Understanding 401(K) Rebalancing: Optimize Your Investment Strategy

When you open a 401(k) account, you will need to decide how to allocate your money across different types of investments, such as stocks, bonds, real estate, and precious metals. Over time, the value of these investments will fluctuate, causing your asset allocation to deviate from your desired balance. Rebalancing is the act of buying and selling different types of investments to realign them with your desired asset allocation. This can be done manually or automatically, and it is an important tool for maintaining your desired level of risk and supporting your retirement goals.

The importance of rebalancing your 401(k)

Rebalancing your 401(k) is a crucial step in maintaining your investment portfolio's health and ensuring your long-term financial goals remain on track. It involves periodically adjusting the asset allocation within your 401(k) account to align with your original desired levels. Over time, your chosen investments will grow at different rates, causing shifts in your portfolio's composition. Some assets may outperform others, leading to an unintended imbalance. By rebalancing, you essentially 'reset' your portfolio, bringing it back to the desired mix of stocks, bonds, and other investments.

There are several benefits to regularly rebalancing your 401(k). Firstly, it helps control risk. Different asset classes carry varying levels of risk and potential return. For example, stocks are generally considered riskier but offer higher potential returns, while bonds are more stable but yield lower returns. When one asset class outperforms the others, your portfolio's risk profile changes. Rebalancing ensures that you're maintaining the level of risk you're comfortable with and have initially planned for.

Secondly, rebalancing helps ensure that your portfolio remains diversified. Diversification is a key principle in investing, as it spreads your risk across various assets, sectors, and markets. By rebalancing, you're effectively buying low and selling high. When you trim holdings that have grown significantly and add to those that have lagged, you're positioning yourself to benefit from future shifts in the market. Diversification also helps smooth out the volatility in your portfolio, as different assets tend to perform well at different times.

Moreover, rebalancing is a way to discipline yourself as an investor. Emotional decisions often lead to poor investment choices, such as buying when the market is high and selling when it's low. By setting a rebalancing schedule and sticking to it, you make decisions based on your long-term strategy rather than short-term market fluctuations. This disciplined approach helps you avoid impulsive reactions to market movements and keeps your investment strategy consistent.

Finally, rebalancing helps you stay focused on your long-term goals. It reminds you of the reasons you're investing in the first place and ensures that your portfolio continues to reflect those goals. Whether you're saving for retirement, a child's education, or another significant expense, rebalancing keeps your investment strategy aligned with your objectives. It also allows you to adjust your portfolio as your goals evolve or your risk tolerance changes over time.

There are different approaches to rebalancing, such as setting a regular schedule (annually, semi-annually, or quarterly) or rebalancing when your portfolio deviates from your target allocation by a certain percentage (e.g., 5% or 10%). It's important to choose a method that suits your investment style and goals. Remember that rebalancing may involve costs, such as trading fees, and potential tax implications, especially in taxable accounts. Nonetheless, the benefits of rebalancing your 401(k) generally outweigh these costs, making it a vital practice for prudent investors.

How to rebalance your 401(k)

Rebalancing your 401(k) is an important part of investment management. It helps you to maintain your desired portfolio allocation and ensures your investments remain in line with your risk tolerance and financial goals.

When you first open a 401(k) account, you will allocate a certain percentage of your money to stocks and another percentage to bonds. Over time, some of your investments will grow faster than others, and your original asset allocation will get out of line.

• Define your target investment mix: Before you begin rebalancing, you need to know your desired asset allocation. This could be, for example, 60% stocks and 40% bonds, or it could include other types of investments such as real estate or precious metals.
• Monitor your portfolio: Keep an eye on your portfolio to see how it is performing. You may want to check in annually or after significant market changes to see if your actual asset allocation matches your desired allocation.
• Rebalance according to a schedule: One approach is to rebalance your portfolio on a regular schedule, such as quarterly, semi-annually, or annually. This is an easy and popular method. Simply decide how frequently you want to rebalance and make any necessary adjustments at those intervals.
• Rebalance based on percentage drift: Another approach is to rebalance when your portfolio allocation has drifted by a certain percentage from its target. For example, if your target allocation is 60% stocks and 30% bonds, you might rebalance when stocks reach 65% or fall to 55%. This method requires more frequent monitoring of your portfolio and market conditions.
• Sell overweighted investments: When rebalancing, you will need to sell some of the investments that have grown beyond their target allocation. For example, if your stock fund has grown to 70% of your portfolio, you would sell enough of that fund to bring it back down to your target allocation.
• Buy underweighted investments: Use the proceeds from the sale of overweighted investments to buy more of the investments that are below their target allocation. This helps you maintain a diverse portfolio and ensures you are not taking on too much risk in any one area.
• Consider future contributions: Instead of selling and buying investments, you can also adjust your future contributions to rebalance your 401(k). This involves changing the investment mix of your future contributions to buy more of the underweighted funds. However, this method may not allow for a perfect recalibration, and it may take longer to reach your target allocation.
• Utilize automatic rebalancing: Many 401(k) plans now offer automatic rebalancing features. These can be set up to rebalance your portfolio according to a schedule or when your allocation drifts by a certain percentage. This takes the work out of rebalancing and ensures it is done consistently.

