The Future Of Investment: Side-By-Side Management

Side-by-side management is a process that evaluates funds and accounts to ensure fair and transparent allocations. It is a way to identify and manage conflicts of interest that may arise when a portfolio manager is responsible for multiple accounts. By comparing accounts side by side, compliance teams can identify if a portfolio manager is favouring one account or fund over another to enhance performance or gain higher fees. Global regulators, such as the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), have implemented regulations and issued fines to ensure that conflicts of interest are properly managed and that customers' interests are not overlooked.

Buy-side analysts determine investment potential and alignment with a fund's strategy

Buy-side analysts are employed by firms that manage money, such as hedge funds, pension funds, mutual funds, and private equity groups. They are responsible for evaluating an investment's potential and determining how well it aligns with a fund's investment strategy. They make recommendations based on their research, which is intended only for the benefit of the fund that employs them.

Buy-side analysts play a pivotal role in the investment process. They identify promising prospects, analyse financial statements, meet with company management, and build financial models to forecast future performance. They then advise portfolio managers on whether to buy, hold, or sell specific securities. Their success is measured by the number of profitable recommendations they make for the fund.

When evaluating an investment, buy-side analysts consider the potential returns and how well it fits with the fund's strategy. They are more cautious and risk-averse than sell-side analysts, often focusing on the potential pitfalls of an investment rather than its upside potential. They are highly motivated to be right in their recommendations as their compensation is often tied to the returns generated by their investment choices.

Buy-side analysts have broader coverage responsibilities than sell-side analysts. They cover entire sectors, such as technology or industrials, while sell-side analysts tend to focus on specific industries within those sectors. Buy-side analysts also have more inward-facing duties, such as making investment decisions and managing their clients' money, with the goal of growing the firm's portfolio.

Sell-side analysts are known for issuing recommendations such as strong buy or sell

Investment management is divided into two sides: the buy-side and the sell-side. The buy-side is a segment of financial markets made up of investing institutions that buy securities for money-management purposes. The sell-side is the opposite of the buy-side, providing only investment recommendations and services to facilitate the purchasing of securities by the buy-side.

Sell-side analysts are known for issuing recommendations such as "strong buy", "outperform", "neutral", or "sell". These recommendations help clients decide whether to buy or sell certain stocks. This is beneficial for the brokerage because every time a client decides to trade stock, the brokerage earns a commission on the transactions.

Sell-side analysts work for investment banks and are paid by and answer to the brokerage, not the clients. Their recommendations are called "blanket recommendations" because they are directed at the general mass of the firm's clients rather than any one client in particular. As such, they may be inappropriate for certain investment strategies. Therefore, it is important to determine whether the recommendation suits one's individual investment style.

Sell-side analysts are also responsible for producing research for the consumption of buy-side firms. They follow a list of companies, usually in the same industry, and provide regular research reports to the firm's clients. This requires the analyst to build models to project the firm's financial results and speak with customers, suppliers, competitors, and other sources with knowledge of the industry.

Sell-side analysts are under tremendous pressure to be the first to provide clients with new and different information. They also have to comply with rules and standards that are less restrictive than those for buy-side analysts.

Buy-side firms include asset managers, hedge funds, and pension funds

Investment management is divided into two sides: the buy-side and the sell-side. The buy-side refers to firms that purchase securities and includes buy-side analysts, investment managers, pension funds, and hedge funds.

Asset managers are buy-side firms that manage a portfolio of securities on behalf of their clients. They employ buy-side analysts who conduct in-house research and make recommendations based on their findings. These recommendations are kept private and are not available to anyone outside the fund. Asset managers then use this research to buy, sell, or hold positions in various securities, anticipating future profits.

Hedge funds are private investment funds that are not available to the general public. They employ a variety of trading strategies, including short-selling and taking highly leveraged positions. Hedge funds have more freedom in their trading strategies compared to mutual funds and can employ more speculative approaches.

Pension funds are another type of buy-side firm that manages retirement funds for employees. These funds are designed to provide income for individuals during their retirement years. Buy-side analysts play a crucial role in pension funds by conducting research and making investment recommendations to ensure the fund's long-term stability and growth.

In summary, buy-side firms, including asset managers, hedge funds, and pension funds, are responsible for investing their clients' money in securities. They aim to create value by identifying underpriced assets and making strategic investments. These firms play a vital role in the financial market by facilitating investment opportunities and helping individuals plan for their future.

Sell-side firms include investment banks, broker-dealers, and market makers

Sell-side firms are those that provide services to sell securities, including investment banks, broker-dealers, and market makers. These firms facilitate the offering of securities to investors, conduct research, and create financial products. They are the driving force of the financial market and work to create and service products available to the buy-side of the industry.

Investment banks are a key component of the sell-side. They act as intermediaries between the issuers of securities and the investing public, and they underwrite stock issuance, taking proprietary positions. Investment banks also play a crucial role in the initial public offerings (IPOs) of stocks, as companies must enlist their services to go public.

Broker-dealers, another important type of sell-side firm, take orders from buy-side firms and work them by splitting them into smaller orders sent directly to an exchange or other firms. They are intermediaries, selling securities to investors, usually on the buy-side. Broker-dealers are paid through commissions charged on the sales price of the stock.

Market makers are the big players on the sell-side, providing liquidity to the market. They are responsible for creating a market for the buying and selling of securities and ensuring that trades can take place.

Together, these sell-side firms play a critical role in the financial industry, facilitating the sale of stocks, bonds, foreign exchange, and other financial instruments to the public market. They work closely with buy-side firms, which include asset managers, hedge funds, and other companies that trade securities for their clients. The collaboration between sell-side and buy-side firms is essential for the functioning of financial markets.

Side-by-side management helps identify conflicts of interest

Conflict of interest is a major concern in the buy-side community. Compliance teams are tasked with ensuring that portfolio managers treat their investors fairly across all funds, regardless of strategy, legal or fee structure. This is where side-by-side management comes in.

Side-by-side management involves evaluating funds and accounts in comparison to ensure fair and transparent allocations. This process helps identify conflicts of interest and ensures that portfolio managers are allocating assets in accordance with regulatory mandates. By highlighting potential infractions, compliance teams can identify problems early on and take appropriate action.

For instance, a portfolio manager overseeing multiple accounts may favour one account or fund over another to enhance performance or gain higher fees for the same trade. They might allocate the best-performing trades to accounts that will accumulate higher fees and bonuses. Side-by-side management helps detect such conflicts by scrutinising all trades and facilitating proactive management reporting.

Global regulators, including the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), closely monitor side-by-side management. The FCA, in particular, has issued fines and penalties against asset managers who fail to comply with regulations. Georgina Philippou, Acting Director of Enforcement and Market Oversight at the FCA, emphasises the importance of managing conflicts of interest: "Ensuring that conflicts of interest are properly managed is central to the relationship of trust that must exist between asset managers and their customers. It is also a fundamental regulatory requirement...Not doing so risks customers’ interests being overlooked in favour of commercial or personal interests."

Frequently asked questions