Morningstar Five-Star Funds: Worth Your Investment?

Morningstar's five-star rating system is a forward-looking, analyst-driven measure of a stock's current price relative to the analyst's estimate of its fair value. While the system is highly regarded, it is not without its flaws and should not be the only consideration when making investment decisions. The ratings are based on past performance and do not always accurately predict future performance. Additionally, by the time a fund receives a five-star rating, it may be too late for investors to participate in its past performance. Other factors such as expense ratios and fund composition should also be considered when evaluating potential investments.

Morningstar's star rating system

The star rating system was first introduced in 1985 and has since become one of the most influential investment resources in the world. The ratings are calculated at the end of every month and are based on a fund's past performance relative to its peers. To receive a rating, a fund must have a record of more than three years.

While the star rating system is a useful tool for investors, it is important to note that it is not a perfect predictor of future performance. The ratings are based solely on a fund's past performance and do not take into account other factors that may impact future results. Additionally, the star ratings can be sensitive to subjective factors such as the weighting of the mathematical formula and the classification of funds into specific categories.

Despite these limitations, Morningstar's star rating system is widely used and trusted by investors. The system provides a simple and intuitive way to assess and compare the track records of different funds. However, investors should not rely solely on the star ratings when making investment decisions, but rather use them as one of many tools in their evaluation process.

The pros and cons of investing in five-star funds

The Morningstar rating system is a highly regarded and widely used investment research tool that assigns a rating of one to five stars to mutual funds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs). While the system is considered a useful first step in the investment decision-making process, it has its limitations and should not be the sole basis for investment decisions.

Pros of Investing in Five-Star Funds:

• Past Performance and Track Record: Five-star funds have demonstrated superior risk-adjusted returns, placing them in the top 10% of funds within their category. This indicates a strong track record of performance and management capability.
• Analyst Recognition: Morningstar's ratings are analyst-driven, providing an expert opinion on a fund's relative value. Their assessments consider various factors, including past performance, management, fees, and the process used to select holdings.
• Low Fees: Five-star funds often have low expense ratios, indicating that they are competitively priced and may offer better value than similar funds with higher fees.

Cons of Investing in Five-Star Funds:

• Not Predictive of Future Performance: Morningstar acknowledges that its star ratings are based on past performance and are not intended to predict future results accurately. Therefore, investing in a five-star fund does not guarantee continued superior performance.
• Time Lag: By the time a fund receives a five-star rating, it may be too late to fully capitalise on its past performance. Investors relying solely on these ratings may miss out on funds with high growth potential that have not yet been recognised by Morningstar.
• Inflexibility: The Morningstar system is based on a fund's performance relative to its peers within a specific category. This means it may not account for funds with unique strategies or those that do not fit neatly into a particular category.
• Overreliance on Ratings: Investors may place too much emphasis on the simplicity of the star rating system, ignoring other critical factors that should be considered when making investment decisions.

In conclusion, while Morningstar's five-star funds recognise top-performing investments, investors should approach these ratings with caution. It is essential to consider other factors, such as investment goals, risk tolerance, and diversification, when constructing a well-rounded investment portfolio.

The criteria for a five-star rating

The Morningstar Rating, commonly called the star rating, is a forward-looking, analyst-driven measure of a stock's current price relative to the analyst's estimate of its fair value. It is also a quantitative, backward-looking measure of a fund's past performance. The rating is calculated at the end of every month, and funds are rated from one to five stars, with the best performers receiving five stars and the worst performers receiving one star.

The Morningstar Rating for stocks assigns a five-star rating to those trading at the largest discount relative to their fair value estimate and a one-star rating to stocks trading at the largest premium. The rating for funds is based on an enhanced Morningstar Risk-Adjusted Return measure, which accounts for all loads, sales charges, and redemption fees. The risk penalty is determined by the amount of variation in the fund's monthly return, with a greater emphasis on downward variation. The greater the variation, the larger the penalty.