Remember, rebalancing is not an exact science, and it is okay if your portfolio is not perfectly aligned with your desired allocation. The most important thing is to ensure your investments match your risk tolerance and financial goals. If you are unsure, consider consulting a financial advisor for assistance.

When to rebalance your 401(k)

When you first open a 401(k) account, you will need to set your asset allocation. This will involve putting a certain percentage of your money into aggressive investments like stock funds and another percentage into less aggressive investments like bond funds. However, over time, your desired portfolio allocation may become skewed as certain investments outperform others. To get those percentages back in line, you will need to rebalance your portfolio periodically.

There are two general approaches to when you should rebalance your 401(k) account. The first is to rebalance on a regular time schedule, such as quarterly, semiannually, or annually. This is the easier and more popular method. Simply decide how frequently you want to rebalance and remember your next rebalance date. For example, you can rebalance annually when you receive your year-end 401(k) statement. How frequently you rebalance is not a critical factor since it will not significantly affect your account’s risk and return. So make it easier on yourself and rebalance less frequently (but at least once a year).

The second approach is to rebalance when the allocation is a certain number of percentage points away from its target. For example, if your target allocation is 50% stocks/50% bonds, you might rebalance when stocks are more than 55% or less than 45%. This method is more difficult because you need to closely monitor fund balances in your account, and market conditions may require you to rebalance quite frequently.

One way to keep your 401(k) account on track is to make sure your contributions are invested according to your asset allocation target. Then, when you rebalance periodically, you should only have to make modest adjustments. To rebalance, simply sell enough of the funds that are above their target and buy enough of the funds that are below their target, until all funds match their target allocation. This means you will be selling some of your recent winners and buying more of your recent losers. But that’s okay—because in asset allocation, today’s winners may be tomorrow’s losers and vice versa.

The benefits of rebalancing your 401(k)

Rebalancing your 401(k) is an important part of managing your investments and maintaining your risk level. When you first open a 401(k) account, you will allocate a certain percentage of your money to stocks and another percentage to bonds. Over time, some of your investments will grow faster than others, and your original asset allocation may get out of line. Rebalancing is the act of buying and selling different types of investments to realign them with the percentages in your desired asset allocation. Here are some benefits of rebalancing your 401(k):

• Maintain your target asset allocation: The performance of different funds in your 401(k) plan can cause your asset allocation to deviate from your desired targets. For example, a participant with an initial 50% stocks/50% bonds allocation in 1995 would have seen their allocation shift to 71% stocks/29% bonds five years later due to strong stock market performance. By rebalancing, you can adjust your allocations to match your original targets and avoid taking on more risk than you intended.
• Reduce risk: As you get closer to retirement, you may want to consider taking on less risk by reducing your stock holdings and increasing your bond holdings. Rebalancing allows you to do this by selling a portion of the investments that have outgrown their percentage and buying more of the ones that are lagging. This helps to ensure that your portfolio remains aligned with your risk tolerance and financial goals.
• Buy low, sell high: Automatic rebalancing can help you buy low and sell high. For example, if one of your funds has experienced strong performance and another has underperformed, rebalancing will trigger a sale of some holdings in the outperforming fund and a purchase of additional holdings in the underperforming fund. This allows you to lock in profits and potentially benefit from future gains in the underperforming fund.
• Maintain diversification: Diversification is an important investment strategy to manage risk. By rebalancing your 401(k), you can ensure that your portfolio remains diversified across different asset classes, investment styles, sizes, and geographies. This helps to reduce the impact of any single investment or market on your overall portfolio performance.
• Save time and effort: While you can manually rebalance your 401(k) by monitoring your fund balances and making adjustments, automatic rebalancing programs are also available. These programs will periodically adjust your allocations according to your target investment mix, saving you time and effort.

