Savings, Investments, And The Economy: National Symbiosis

The saving-investment identity is a concept in national income accounting. It states that the amount saved in an economy will be the amount invested in new physical machinery, new inventories, and the like. In other words, the flow variable investment must be financed by some combination of private domestic saving, government saving (surplus), and foreign saving (foreign capital inflows). This is an identity, meaning it is true by definition.

In a closed economy with a government, the remainder of aggregate output, after subtracting consumption by individuals and the government, must equal investment. This can be expressed as: Y = C + I + G, therefore I = Y - C - G. However, it is also true that Y = C + S + T, where T is the amount of taxes levied. This equation says that saving (S) is equal to disposable income (Y-T) minus consumption (C). Combining both expressions gives: I + G = S + T, therefore I = S + (T-G).

In an open economy, a similar expression can be found. The national income identity is: Y = C + I + G + (X-M), where (X-M) is the balance of trade (exports minus imports). Private saving is still S = Y - T - C, so again combining (by solving for Y-C on one side and equating) gives: I + G + (X-M) = S + T, therefore I = S + (T-G) + (M-X).

This does not imply that an increase in saving must lead directly to an increase in investment. Indeed, businesses may respond to increased inventories by decreasing both output and intended investment. Likewise, this reduction in output by business will reduce income, forcing an unintended reduction in saving.

National saving and investment are equal because investment is defined as including inventory accumulation

The concept of national saving being equal to investment is known as the "'saving identity' or the "saving-investment identity". This is a macroeconomic principle that holds true in an open economy (an economy with foreign trade and capital flows).

The saving-investment identity states that the amount saved in an economy will be the amount invested in new physical machinery, new inventories, and the like. In other words, the flow variable investment must be financed by some combination of private domestic saving, government saving (surplus), and foreign saving (foreign capital inflows).

This identity is true by definition, and it only holds because investment is defined as including inventory accumulation, both deliberate and unintended. Therefore, if consumers decide to save more and spend less, the fall in demand would lead to an increase in business inventories. This change in inventories brings saving and investment into balance without any intention by businesses to increase investment.

For example, consider a scenario where Joe buys a $500 car from Amanda and saves the money under her bed. At first glance, this scenario seems to contradict the saving-investment identity, as the savings equal $500 while the investment equals $0. However, if Joe produces something himself, the output he generates will go into inventories (unplanned investment) when Amanda does not buy it, bringing the savings and investment back into balance.

In another scenario, Joe receives $500 from the Federal Reserve and puts it in a bank, which lends out $250 to Amanda, who invests in inventory. Again, if Joe does not use the remaining $250 to purchase Amanda's goods, she will have an accumulation of inventory, increasing investment by $250 and balancing it with the savings.

In summary, national saving equals investment because the definition of investment includes inventory accumulation. When consumers save more, it leads to an increase in business inventories, bringing saving and investment into balance.

The saving-investment identity holds true because saving includes private and public saving

In a nation's financial capital market, the quantity of financial capital supplied at any given time must equal the quantity of financial capital demanded for the purposes of making investments. This is a fundamental notion that must always remain true.

A country's national savings include the total of its domestic savings by households and companies (private savings), as well as the government (public savings).

The demand for financial capital represents groups that are borrowing money. Businesses need to borrow to finance their investments in factories, materials, and personnel. When the federal government runs a budget deficit, it is also borrowing money from investors by selling treasury bonds. Therefore, both business investment and the federal government can demand (or borrow) the supply of savings.

There are two main sources of supply for financial capital in an economy: saving by individuals and firms (private saving), and the inflow of financial capital from foreign investors, which is equal to the trade deficit (imports minus exports).

There are also two main sources of demand for financial capital: private sector investment and government borrowing. When government spending is higher than the taxes collected, the government needs to borrow money.

The national saving and investment identity can be expressed as:

Supply of financial capital = Demand for financial capital

S + (M - X) = I + (G - T)

Where:

• S = private savings
• T = taxes
• G = government spending
• M = imports
• X = exports
• I = investment

In this equation, certain components can switch between the supply and demand sides. For example, if the government runs a budget surplus, it would be contributing to the supply of financial capital and would appear on the left (saving) side of the equation. Conversely, if the government runs a budget deficit, it would be a demander of financial capital and would appear on the right-hand side of the equation.

The saving-investment identity holds true because saving includes both private and public saving, and the equation can be rearranged to reflect the different components of an economy's financial capital.

The saving-investment identity is an identity, meaning it is true by definition

The saving-investment identity is an economic concept that holds true in both open and closed economies. It is an "identity", meaning that it is true by definition.

In a closed economy with a government, the remainder of aggregate output (Y), after subtracting consumption by individuals (C) and the government (G), must equal investment (I). This can be expressed as:

> I = Y - C - G

However, it is also true that:

> Y = C + S + T

Where T is the amount of taxes levied, and S is saving (disposable income minus consumption). Combining both expressions gives:

> I + G = S + T

> I = S + (T - G)

Thus, investment is equal to private saving plus "public saving" (public saving is positive when there is a budget surplus, i.e. public debt reduction).