Funds are rated for up to three periods: the trailing three, five, and 10 years. For funds that remain in the same Morningstar Category for the entire evaluation period, the following weights are used to calculate an overall rating:

• For funds older than three years but younger than five, 100% weight is given to the three-year rating.
• For funds older than five years but younger than 10, 60% weight is given to the five-year rating, and 40% to the three-year rating.
• For funds older than 10 years, 50% weight is given to the 10-year rating, 30% to the five-year rating, and 20% to the three-year rating.

The Morningstar star rating is best used as an initial screen to identify funds worthy of further research. It is a quantitative measure, and a high rating does not imply the approval or endorsement of a fund by a Morningstar analyst. It is important to note that the rating is based on the fund's historical performance, and the portfolio manager responsible for that performance may no longer be managing the fund. Additionally, not all five-star funds are equal or interchangeable, as a five-star sector fund is likely far riskier than a highly-rated diversified fund.

The performance of five-star funds over time

Morningstar's star rating system is a forward-looking, analyst-driven measure of a stock's current price relative to the analyst's estimate of its fair value. The system ranges from 1 star (lowest quality) to 5 stars (highest quality), with the top 10% of funds receiving five stars.

While Morningstar is highly regarded for its investment research, its ratings are not always accurate predictors of fund performance. A study by Vanguard found that Morningstar's ratings were not a good method to predict performance when measured against a benchmark. Morningstar itself also acknowledges that its rating system is a quantitative measure of a fund's past performance and is not intended to predict future performance.

A study by Russel Kinnel, director of manager research at Morningstar, found that 5-star mutual funds beat 1-star funds in terms of total returns, although there were exceptions. Kinnel's data suggests that a higher-star fund beats a lower-star fund approximately 84% of the time.

It is important to note that the Morningstar star ratings are based on past performances relative to similar funds and do not account for outliers or leadership changes. As such, investors should not rely solely on the star ratings when making investment decisions but should consider other factors such as expense ratios and fund benchmarks.

Alternative investment strategies

While Morningstar's five-star rating system is a highly regarded tool for evaluating mutual funds and ETFs, it is not the only factor to consider when making investment decisions. Here are some alternative investment strategies to consider:

• Consider a broader range of ratings: Instead of focusing solely on five-star funds, investors can broaden their search to include funds with lower ratings. This approach can provide a more comprehensive view of the investment landscape and potentially identify funds with strong performance that may have been overlooked.
• Look beyond past performance: Morningstar's star ratings are based primarily on past performance, which may not always be indicative of future results. It is important to also consider other factors such as the fund's investment strategy, management team, and risk-adjusted returns.
• Compare funds within the same category: When evaluating funds, it is crucial to compare them to their peers within the same investment category. This allows for a more apples-to-apples comparison, as funds in different categories may have different risk and return profiles.
• Focus on low-cost funds: Research has shown that expense ratios can be a better predictor of future performance than star ratings. Consider prioritizing funds with lower expense ratios, as these tend to outperform their high-cost counterparts over time.
• Utilize index funds: Index funds are passive investments that aim to replicate the performance of a specific market index. They tend to have lower costs than actively managed funds and can provide broad market exposure. Morningstar's Medalist Rating system can help identify top-performing index funds.
• Diversify your portfolio: Diversification is a key principle of investing. Instead of investing solely in five-star funds, consider spreading your investments across a variety of asset classes, sectors, and investment strategies to reduce risk and improve long-term returns.
• Conduct thorough due diligence: Morningstar's ratings are a useful starting point, but it is important to conduct your own research and due diligence before investing. Read fund prospectuses, analyst reports, and consider seeking advice from financial professionals to make informed investment decisions.
• Monitor and rebalance your portfolio: Regularly review and rebalance your portfolio to ensure it aligns with your investment goals and risk tolerance. Stay informed about market trends and be prepared to make adjustments as needed to adapt to changing market conditions.
• Consider tax implications: Be mindful of the tax implications of your investment decisions. Some investment strategies, such as buying and holding index funds, can be more tax-efficient than frequently trading individual stocks.
• Invest for the long term: Investing is a long-term endeavour. Avoid making impulsive decisions based solely on short-term market fluctuations. Focus on your long-term investment goals and maintain a disciplined approach to investing.

Frequently asked questions