Bond Funds Vs Individual Bonds: Pros And Cons For Investors

Investing in bonds can be a great way to generate a stable income stream. But should you invest in individual bonds or bond funds?

There are several factors to consider when deciding between the two. Firstly, diversification: individual bonds may require a larger initial investment to achieve sufficient diversification, whereas bond funds provide instant diversification by pooling together a large number of bonds from different issuers.

Secondly, convenience: investing in individual bonds requires significant time and effort to research and manage, whereas bond funds are professionally managed, saving you time and effort.

Thirdly, costs: individual bonds may have higher transaction costs and commissions, whereas bond funds benefit from institutional pricing and can be traded without ongoing fees.

Lastly, control and transparency: individual bonds offer greater control over your portfolio and transparency on what you own, whereas bond funds give you less control over the specific bonds you own.

Both options have their pros and cons, and the best choice for you will depend on your financial goals, risk tolerance, and behavioural preferences.

Bond funds offer greater diversification per dollar invested

Investing in bond funds offers greater diversification per dollar invested. Bond funds are a collection of individual bonds, so they provide exposure to a basket of bonds within the fund. This means that investors can achieve a diversified bond portfolio with a smaller amount of money.

For example, an investor may need to hold at least 10 different individual issues to achieve proper diversification when investing in individual bonds. In contrast, bond funds can invest in hundreds of bonds, providing greater diversification with one investment. This greater diversification can be achieved for a lower cost, as the funds can access institutional pricing, which is typically lower than the pricing available to individual investors.

The greater diversification offered by bond funds can also reduce the overall credit risk of a portfolio. This is because the failure of any one bond will have a minuscule effect on the fund.

Additionally, bond funds are professionally managed, which can be beneficial when investing in some of the riskier segments of the fixed-income market, such as high-yield bonds, bank loans, or preferred securities. Actively managed funds also allow managers to buy or sell bonds depending on the economic and interest rate environment, potentially increasing returns and income.

However, it is important to note that bond funds usually come with management fees, which can be higher for more actively traded funds and may lead to lower returns.

Bond funds are professionally managed

One of the key differences between investing in individual bonds and bond funds is the level of professional management involved. Bond funds are professionally managed, which can be a significant advantage for investors who want to benefit from the expertise and convenience of having their investments managed by professionals. Here are some key points to consider regarding the professional management aspect of bond funds:

Diversification and Institutional Pricing

Professional management in bond funds allows investors to achieve greater diversification with their investments. Bond funds typically hold a large number of bonds with varying maturities, coupon rates, credit ratings, and issuers. This diversification helps to reduce the overall risk of the investment portfolio. Additionally, bond funds often have access to institutional pricing, which means they can obtain better pricing on individual bonds compared to individual investors. Lower prices for bonds result in higher yields for investors.

Active Management and Risk Mitigation

The active management provided by professionals in bond funds can be particularly beneficial in riskier segments of the fixed-income market, such as high-yield bonds, bank loans, or preferred securities. These segments require a strong understanding of industry trends and credit analysis for successful navigation. Professional fund managers can actively buy or sell bonds based on economic conditions and interest rate environments, potentially increasing returns and income for investors. Their expertise helps mitigate risks and take advantage of market opportunities.

Convenience and Time Savings

Investing in bond funds can save investors a significant amount of time compared to managing individual bonds. Researching and analysing thousands of individual bonds and their issuers is a time-consuming task. Even after investing in a portfolio of individual bonds, the ongoing management and monitoring can be demanding. Professional management in bond funds relieves investors of this burden, allowing them to focus on their financial goals rather than day-to-day management.

Suitability for Financial Goals

The professional management aspect of bond funds makes them particularly suitable for investors seeking greater diversification and professional guidance to achieve their financial goals. If an investor's priority is predictable value and certainty, individual bonds may be a better option. However, for those who want their investments to be actively managed by professionals and benefit from broader diversification, bond funds are a more attractive choice.

Behavioural Considerations

Behavioural preferences also play a role in the decision between individual bonds and bond funds. Some investors may feel uncomfortable seeing the net asset value (NAV) of their fund fluctuate or having limited control over certain tax consequences. In such cases, individual bonds might be a more suitable option. Recognising how different investment choices align with one's behavioural preferences is essential for making informed decisions.

Bond funds are more accessible

Secondly, bond funds offer access to institutional pricing, which is typically more attractive than the pricing available to individual investors. Institutional investors, who purchase large quantities of bonds at once, benefit from economies of scale and can, therefore, obtain bonds at lower prices. This results in higher yields for bond funds compared to individual investors.

Thirdly, bond funds provide professional management, which can be beneficial for investors, especially in riskier segments of the fixed-income market, such as high-yield bonds, bank loans, or preferred securities. Actively managed bond funds allow fund managers to buy or sell bonds depending on the economic and interest rate environment, potentially increasing returns and income for investors.

Lastly, bond funds have lower minimum investment requirements than individual bonds. Individual bonds often have high denominations that can be cost-prohibitive for some investors. In contrast, bond funds are more accessible to a wider range of investors, allowing them to invest in a diversified portfolio of bonds with a smaller initial investment.

While there are benefits to investing in individual bonds, such as greater control and transparency, bond funds offer advantages in terms of accessibility, diversification, pricing, and professional management, making them a more inclusive investment option for those looking to enter the fixed-income market.

Bond funds offer access to institutional pricing

When you buy individual bonds, you are purchasing them as a single investor. This means that you are likely to receive less attractive pricing than institutional investors, who buy large quantities of bonds at one time. Bond funds, on the other hand, are able to access the more favourable pricing that institutional investors receive.

The price you pay for a bond is important because, all else being equal, a lower price means a higher yield. So, by offering access to institutional pricing, bond funds are able to provide higher yields than individual bonds.

Additionally, bond funds are often more cost-effective than individual bonds because they are managed by professionals who have the knowledge and expertise to navigate the nuances of the fixed-income market. This professional management can potentially increase returns and income by allowing the manager to buy or sell bonds depending on the economic and interest rate environment.

Furthermore, bond funds provide greater diversification per dollar invested. They give you exposure to a basket of bonds within the fund, which means you can achieve a diversified bond portfolio with a smaller investment. This diversification also reduces the impact of any single bond default.

While there are management fees associated with bond funds, the overall costs may still be lower than those of individual bonds, especially when you consider the significant amount of time and effort required to research and manage a strategy for individual bonds.

Bond funds are more tax-efficient

The tax consequences of investing in bond funds or individual bonds differ. Bond funds pool money to purchase the bonds in their portfolio. With pooled funds, your cost basis for tax purposes is more complicated than if you had purchased an individual bond and held it to maturity. Additionally, you have no control over the buying and selling of the individual bonds, which can lead to unexpected capital gain distributions at the end of the year. These capital gains distributions can be challenging to predict and plan for from a tax standpoint.

On the other hand, bond funds are generally more tax-efficient than maintaining an active bond strategy with individual bonds. Income from bond funds is primarily in the form of dividends, while individual bonds can generate capital gains.

Moreover, taxes are simpler for bond funds. If you invest in a bond fund in a taxable account, you receive tax forms from the bond fund company. If you have a portfolio of individual bonds, you receive tax forms from TreasuryDirect or your brokerage account, listing the tax-related items for each bond. It is easier to figure out the tax reporting for one bond fund versus many individual bonds.

Additionally, owners of individual Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS) owe tax on phantom income that they do not receive. This is not an issue with TIPS funds.

Frequently asked questions