Starbucks: Worth Your Investment?

Starbucks is one of the most recognisable coffee brands in the world, with over 36,000 locations across the globe. The company has experienced impressive growth since its founding in 1971, and its stock has skyrocketed since its initial public offering in 1992. However, there are several risks and uncertainties facing Starbucks that potential investors should be aware of. These include competition from low-cost providers and beverage giants, commodity price fluctuations, market saturation, and performance in emerging markets. While Starbucks has a strong track record of success, investors need to carefully consider these factors before deciding whether to invest in the company.

Starbucks' international expansion

Starbucks' first overseas venture was in Japan in 1996. Since then, it has expanded to over 34 countries, with a presence in Europe, Asia, and Latin America. The company has applied flexible entry strategies, including licensing, joint ventures, and whole ownership. In the fiscal year 2009, Starbucks opened 3,439 licensed cafes worldwide, representing 62% of its total stores. The company also operates some overseas stores directly, acquiring local coffee retailers. In the UK, Canada, Thailand, and Singapore, Starbucks owns 2,068 wholly-owned cafes, which account for 38% of its overseas stores.

Starbucks' expansion strategy is driven by several factors. One key reason is the company's desire to spread coffee culture and deliver a fine coffee experience, including high-quality coffee and elegant branding. By having direct investments and control over operations, Starbucks can effectively manage its core competencies, such as employee training and store management. Additionally, joint ventures with local retailers have helped Starbucks minimise risks, gain local market knowledge, and overcome cultural gaps in Asian countries, which are a primary target for their international expansion.

However, Starbucks' international expansion has also faced challenges and setbacks. In Australia, for example, the company faced strong competition from entrenched local cafe cultures and franchise players, leading to heavy losses and store closures. Similarly, in India, Starbucks faced regulatory hurdles and resistance from the government, delaying its entry into the market.

Despite these challenges, Starbucks continues to focus on international expansion, particularly in China. The company believes that international markets offer higher profit margins due to lower operating expenses compared to US stores. Additionally, international markets, particularly China, are recovering faster from the coronavirus pandemic, providing further incentive for Starbucks' global growth strategy.

Competition from other coffee shops and beverage companies

Starbucks is the leading company in the coffee industry, with $29.1 billion in annual sales in 2021. However, it faces competition from various other coffee shops and beverage companies.

McDonald's

McDonald's is a significant competitor to Starbucks, particularly with its McCafé line of coffee-related products. With 40,031 restaurants worldwide in over 100 countries, McDonald's has a much larger customer base and significantly greater financial resources than Starbucks. The company can devote more money to marketing campaigns and product development and research, and it can also offer better deals than Starbucks. McDonald's offers a wide variety of options, including burgers, fries, and breakfast food items, and it stands as a strong competitor to Starbucks in the breakfast and coffee market. In 2021, McDonald's reported revenue of $23.223 billion, a 20.9% increase from the previous year.

Dunkin' Donuts

Dunkin' Donuts is another major competitor to Starbucks, with over 11,500 restaurants worldwide and more than 8,500 locations in the United States alone. The company offers a diverse menu that includes breakfast sandwiches, frozen beverages, donuts, and coffee products. Dunkin' Donuts provides a more cost-effective option for coffee lovers compared to Starbucks, with a pricing strategy that focuses on the middle class. The company is now privately held, and in the fiscal year 2020, its revenue stood at $1.25 billion, a decline from the previous year's figure of $1.31 billion.

Tim Hortons

Tim Hortons is a significant competitor to Starbucks, particularly in Canada, where it enjoys iconic status. With nearly 5,000 quick-service restaurants located across 14 countries, Tim Hortons offers coffee, donuts, muffins, cookies, pastries, bagels, and Greek yogurt mixed with berries. One key advantage for consumers when choosing Tim Hortons over Starbucks is affordability. A small cup of Caffe Latte at Tim Hortons costs $2.49, while Starbucks charges $2.95.

Independent Coffee Shops

Independent coffee shops have also gained popularity as competitors to Starbucks. These smaller businesses offer unique blends of coffee and a more personal service experience. Customers appreciate feeling special and valued when they visit a local café, and these independent shops benefit from word-of-mouth recommendations based on positive experiences. The number of independent coffee shops has skyrocketed in recent years, particularly in urban areas like London, where there was an 800% growth from 50 outlets in 2010 to over 400 in 2020.

Other Competitors

Other notable competitors to Starbucks include Folgers, Maxwell House, Peet's Coffee, Lavazza, Costa Coffee, and The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf. These companies offer a range of coffee products and unique blends, providing alternatives to Starbucks' products and services.

Commodity price fluctuations

Starbucks is vulnerable to commodity price fluctuations, particularly the prices of coffee beans, sugar, and milk. The company spends a large amount of money on these commodities, and if prices were to skyrocket, it could negatively impact their bottom line. However, Starbucks uses derivative contracts as a safeguard against commodity price spikes, and there is evidence that these measures are beneficial for their bottom line. For example, despite surging coffee prices in 2021, Starbucks did not increase the prices of its drinks. This was due to their purchasing strategy, which includes buying coffee ahead of time and locking in prices.