In an open economy, a similar expression can be derived. The national income identity is:

> Y = C + I + G + (X - M)

Where (X - M) is the balance of trade (exports minus imports). Private saving is still:

> S = Y - T - C

Combining both expressions gives:

> I + G + (X - M) = S + T

> I = S + (T - G) + (M - X)

Thus, in an open economy, investment must be financed by some combination of private domestic saving, government saving (surplus), and foreign saving (foreign capital inflows).

The saving-investment identity holds true because investment is defined as including inventory accumulation, both deliberate and unintended. Therefore, if consumers decide to save more and spend less, the fall in demand would lead to an increase in business inventories, bringing saving and investment into balance without any intention by businesses to increase investment.

It is important to note that this does not imply that an increase in saving will lead directly to an increase in investment. Businesses may respond to increased inventories by decreasing output and intended investment, which would reduce income and force an unintended reduction in saving.

The saving-investment identity does not imply that an increase in saving leads directly to an increase in investment

The saving-investment identity is a concept in national income accounting. It states that the amount saved in an economy will be the amount invested in new physical machinery, new inventories, and the like. In other words, the flow variable investment must be financed by some combination of private domestic saving, government saving (surplus), and foreign saving (foreign capital inflows).

However, this does not mean that an increase in saving leads directly to an increase in investment. If consumers decide to save more and spend less, the fall in demand would lead to an increase in business inventories. This change in inventories brings saving and investment into balance without any intention by businesses to increase investment.

For example, businesses may respond to increased inventories by decreasing both output and intended investment. This reduction in output by businesses will reduce income, forcing an unintended reduction in saving. Even if the end result is a lower level of investment, it will remain true at any given point in time that the saving-investment identity holds.

The saving-investment identity is also true because saving is defined to include private and public saving. Public saving is positive when there is a budget surplus, that is, public debt reduction.

In a closed economy with government, the remainder of aggregate output (Y), after subtracting consumption by individuals (C) and government (G), must equal investment (I). This can be expressed as:

I = Y - C - G

However, it is also true that:

Y = C + S + T

Where T is the amount of taxes levied. This equation says that saving (S) is equal to disposable income (Y - T) minus consumption (C). Combining both expressions gives:

I + G = S + T

Or:

I = S + (T - G)

Thus, investment is equal to private saving plus public saving.

In an open economy, a similar expression can be found. The national income identity is:

Y = C + I + G + (X - M)

Where (X - M) is the balance of trade (exports minus imports). Private saving is still:

S = Y - T - C

Combining both expressions gives:

I + G + (X - M) = S + T

Or:

I = S + (T - G) + (M - X)

Thus, in an open economy, investment is equal to private saving plus public saving plus capital inflow.

In summary, while the saving-investment identity holds true by definition, it does not imply a direct causal link between saving and investment. The relationship is more complex and depends on various factors such as business inventories, output, income, and the balance of trade.

The saving-investment identity is the basis of the investment-savings theory

The saving-investment identity is a concept in national income accounting. It states that the amount saved in an economy will be the amount invested in new physical machinery, new inventories, and similar areas. This is true for both open and closed economies.

In an open economy, private saving, government saving (the budget surplus or negative of the deficit), and foreign investment domestically (capital inflows from abroad) must equal private physical investment. This means that the flow variable investment is financed by a combination of private domestic saving, government saving, and foreign saving.

In a closed economy with a government, the remainder of aggregate output (Y), after subtracting consumption by individuals (C) and the government (G), must equal investment (I). This can be expressed as:

Y = C + I + G

I = Y - C - G

This equation demonstrates that investment is equal to savings, which is the basis of the investment-savings theory.

The saving-investment identity holds true because investment is defined to include inventory accumulation, both deliberate and unintended. For example, if consumers decide to save more and spend less, there will be a fall in demand, leading to an increase in business inventories. This change in inventories brings saving and investment into balance, even without a conscious decision by businesses to increase investment.

Additionally, the saving-investment identity holds because saving is defined to include both private and public saving. Public saving is positive when there is a budget surplus, resulting in public debt reduction.

While the saving-investment identity remains true at any given point in time, it does not imply a direct causal link between an increase in saving and an increase in investment. Businesses may respond to increased inventories by decreasing output and intended investment. This reduction in output will lower income, leading to a decrease in saving. Despite the potential for a lower level of investment, the saving-investment identity will still hold true.

The saving-investment identity is also recognised by classical macroeconomic theorists such as Adam Smith and David Ricardo. Smith noted its importance in "The Wealth of Nations", highlighting how it relates to the question of general equilibrium and the general glut controversy. Ricardo agreed with Smith on the equality of saving and investment but introduced the concept of diminishing returns as population decreases.

Frequently asked questions