Strategies for rebalancing your 401(k)

Once you have set up your 401(k) retirement account, it's important to periodically rebalance your portfolio to ensure your investments remain aligned with your risk tolerance, time horizon, and savings goals. Here are some strategies to help you effectively rebalance your 401(k):

• Regular Time-Based Rebalancing: One approach is to rebalance your 401(k) on a fixed schedule, such as quarterly, semi-annually, or annually. This method is straightforward and popular. Decide how often you want to rebalance and mark your calendar. For instance, you can choose to rebalance annually when you receive your year-end 401(k) statement. The frequency of rebalancing is not critical, and rebalancing less frequently (but at least once a year) is recommended.
• Percentage-Based Rebalancing: Another strategy is to rebalance when your asset allocation deviates from its target by a certain percentage. For example, if your target allocation is 50% stocks and 50% bonds, you may choose to rebalance when stocks exceed 55% or fall below 45%. This method requires closer monitoring of your fund balances and market conditions, and you may need to rebalance more frequently.
• Sell Overweight and Buy Underweight: When rebalancing, you can sell a portion of the investments that have grown beyond their target allocation and use the proceeds to buy more of the investments that are below their target. This strategy helps you return to your desired allocation. For example, if your portfolio is overweight in equities due to strong performance, you can sell some of those holdings and use the funds to buy more bonds to match your target allocation.
• Change Future Allocations: Instead of selling and buying, you can adjust your future contributions to rebalance your portfolio gradually. This method is less precise and may take longer to reach your desired allocation. For instance, if your portfolio is overweight in equities, you can change your allocation for the next pay period to contribute more to bonds and less to equities. Remember to adjust your future allocation once your portfolio reaches your target to avoid over-contributing to one asset class.
• One-Time Overcontribution: If you are looking to add funds to your 401(k), you can rebalance by making a one-time overcontribution to the underweight security. First, determine your target portfolio balance based on the value of your overcontributed asset. Then, calculate how much you need to contribute to reach that balance. Finally, buy the underweight security to match your desired allocation. Keep in mind any contribution limits set by the IRS.
• Convert to Target Date Fund: An alternative approach is to switch to a target date fund that automatically rebalances your portfolio based on your proximity to retirement. These funds adjust their asset allocation over time, typically shifting towards more conservative investments as you get closer to retirement. For example, if you plan to retire in 20 years, you can consider a Target Date 2045 plan.
• Consider the Big Picture: Remember that your 401(k) may be one of several places you invest your money. When rebalancing, consider your entire investment portfolio, including other retirement accounts and mutual funds. Look for investment products with the lowest fees across your holdings. Additionally, consider the type of accounts you have, as there are different tax implications for Roth 401(k) and traditional 401(k) contributions.
• Diversify Your Investments: Diversification is a crucial strategy to manage risk. Spread your investments across different asset classes, such as stocks, bonds, commodities, and more. You can also diversify within asset classes. For example, with stocks, you can invest in a mix of styles (value and growth), sizes (large-cap, mid-cap, small-cap), and geographies (U.S., international developed, emerging markets).
• Adjust Your Asset Allocation Over Time: Your asset allocation doesn't have to remain static. As you get closer to retirement, you may want to adjust your allocation to reduce risk. Many financial experts recommend moving towards a more conservative mix as retirement approaches. Target date funds can automatically adjust your allocation for you, or you can manually buy and sell specific equities to realign your portfolio.
• Monitor Your Portfolio's Performance: Keep an eye on how your portfolio is performing. Different sectors of the stock market may not always move in tandem. For example, if you hold both large-cap and small-cap stocks, the small-cap portion may grow faster than the large-cap portion. If this happens, you can rebalance by selling some of your small-cap holdings and reinvesting in large-cap stocks to maintain your desired asset allocation.
• Seek Professional Advice: If you feel you need assistance, consider consulting a financial advisor. They can provide guidance and help you make informed decisions about rebalancing your 401(k) and managing your investments.

Frequently asked questions