing a loss of 2.25% on an investment that would normally track the benchmark.

This effect is known as the "constant leverage trap" and can lead to significant losses for investors, especially in volatile markets. Additionally, leveraged ETFs have higher fees, which further eat into returns over the long term.

While leveraged ETFs may be useful for short-term trading purposes, they are generally not suitable for long-term investments due to the risk of amplified losses and higher fees.

An Alternative View

Despite the conventional wisdom that leveraged ETFs are unsuitable for long-term investments, some investors argue that they can be profitable over longer time frames if used correctly. The key, they argue, is to buy low and sell high. By progressively buying into the market as it drops, investors can lower their cost basis and then sell when the market recovers, potentially generating large returns.

However, this strategy is not without risk. Leveraged ETFs are highly volatile, and there is a chance of losing a large portion of the investment if the market turns bearish. Additionally, leveraged ETFs may be forced to sell at the worst possible moment during severe downturns, locking in losses.

While some investors may find success with leveraged ETFs over the long term, the general consensus is that they are better suited for short-term trading due to the risks and costs associated with their structure.

Frequently asked questions