Roth Retirement Funds For Angel Investing: Risks And Rewards

Angel investors are individuals who provide seed money to startups in exchange for an equity stake in the company if the idea is successful. They are often the lifeblood of early-stage and startup businesses, providing much-needed capital, strategic insight, guidance, and expertise. The importance of their financial stimulus cannot be overstated, with estimates suggesting they provide up to 90% of outside equity for startups. Angel investing is a risky endeavour, as there is no guarantee that a startup will succeed, and it can take an average of seven years to see a return on investment. However, it can also be extremely lucrative, with an average return on investment of 2.7x for companies that were still operating when the investor exited the partnership in 2021. So, should you use your Roth to angel invest? Well, that depends on your personal financial situation and your risk tolerance. Angel investing through a Roth IRA can offer tax advantages, but it's important to carefully consider the risks and potential complications before making any decisions.

Tax efficiency

Angel investing through a self-directed IRA can offer tax benefits. Firstly, angels can invest using pre-tax dollars from their retirement accounts and avoid paying capital gains taxes, which typically range from 15% to 20%. If the investment is successful, they may either pay no taxes on their investment (with a Roth IRA) or defer taxes until retirement age (with a traditional IRA). This means that any gains made in IRAs have favourable tax treatments.

For example, PayPal co-founder Max Levchin reportedly invested in Yelp through his Roth IRA. His investment was worth tens of millions, and the gains remained tax-free.

Additionally, by putting retirement dollars into pre-tax angel investments, investors preserve on-hand liquidity. This allows investors to save their ready cash for other uses and easily expand their angel investments if the companies are successful.

However, it is important to note that there may be some complexities and restrictions when using a self-directed IRA for angel investing. For instance, there may be rules against self-dealing, limiting the investor's ability to be a key employee of the company or own more than 50% of the company's equity. Furthermore, there may be administrative considerations, such as tracking investments and dealing with tax implications, which can be more complex for IRA investments.

Risk and reward

Angel investing is a high-risk, hands-on form of investing, where investors provide capital to startups in exchange for an equity stake. The risk comes from the high startup failure rate, illiquidity, and long exit timelines. However, angel investing also has the potential for substantial returns and tax incentives.

Angel investing is suitable only for those with stable income streams and minimum investable assets of $1 million–$2 million. It is recommended that investors have at least six months of living expenses saved up and that potential investment amounts fit within 5–15% of their liquid net worth.

When deciding whether to use a Roth IRA for angel investing, it is important to consider the level of risk involved. If the funds in your Roth IRA are critical to your retirement and you cannot afford to lose them, you should not use them for angel investing. On the other hand, if the funds are more discretionary and you are willing to take on higher-risk, higher-reward investments, then using your Roth IRA for angel investing may be an option.

One advantage of using a Roth IRA for angel investing is the favourable tax treatment on gains. In a traditional IRA, gains are tax-free when they happen, but you pay ordinary income tax upon withdrawals. In a Roth IRA, the gains are entirely tax-free. Additionally, if you make a capital gain on an angel deal outside an IRA, it may be taxable, whereas in a Roth IRA, it would not be.

However, there are also some disadvantages to consider. Angel investments are hard to sell and turn back into cash, which can be problematic if you need to make required minimum distributions (RMDs) from your IRA. Additionally, distributing shares at "market value" can be complicated, as the value of early-stage startups is hard to judge.

Overall, using a Roth IRA for angel investing can be a viable option for those with sufficient financial resources and a high-risk tolerance. However, it is important to carefully consider the risks and rewards involved before making any investment decisions.

Long-term commitment

Angel investing is a long-term commitment. The average hold time for angel investments in startups is about seven years, and this horizon can be much longer. Mid-career professionals and younger investors are well-suited to angel investing because they can afford to wait out the long hold times.

Angel investing is also a risky endeavour. There is no guarantee that a startup or early-stage business will be successful, and 50% of startups fail in the first five years. Therefore, angels should only use a relatively modest percentage of their total retirement net worth for angel investing.

Angel investors are often the lifeblood of early-stage and startup businesses. They provide much-needed capital and strategic insight, guidance, and expertise for new businesses. The Angel Capital Association estimates that angel investors provide as much as 90% of outside equity for startups, with individual investments averaging between $10,000 and $25,000.

Angel investors can unlock the investment power of their retirement dollars using a self-directed solo 401(k) or self-directed IRA. These accounts offer significant tax savings for angel investments. For example, angels can invest using pre-tax dollars from their retirement accounts and avoid paying capital gains taxes, which range from 15 to 20%. If the business is successful, angels either pay no taxes on their investment if they use a Roth IRA as the investment vehicle or defer taxes until retirement age with a traditional IRA.

Angel investing with retirement funds also preserves on-hand liquidity. Angels can save the ready cash in their after-tax accounts for other uses and easily grow the scope of their angel investments if companies are successful.

Liquidity

The illiquid nature of angel investing can pose a problem if you need to access your money in the event of an emergency or other unexpected expenses. It is important to remember that once you invest in a startup, you may not be able to get your money back unless there is a sale or initial public offering (IPO). Even then, there is no guarantee that you will get your initial investment back, let alone make a profit.

To mitigate the risk of illiquidity, it is crucial to ensure that you only invest money that you can afford to lose and that you do not need in the near future. Diversification can also help reduce the risk of illiquidity by spreading your investments across multiple startups in different industries. This way, if one investment does not work out, you may still have the potential to offset losses with gains from other investments.

Another strategy to consider is investing through an angel group or syndicate, which allows you to pool your money with other investors to fund a particular deal. This can provide access to a wider range of investment opportunities and help spread the risk across a larger number of investors. Additionally, working with a professional angel investor network or venture capital firm can improve your chances of finding more liquid investments with better exit opportunities.

Finally, it is worth noting that there are alternative investment structures, such as "structured exits," that are designed to provide investors with more liquidity. These structures allow investors to start getting back their investment fairly quickly and often involve getting a return based on the income portfolio of the companies they invest in. While these structures may not offer the same level of potential upside as traditional angel investments, they can provide a measure of protection against the risk of illiquidity.

Retirement funds

The benefit of using retirement funds for angel investing is the tax efficiency gained by investing through a Traditional or Roth IRA. In a Traditional IRA, you avoid paying capital gains tax, which ranges from 15-20%, and pay ordinary income tax upon withdrawals. In a Roth IRA, the gains are entirely tax-free.

When deciding whether to use retirement funds for angel investing, it is important to consider the liquidity of your other assets. Angel investments are typically hard to sell and turn back into cash, so if you have a long-term horizon for your retirement funds, they can be a good fit for angel investing.

Additionally, it is crucial to remember that angel investing through a retirement account should be viewed as a long-term commitment, with average hold times for angel investments in startups being about seven years, and oftentimes longer.

Furthermore, there are administrative considerations when using retirement funds for angel investing, such as tracking investments and dealing with tax implications. There may also be fees charged by the IRA custodian, which can add up if you are making a large number of small investments.

In conclusion, using retirement funds for angel investing can be a great way to support early-stage startups while also gaining tax benefits. However, it is important to carefully weigh the risks and ensure that you have the appropriate investment horizon and liquidity in place.

Frequently asked questions