Cryptocurrency Or Stocks: Where Should You Invest?

Cryptocurrency and stocks are both valid investment options, but they have different characteristics and serve distinct purposes in an investment portfolio. Cryptocurrency, often referred to as crypto, is a decentralised, digital currency based on cryptography. On the other hand, stocks represent ownership in a company and are traded on stock exchanges. The key differences between investing in cryptocurrency versus stocks lie in their volatility, regulation, security, and diversification options. Cryptocurrency is generally considered more volatile, with rapid price fluctuations, while stocks offer more stable and consistent returns. The crypto market is largely unregulated, which adds to the risk, whereas stock markets are subject to governmental oversight and investor protections. In terms of security, both stocks and cryptocurrencies are vulnerable to scams and cyber-attacks, but the decentralised nature of crypto places more responsibility on investors for safeguarding their assets and passwords. When it comes to diversification, stocks offer a wider range of options across sectors and countries, while the crypto market has a more limited selection. Ultimately, the decision to invest in crypto or stocks depends on an individual's risk tolerance, financial goals, and investment horizon.

Volatility: Crypto is newer and more volatile than stocks, which generally offer more stable returns

Volatility is a key differentiator between crypto and stocks. Cryptocurrency is a newer asset class and is more volatile than stocks, which generally offer more stable returns.

The value of a cryptocurrency is based on supply and demand. Crypto prices are known for their volatility, which carries the risk of significant losses or the potential for significant gains. The uncertainty about the future value of cryptocurrencies and the fact that they are often not backed by physical assets means that they are usually considered more volatile than stocks.

Stocks, on the other hand, represent ownership of a business, and stock investors can base their investment decisions on business results, cash reserves, growth prospects, and more. Stocks have generally offered more stable and consistent returns over the long term, although short-term fluctuations can still occur.

The high volatility of cryptocurrencies means that they are more suitable for investors with a higher risk tolerance, while stocks are generally a safer option for those seeking more stable returns.

Regulation: Stocks are subject to governmental oversight, while the crypto market is decentralised and unregulated

Regulation

The stock market is highly regulated by government bodies, whereas the crypto market is decentralised and unregulated.

The US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is the top regulatory agency responsible for overseeing the securities industry. It registers new securities and handles all the filings that public companies must make, such as annual and quarterly reports. The SEC also has a robust anti-fraud unit that monitors advertising and marketing to ensure companies comply with strict securities sales rules.

The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) is an independent organisation that creates and enforces rules for brokers, broker-dealer firms, and funding portals. It sets standards for stockbrokers and other industry professionals, licensing them after comprehensive examinations. FINRA can also revoke licenses and levy individuals and organisations for unethical behaviour.

The stock market is also regulated by individual state governments, which have securities divisions that respond to complaints and register securities sold within the state.

In contrast, the crypto market is decentralised and unregulated. However, as cryptocurrency usage increases, so do the number of cryptocurrency regulations around the world. The US, for example, has made strides in developing federal cryptocurrency legislation. The Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) considers cryptocurrency exchanges to be money transmitters and has issued guidelines for crypto exchanges to comply with. The US Treasury has also emphasised the urgent need for crypto regulations to combat global and domestic criminal activities.

While the crypto market is decentralised and lacks the same level of regulation as the stock market, it is not entirely without rules and oversight.

Scams and Security Risks: Both are vulnerable to scams, but the evolving and unregulated nature of crypto makes it a hotbed for scams

While both stocks and cryptocurrencies are vulnerable to scams, the unregulated nature of crypto makes it particularly susceptible to fraudulent activity.

Cryptocurrency scams take many forms, including fake initial coin offerings (ICOs), pump-and-dump schemes, fraudulent exchanges, and "rug pulls". In a pump-and-dump scheme, scammers promote ("pump") a stock or other asset to inflate its price, then sell off ("dump") their own shares, leaving victims with worthless assets. A "rug pull" occurs when scammers raise funds for a project, then suddenly remove all the liquidity and disappear. Cryptocurrency scams often aim to gain access to a target's digital wallet or authentication credentials, or to trick people into sending cryptocurrency to a compromised digital wallet.

Phishing scams are another common type of cryptocurrency fraud. In these scams, scammers send emails with malicious links to a fake website to gather sensitive information such as wallet key details. Scammers may also impersonate celebrities, businesspeople, or cryptocurrency influencers, promising to match or multiply any cryptocurrency sent to them.