In addition to coffee beans, Starbucks is also susceptible to price fluctuations in other commodities such as sugar and milk. These commodities are essential for Starbucks' beverage offerings, and any significant changes in their prices could impact the company's costs and profitability. However, it is worth noting that Starbucks has demonstrated its ability to mitigate the impact of commodity price fluctuations through various strategies, such as derivative contracts and proactive purchasing decisions.

The company's vulnerability to commodity price fluctuations is a crucial consideration for investors. While Starbucks has implemented measures to manage this risk, the impact of changing commodity prices on their financial performance is a factor that investors should monitor. This is especially true for those considering investing in Starbucks, as commodity prices can directly affect the company's profitability and stock performance.

Furthermore, commodity price fluctuations can also impact Starbucks' competitive landscape. When commodity prices rise, it can create pressure across the industry, causing companies to adjust their pricing strategies. In such situations, Starbucks' ability to maintain stable prices can be a competitive advantage, as it did in 2021 when coffee prices surged. However, if competitors find alternative ways to manage their costs or choose to absorb higher commodity prices without passing them on to consumers, Starbucks may face challenges in maintaining its market position.

Overall, while Starbucks is vulnerable to commodity price fluctuations, the company has demonstrated its ability to mitigate this risk through various strategies. Investors should carefully consider this factor, as it can impact the company's financial performance and competitive position in the market. Monitoring Starbucks' ability to adapt to changing commodity prices and assessing the effectiveness of their risk management strategies are crucial aspects of evaluating the investment potential in the company.

The impact of macroeconomic factors

Starbucks, as the world's biggest coffeehouse chain, is susceptible to various macroeconomic factors that can influence its business and impact investment prospects. These factors, analysed through frameworks such as PESTEL, encompass political, economic, social, technological, environmental, and legal considerations.

Political factors present both opportunities and challenges for Starbucks. The integration of regional markets through single-market and free-trade policies facilitates expansion into new territories. Conversely, the disintegration of markets and bureaucratic red tape in developing countries can impede growth and favour local competitors. Political stability, the risk of military invasion, the level of corruption, and the extent of government intervention are additional considerations.

Economic factors have a significant impact on Starbucks' operations and investment attractiveness. The ongoing global economic recession has hurt consumer purchasing power, leading to a shift towards cheaper alternatives. However, Starbucks has the opportunity to adapt by offering more affordable products to retain and expand its customer base. Other economic factors include inflation, rising labour and operational costs, exchange rates, and the economic cycle.

Social and cultural factors play a crucial role in shaping Starbucks' marketing strategies. The company must consider the demographics, class structure, and cultural norms of its target markets. The growing coffee culture and middle class present expansion opportunities, while the rise of independent coffeehouse movements poses a threat to multinational chains like Starbucks. Additionally, consumers are increasingly conscious of ethical and environmental considerations, which can influence their brand preferences.

Technological factors offer Starbucks significant opportunities to enhance its operations and customer experience. The company has already embraced the mobile revolution by partnering with Apple and introducing discount coupons via iPhone apps. The introduction of Wi-Fi and mobile payment options further strengthens its position.

Environmental factors, including the availability of sustainable practices and responsibly sourced materials, provide Starbucks with opportunities to enhance its brand image and attract environmentally conscious consumers.

Legal factors, such as product safety regulations, employment laws, and trade regulations, must be carefully navigated by Starbucks to ensure compliance and maintain its social license to operate.

Overall, a holistic understanding of these macroeconomic factors and their potential impact on Starbucks' business is essential for informed investment decision-making.

The company's customer service culture

Starbucks has established itself as a company that celebrates coffee and connection, with a focus on creating a neighbourhood gathering place and being a part of its customers' daily routines. The company refers to its employees as "partners" to emphasise that they are all partners in shared success. Starbucks aims to deliver performance through the lens of humanity, with a commitment to the highest-quality coffee and responsible business practices.

Starbucks' customer service culture is centred around creating a unique and memorable experience for each customer. The company empowers its employees to add their personal touch and make decisions about what is right for the customer. This approach allows for the creation of emotional connections with customers, leading to long-term relationships and brand loyalty. For example, in one instance, a Starbucks employee in Geneva wrote "Wayne" on the cup of a customer named Wei, as the name was unfamiliar to the employee. When Wei corrected the spelling, the employee used their inspiration from Wei's well-groomed, dark suit to write "Bruce Wayne" on the next cup, linking it to the DC Comics character Batman. This complicit smile and unique experience led to a memorable connection between the customer and the brand.

Starbucks focuses on nurturing human connections and creating a people-centred approach. The company prioritises treating its employees and customers as human beings, fostering a partnership between them. This people-centred approach extends to the physical aspects of the customer experience, such as the cardboard cup, which may not be seen as a vehicle for excellence but aligns with the brand's promise of a unique and personalised experience.

Starbucks also emphasises the importance of inclusion, diversity, equity, and accessibility in its customer service culture. The company actively hires individuals with disabilities and provides reasonable accommodations and assistive technologies to enable them to do their jobs effectively. Starbucks aims to create an inspirational journey for its customers and employees, treating everyone warmly, with transparency, dignity, and respect.

Overall, Starbucks' customer service culture is centred around creating unique, emotional, and memorable experiences for its customers, empowering its employees to make decisions, and fostering human connections and partnerships. The company's focus on people and its commitment to inclusion and diversity contribute to its success and positive brand image.

Frequently asked questions