Investing In India: A Guide For Nris In America

Indians living in America may want to invest in India for a variety of reasons, including emotional attachment to their country of birth, or because they see India as an attractive destination for investments. However, it is important to consider the risks involved and to have a diversified portfolio. In this paragraph, we will explore the benefits and drawbacks of Indians living in America investing in India and provide an overview of the different investment options available. We will also discuss the impact of factors such as bank interest rates, regulatory policies, and currency conversion on investment decisions. Finally, we will offer guidance on how to navigate the regulatory and compliance landscape when investing across borders.

Investing in India: Pros and Cons

Pros

India has the potential to offer great returns over the next few decades. Here are some reasons why Indians living in America might consider investing in India:

• India is a developing market with a lot more scope for growth than more mature markets.
• You will be more familiar with political and economic risks and may find ways to mitigate those risks.
• Bank interest rates in India can be as high as 8%.
• Regulatory policies in India are less likely to be missed as you will be more cued into regulatory changes.
• It is easier to liquidate your funds if you've invested in the Indian stock market.

Cons

However, there are also some drawbacks to investing in India. Here are some reasons why Indians living in America might choose not to invest in India:

• The US market has historically outperformed the Indian stock market.
• The greater risk in investing in India comes from political and economic factors like the reform process, currency risk, etc.
• There are tax and regulatory aspects to take into account when investing in India, which can be cumbersome.
• You may not be able to invest in Indian mutual funds as per SEC rules.
• Converting currency from INR to USD and then back will not be free of cost.

Regulatory policies

One key regulatory difference is that the US market is heavily regulated and prioritises American citizens over international investors. This means that Indians investing in the US may face additional hurdles and may not have the same access to information as they would when investing in India. On the other hand, the Indian market, as a developing market, has more scope for growth than the more mature American market. This can be a deciding factor for investors.

Another regulatory consideration is the need to comply with the laws and regulations of two countries. Indians investing in the US will need to navigate the regulatory and compliance procedures of both India and the US. This includes reporting requirements, such as the need to report global income, including dividends, interest, and capital gains, on US tax returns. Additionally, there may be restrictions on the types of investments that can be made, and on the number of trades that can be conducted.

The Liberalized Remittance Scheme (LRS) in India allows Indian residents to invest up to $250,000 per financial year (April to March) in overseas investments, including overseas direct investment (ODI) and overseas portfolio investments (OPI). This limit also covers other purposes such as private visits outside India, gifts or donations, maintenance of relatives abroad, medical treatment, and education. It is important to be mindful of these restrictions and plan investments accordingly.

Furthermore, the process of investing in US stocks from India can be complex and may involve higher costs. Investing directly in US stocks may require opening an overseas trading account with a domestic or foreign broker, which can incur additional charges. Additionally, there may be brokerage and currency conversion fees associated with buying and selling US stocks.

In summary, Indians living in America who are considering investing in India need to be aware of the regulatory differences between the two countries. The US market is heavily regulated and may not provide the same level of access to information as the Indian market. Additionally, investing across borders comes with compliance procedures and potential restrictions. It is important to carefully consider these regulatory policies and seek expert advice before making any investment decisions.

Currency conversion

When investing in India, it is crucial to consider the potential risks associated with currency fluctuations. If the rupee depreciates against the dollar, the value of investments in India may decrease when converted back to dollars. Therefore, it is advisable to diversify your investment portfolio and not allocate all your investments in India. Financial experts recommend that Indian Americans maintain a well-diversified portfolio that includes a mix of developed international markets, emerging markets, and even some frontier markets if risk tolerance allows.

One way to mitigate currency risk is to invest in India through US-based funds, such as Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs). These funds are managed by professionals who hedge currency risks, providing some protection against fluctuations in the USD-INR exchange rate. US-based ETFs allow Indian Americans to participate in the growth of Indian companies while avoiding the complexities of regulatory and compliance processes in India.

Additionally, when investing in India, it is essential to consider the tax implications in both countries. Indian Americans must report their global income, including dividends, interest, and capital gains, on their US tax returns. They may need to pay taxes in India and then claim a tax credit in the US, which can be a cumbersome process. Understanding the regulatory and compliance procedures in both countries is crucial before making any investments.

In conclusion, currency conversion and exchange rates play a significant role in financial planning for Indians living in America who are considering investing in India. By diversifying their portfolios, considering US-based investment options, and staying informed about currency fluctuations, Indian Americans can make more informed decisions about their investments in India.

Growth potential

India has the potential to offer great returns over the next few decades. The country is a growth story, with a broad-based and multi-sectoral economic partnership with the US. The two nations have strong bilateral cooperation in trade and investment, defence and security, education, science and technology, pharmaceuticals and biotechnology, civil nuclear energy, environment, clean energy, space technology and applications, health, and research and development.

The US is the third-largest investor in India, with FDI investments of $66.7 billion from April 2000 to June 2024. Bilateral trade exceeded $190 billion in 2023, and India-US have an ambitious target of achieving bilateral trade worth $500 billion by 2025. The US is India's largest export destination, and India is the US's 9th largest trading partner.

The Indian-American community in the US is an important ethnic group, with a large number of professionals, business entrepreneurs, and educationalists with increasing influence in society. Roughly, one-third of all immigrant-focused startups in the US have Indian founders, and 2% of Fortune 500 Companies, including Microsoft and Alphabet, are led by Indian Americans. Indian Americans have founded ~8% of high-technology US firms and 15% of Silicon Valley startups.

The Indian stock market has been growing steadily over the past two decades, emerging as a marketplace for high-growth Indian companies that can deliver potentially lucrative returns over 3-5 years. There are 5000+ stocks on the Indian market, a mix of iconic companies, reliable organizations, and budding companies that are aiming to be future world leaders.

India being a developing market has a lot more scope for growth than more mature markets. This can be a deciding factor for investors who already have funds abroad as well.

Liquidity

The US stock market is known for its liquidity, providing ample opportunities for buying and selling shares with ease. This liquidity, combined with the strong historical performance of the US market, makes it an attractive option for investors seeking growth potential.

However, the Indian stock market also offers liquidity, and it is easy to liquidate funds whenever required. The Indian market is also less regulated, which can make it easier to buy and sell shares.

When investing in India, it is important to consider the different types of accounts and investment vehicles available to NRIs. NRE and FCNR accounts, for example, allow NRIs to keep their foreign savings or earnings in Indian rupees or other foreign currencies, respectively. These accounts offer varying levels of liquidity and are subject to different tax and regulatory requirements.

Additionally, when investing in the Indian market, it is essential to be aware of any restrictions and compliance procedures. For instance, Indian investors are subject to annual remittance limits set by the Reserve Bank of India. There are also different tax regulations and requirements in India and the US, which can be complex and time-consuming to navigate.

In terms of liquidity, both the US and Indian markets have their advantages. The US market offers greater liquidity and is more regulated, while the Indian market is less liquid but provides opportunities for higher returns and is less regulated.

Ultimately, when deciding where to invest, it is crucial to consider your investment goals, risk tolerance, and the level of liquidity you require. It may be beneficial to consult a financial advisor to determine the best course of action for your specific circumstances.

Frequently asked questions