College: A Risky Bet?

For some people, college may not be a smart investment. The value of a college degree can vary depending on factors such as field of study, type of college, graduation rate, and future occupation. The return on investment (ROI) of a bachelor's degree can vary widely between schools, and for certain schools, the ROI is negative.

Additionally, college may not be a good fit for everyone. Some people may be better suited to learning a trade or pursuing other paths. Success in college often depends on factors such as discipline, time management, and work ethic rather than pure intelligence. Furthermore, the high cost of college and the potential for significant student loan debt can be a burden, especially if the degree does not lead to improved employment prospects or higher earnings.

While college can provide valuable skills, knowledge, and experiences, it is essential to consider individual circumstances, goals, and alternatives before deciding whether to pursue a college education.

The return on investment (ROI) of a bachelor's degree varies across schools and fields of study

The type of college is a significant factor in determining the ROI of a bachelor's degree. Community colleges and certificate programs generally offer higher short-term ROI, defined as a 10-year period, as they take less time to complete and tend to cost less than a bachelor's degree. On the other hand, colleges that primarily award bachelor's degrees provide better long-term ROI, typically over a 40-year timeframe.

Public colleges tend to offer higher ROI over 10 years compared to private nonprofit colleges. However, private nonprofit institutions outperform public colleges over 40 years. This is because private nonprofit colleges usually cost more and take longer to complete, delaying graduates' entry into the workforce. Nonetheless, private nonprofit college graduates tend to earn almost $8,000 more annually 10 years after enrollment than their counterparts from public colleges.

The field of study also influences the ROI of a bachelor's degree. For example, the Bachelor of Science (BS) is typically a three-to-five-year undergraduate degree in engineering, computer science, mathematics, economics, finance, business, or the natural sciences. In contrast, the Bachelor of Arts (BA) covers a broader range of disciplines and is often pursued by students majoring in humanities-oriented fields. The choice between a BS or BA degree can depend on the university and the specific subject. Some universities offer both BS and BA degrees in the same discipline, with the BS being more specialized and targeted toward students intending to pursue graduate school or a profession in that field.

In conclusion, the ROI of a bachelor's degree is contingent on various factors, including the type of college, field of study, and timeframe considered. While community colleges and certificate programs offer higher short-term ROI, colleges awarding bachelor's degrees provide better long-term returns. Additionally, the field of study, such as BS versus BA, can impact the ROI, with more specialized degrees often leading to higher earnings in the long run.

The completion rate of colleges is an important factor in determining the value of a degree

The choice of college can have a significant impact on a student's likelihood of graduating. For example, Harvard University has a graduation rate of 97%, while less selective colleges often exhibit a wider range of completion rates. Students can increase their chances of graduating by choosing a college with a strong track record within their ability level.

The completion rate of a college is influenced by various factors, including the selectivity of the institution, the quality of teaching, and the support provided to students. Additionally, the dedication, work ethic, and time management skills of the students themselves play a crucial role in their success.

The value of a college degree is also dependent on other factors such as the field of study, type of college, and future occupation. Certain fields may offer higher ROI than others, and the reputation and alumni network of a college can impact a graduate's career prospects.

Furthermore, the completion rate of a college can be an indicator of the support and resources provided to students. Colleges with higher completion rates may offer better academic advising, tutoring services, or other resources that contribute to student success.

In conclusion, the completion rate of a college is a significant factor in determining the value of a degree. It reflects the likelihood of students graduating and obtaining the full benefits of a college education. By considering completion rates, students can make more informed decisions about their choice of college and increase their chances of a positive ROI on their investment in higher education.

The cost of college is becoming too high for the potential return

The rising cost of college is a concern for many, and it is a valid question to ask whether the potential return is worth the investment. The value of a college degree varies according to several factors, such as the field of study, type of college, graduation rate, and future occupation.

The return on investment (ROI) of a bachelor's degree can vary widely depending on the institution. According to PayScale, an online salary information company, the ROI can even be negative for certain schools. This means that the potential earnings after graduation may not be enough to cover the cost of the degree, resulting in a financial loss.

The high cost of college can lead to significant student debt, which can be challenging to repay, especially if graduates struggle to find well-paying jobs. Student loans can impact an individual's financial stability and ability to make significant purchases or investments in the future.

Furthermore, the completion rates of colleges vary, and not all students graduate. The likelihood of graduating differs across institutions, with some colleges having much higher completion rates than others. For example, Harvard has a graduation rate of 97%, while other colleges may have lower rates, increasing the risk of not obtaining a degree despite the investment.

The cost of college also includes the opportunity cost of not working during those years. Attending college often means forgoing income that could have been earned during that time, further adding to the overall cost of the degree.

While a college degree can lead to higher earnings and improved employment prospects, it is not a guarantee. The job market is competitive, and there may be instances where a college degree does not provide a significant advantage or return on investment.

Therefore, when considering the cost of college, it is essential to weigh the potential benefits against the financial investment required. For some individuals, the potential return may not justify the high cost, and exploring alternative paths, such as trade schools or specific skill-building, may be a more prudent financial decision.

The current education system is not for everyone

Secondly, success in college is not solely determined by intelligence but by other factors such as discipline, networking, time management, and drive. The current education system favours those with a strong work ethic and a clear plan or trajectory. For those without these advantages, the system can be challenging and may not provide a positive return on investment.

Thirdly, the current education system may not cater to different learning styles and aptitudes. Some individuals may excel in hands-on learning or trades but struggle in an academic setting. The traditional college path may not be the best option for these individuals, as they could acquire valuable skills and connections through alternative routes.

Additionally, the cost of college can be a significant barrier for many. The prospect of taking on massive amounts of debt with no guarantee of a positive return can deter individuals from pursuing a college education. The financial risk may be especially concerning for those who are unsure of their major or career path.

Lastly, the college experience may not suit everyone's personal development. While college provides an opportunity to live independently and gain valuable skills, it can also be a source of depression and stress for some. For certain individuals, entering the job market directly after high school or pursuing alternative educational paths may be a more suitable option.

In conclusion, while a college education can provide benefits, it is not a one-size-fits-all solution. The current education system needs to acknowledge and accommodate diverse learning styles, career paths, and personal goals. Recognising that college is not the only path to success can empower individuals to make informed choices that align with their unique strengths and aspirations.

College degrees are not a requirement for all jobs

In 2023, the share of jobs on hiring platform ZipRecruiter that listed a bachelor's degree as a requirement dropped to 14.5%, from 18% in 2022. This is a reversal of the "degree inflation" trend that picked up after the Great Recession, where employers added degree requirements to job descriptions that didn't need them.

In place of four-year degrees, many companies are focusing on skills-based hiring to widen the talent pool. For example, tech companies like Accenture and IBM have dropped degree requirements for many middle-skill and higher-skill roles, instead prioritising "motivation, skills, and experience". This approach has also been adopted by the US government, which in 2021 announced limits on the use of educational requirements when hiring for IT positions.

The Covid-19 pandemic labour shortage has forced companies to rethink the prerequisites for a successful hire and the kinds of employees they need to help them succeed. In addition, the pandemic, George Floyd's murder, and the attention that brought to structural racism in America, generated new focus on diversity, equity, and inclusion in businesses. Nonessential degree requirements have been recognised as not being race-neutral, as they embed into the labour market the legacy of Black exclusion from the US education system.

While some jobs do require a college degree, for many, it is not a necessity. A college degree may not be a smart investment for everyone, and it is important to consider factors such as field of study, type of college, graduation rate, and future occupation when deciding whether to pursue one.

Frequently asked questions