Romance scams are also prevalent in the cryptocurrency space. Scammers use dating websites to make individuals believe they are in a real relationship, then convince them to transfer funds or account authentication credentials.

Cryptocurrency's lack of government backing and its decentralised nature make it a more attractive target for scammers than stocks. The relative newness of crypto also contributes to its vulnerability, as investors may be less knowledgeable about potential scams and the steps needed to avoid them.

However, it is important to note that scams targeting stock investors also exist. For example, securities fraud, which involves deceiving investors into making purchase or sale decisions based on false information, is a well-known issue in the stock market. This can include stock manipulation, misstatements on financial reports, and insider trading.

To protect themselves, investors in both stocks and cryptocurrencies should be vigilant for signs of potential scams, such as guarantees of low-risk investments, a sense of urgency or ambiguity, and unsolicited offers. Conducting thorough research and due diligence is essential before investing in any opportunity.

Diversification: Stocks offer a wider range of sectors and countries to invest in, reducing risk

Diversification is a key consideration when weighing up whether to invest in stocks or cryptocurrency. Stocks offer a wider range of sectors and countries to invest in, which can help to reduce risk.

Stocks have been the go-to investment for building wealth for individuals and organisations for much of the 20th and 21st centuries. They are traded on accredited exchanges worldwide and offer security, stability, and transparency. Exchanges for buying and selling cryptocurrency are newer and largely unregulated.

With stocks, investors can select from companies in almost every sector and country in the world. This enables investors to put together a highly diverse portfolio that isn't dependent on particular industries or geographical markets. This diversification can help to reduce the risk of losing everything.

While there are thousands of cryptocurrencies, and more are being created all the time, there are fewer options to diversify a crypto portfolio. While investors can reduce risk by ensuring they don't put all their money into one type of cryptocurrency, there is no easy way to fully diversify crypto investments. This leaves investors in a riskier position if they put all their money into one or a handful of cryptocurrencies.

Timeline: Crypto's price fluctuations might help you make money faster, but can also lead to short-term losses

Cryptocurrency is a highly volatile asset class. Its prices fluctuate drastically in short periods, presenting investors with opportunities to make quick gains but also putting them at risk of substantial losses.

The Volatile Nature of Cryptocurrencies

Cryptocurrency prices can be extremely volatile due to their speculative nature. Various factors influence their value, including media hype, investor sentiment, government regulations, and the actions of "whales" (large investors). For example, in 2021, the value of a single Bitcoin ranged from $28,383 to over $65,000.

The Impact of "Whales"

"Whales" are investors with substantial cryptocurrency holdings who can significantly impact the market. They may employ strategies like rinse and repeat trading, where they sell large amounts at below-market rates, causing panic among small traders, and then buy more when prices drop.

Regulatory and Media Influence

Cryptocurrency prices are also susceptible to regulatory changes and media coverage. For instance, China's ban on cryptocurrency transactions in 2021 negatively affected prices. On the other hand, positive media coverage, such as the announcement of a Bitcoin-related exchange-traded fund (ETF) in 2021, caused a surge in Bitcoin's value.

The Role of Supply and Demand

Like any commodity, the price of cryptocurrencies is heavily influenced by supply and demand. Bitcoin, for example, has a limited supply of 21 million coins, and as the circulating supply approaches this limit, prices are expected to climb higher.

The Impact of Adoption and Use Cases

The more cryptocurrencies are adopted and used, the higher their value tends to go. For instance, Ethereum's value is linked to its role in executing transactions and developing applications on its blockchain, so increased usage leads to higher demand and, consequently, higher prices.

Weighing the Risks and Rewards

While cryptocurrencies offer the potential for large, quick gains, they also come with significant risks. Their extreme volatility means fortunes can be made or lost rapidly. Additionally, they lack the intrinsic value of stocks, which are backed by a company's assets and earnings.

Managing Your Portfolio

When incorporating cryptocurrencies into your investment portfolio, it's generally recommended to allocate a small percentage (around 5% or less) due to their volatility. This way, you can benefit from potential gains without putting your entire portfolio at risk.

In summary, cryptocurrencies' price fluctuations present opportunities for rapid gains but also carry the risk of short-term losses. Investors need to carefully consider their risk tolerance and conduct thorough research before investing in this volatile asset class.

Frequently asked questions