Gold Vs Mutual Funds: Which Is The Better Investment?

Gold and mutual funds are both popular investment options, but which is better? Gold is a precious metal that has been a preferred choice of investment for centuries, while mutual funds are financial investments that pool investors' money to buy securities. Gold is a relatively secure investment option that can act as a hedge against inflation, whereas mutual funds offer the advantage of compounding and may deliver market-linked returns. Gold does not generate income, but it can provide protection against market downturns and hyperinflation. Mutual funds, on the other hand, carry higher risk but offer higher potential returns through diversified investments. The choice between gold and mutual funds depends on factors such as financial goals, risk tolerance, and investment budget.

Gold vs Mutual Funds: Returns

Gold and mutual funds are both rewarding investment options, but they differ in many ways. Gold is a precious metal that is available in limited quantities, making its demand higher than its supply. As a result, its price is expected to increase over time. Gold has consistently provided returns of up to 10-13% per annum in the long run. It is also among the lowest-risk-bearing assets and is highly liquid. However, gold does not provide a compounding benefit as it does not yield dividends or interest.

Mutual funds, on the other hand, pool investors' money to buy securities such as stocks, bonds, and other assets. The returns of mutual funds vary among different plans, but they generally deliver around 10-12% returns per annum, with some funds providing up to 15-18% returns. Mutual funds offer the advantage of compounding and are professionally managed by expert fund managers. However, they carry a higher risk than gold as their value depends on market conditions.

When comparing gold vs mutual funds in terms of returns, it is important to consider the different benefits and risks associated with each investment option. Gold offers stable and consistent returns with low risk, while mutual funds offer potentially higher returns but with higher risk. Ultimately, the choice between investing in gold or mutual funds depends on an individual's financial goals, risk tolerance, and investment horizon.

Gold ETFs (Exchange-Traded Funds) are another option for investing in gold. Gold ETFs offer higher liquidity than physical gold and are traded on stock exchanges, allowing for easy buying and selling of units. They also have lower costs compared to physical gold, as there are no storage or insurance fees. However, gold ETFs have management fees that can affect overall returns.

In summary, both gold and mutual funds can be rewarding investments, but they offer different returns and come with their own set of risks and benefits. Gold provides stable and consistent returns with low risk, while mutual funds offer potentially higher returns but with higher risk. Gold ETFs are another option for investing in gold, offering higher liquidity and lower costs compared to physical gold. The best investment choice depends on an individual's financial goals, risk tolerance, and investment preferences.

Gold vs Mutual Funds: Risk

Gold and mutual funds are both rewarding investment options, but they differ in terms of the risk involved. Gold is a relatively secure investment option with a low risk of loss. It is a physical commodity with a limited quantity, and its price is expected to increase over time. Gold has consistently provided returns of up to 10-13% per annum in the long run. It is also a hedge against inflation and has shown strong performance during economic crises. However, investing in physical gold comes with the additional costs of storage, insurance, and authentication.

On the other hand, mutual funds pool investor money to buy securities, such as stocks, bonds, and other assets. Most mutual funds invest in the stock market, which makes them riskier than gold investments. The returns of mutual funds vary among different plans, but they generally offer higher potential returns than gold. Mutual funds also offer the advantage of compounding and diversification. However, the value of mutual funds is tied to the performance of the securities market, and they carry a higher risk than gold.

Gold ETFs (Exchange-Traded Funds) are another option for investing in gold. Gold ETFs offer higher liquidity than physical gold and are traded on stock exchanges. They also have lower costs than physical gold since investors do not have to pay for storage and insurance. However, gold ETFs are subject to management fees, which can affect overall returns. Additionally, there is a possibility that the fund may fail to properly track the price of gold.

Overall, gold is considered a lower-risk investment option compared to mutual funds, especially during economic downturns and periods of high inflation. Mutual funds, on the other hand, offer higher potential returns and diversification but carry a higher level of risk. The choice between the two ultimately depends on the investor's financial goals, risk tolerance, and investment horizon.

Gold vs Mutual Funds: Liquidity

Liquidity is a key consideration when comparing gold and mutual funds as investment options.

Gold is a highly liquid instrument. Physical gold can be easily converted into cash by visiting a local jeweller, and even Digital Gold can be converted into cash with ease (except for sovereign gold bonds). Gold ETFs are also highly liquid, as they can be bought and sold instantly on the stock market during trading hours.

On the other hand, the liquidity of mutual funds depends on the type of fund. Most mutual funds are open-ended schemes, meaning they can be sold easily on the stock exchange. However, some mutual funds, such as gold mutual funds, may have a lock-in period, such as the minimum five-year lock-in period for sovereign gold bonds.

Gold ETFs offer higher liquidity than physical gold, as they can be traded quickly through financial markets without the logistical challenges of physical gold transactions. Gold ETFs are traded on stock exchanges, allowing investors to buy or sell units at any time during trading hours. In contrast, selling physical gold may involve finding a buyer and authentication processes, which can take longer.

While gold and mutual funds both offer liquidity, the level of liquidity can vary depending on the specific type of investment. Gold, particularly in the form of gold ETFs, tends to offer greater liquidity compared to mutual funds, which may have certain restrictions on buying and selling.

Gold vs Mutual Funds: Tax Benefits

When it comes to tax benefits, gold and mutual funds have some key differences. Gold, as a commodity, is subject to different taxes depending on whether it is purchased physically or digitally. On the other hand, mutual funds, as financial investments, offer certain tax advantages that may be beneficial for investors.

Gold:

Physical gold purchases in India, such as jewellery, gold biscuits, ornaments, and coins, are subject to a 20% tax and a 4% cess on long-term capital gains (LTCG). This results in an overall taxable rate of 20.8%. However, this rate does not apply to short-term capital gains, which are taxed based on the individual's income bracket. It's important to note that physical gold is also subject to other taxes and duties, such as customs duty, Agriculture Infrastructure Development Cess (AIDC), and Goods and Service Tax (GST).

Digital gold investments, on the other hand, are treated similarly to physical gold in terms of taxation. Returns from digital gold held for less than 36 months are not directly taxable, but long-term capital gains are taxed at 20%, along with a surcharge and a 4% cess.

Mutual Funds:

Mutual funds, including gold mutual funds, provide certain tax benefits that may make them attractive to investors. For example, mutual funds offer the advantage of compounding, especially through Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs). Additionally, mutual funds provide diversification across different asset classes, which can help reduce risk.

Gold mutual funds specifically invest in gold Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs), which are traded on stock exchanges. While gold mutual funds may require a higher minimum investment compared to gold ETFs, they offer a convenient way to invest in gold without the need for a Demat or trading account.

In terms of taxation, both gold mutual funds and gold ETFs are taxed at 20.8% for long-term capital gains. For short-term capital gains, the tax rate is based on the individual's income slab. It is important to note that gold mutual funds typically have an exit load, while gold ETFs do not.

Sovereign Gold Bonds (SGBs) and Gold Monetization Scheme (GMS):

It's worth mentioning that Sovereign Gold Bonds (SGBs) and the Gold Monetization Scheme (GMS) offer tax benefits that are not available with physical or digital gold purchases. In the case of SGBs, interest income is taxable, but capital gains are exempt. With GMS, both interest income and capital gains are exempt from tax.

When comparing gold vs mutual funds in terms of tax benefits, both options have their own advantages. Gold, especially in its physical form, is subject to various taxes and duties, but mutual funds offer tax advantages through compounding and diversification. Additionally, specific programs like SGBs and GMS provide tax exemptions on capital gains. Ultimately, the decision between investing in gold or mutual funds depends on the investor's financial goals, risk tolerance, and tax situation.

Gold vs Mutual Funds: Investor Profile

Gold and mutual funds are both rewarding investments, but which is more beneficial depends on your financial goals, risk tolerance, and capital availability.

Gold is a precious metal that is available in limited quantities. It is a relatively secure and stable investment option that has been a preferred choice for Indians for centuries. Gold is often used as a hedge against inflation and has consistently provided returns of up to 10-13% per annum in the long run. It is also a highly liquid instrument that can be easily converted to cash. However, gold does not provide a compounding benefit and does not generate any income, as it does not yield dividends or interest.

Mutual funds, on the other hand, pool investor money to buy securities, stocks, bonds, and other assets. They offer the advantage of compounding and diversification. Mutual funds have delivered returns of around 10-12% per annum, with some funds providing returns of up to 15-18%. Most mutual funds are open-ended schemes, meaning they can be sold easily on the stock exchange. However, they carry a higher risk than gold as their value depends on market conditions.

If you are a risk-averse investor, gold may be a better option. It is suitable for those seeking a traditional and secure investment that retains value during economic downturns and has the potential to hedge against inflation. Gold is also a good choice for those looking for an asset with high liquidity and diversification beyond stocks and bonds.

On the other hand, mutual funds may be more suitable for aggressive investors who are willing to take higher risks to earn market-linked returns. Mutual funds are a good choice for those seeking higher potential returns through diversified investments, professional management of their portfolio, and tax benefits to reduce their tax liability.

Ultimately, the decision to invest in gold or mutual funds depends on your individual financial goals and risk tolerance. Both investments can be beneficial and can be used to diversify your portfolio.

Frequently asked questions