Collateral Appraisal: Does Loan-To-Value Matter?

When applying for a loan, the lender will require an appraisal to determine the value of the property that will be used as collateral against the loan. This is known as the collateral value and is used by lenders to estimate the level of risk associated with a loan application. The collateral value is typically determined by looking at the recent sale prices of similar assets or having the asset appraised by a qualified expert. The appraisal process can help lenders understand how much an asset is worth and how much they can lend to the borrower. Therefore, the loan-to-value (LTV) ratio is an important metric that lenders consider when reviewing loan applications. The LTV compares the size of the loan to the value of the collateral. A higher LTV ratio indicates that the loan amount is closer to the value of the collateral, which may increase the risk for the lender.

Appraisal inaccuracies and how to address them

An inaccurate appraisal can have costly repercussions for mortgage brokers, real estate investors, and homeowners. It is therefore important to understand how a lender uses appraisals to determine things like your interest rate, required down payment, and approval of your loan.

For instance, if the appraisal value is too low, the lender might not give you enough money. On the other hand, if the listing price is too high, your property may never sell, and it will be a waste of time.

If you believe your property appraisal is inaccurate, suspect discrimination in the lending process, or have an appraisal-specific complaint, you should contact your lender to request a reconsideration of value, if they have a process to do so, or to file a complaint regarding the appraisal with the lender if they do not. If the lender does have a process for re-analyzing an appraisal, it is important to ask what information they will need and what their procedures are to request a reconsideration of value.

To prompt a lender to reassess a valuation due to potential inaccuracies, you should collect and provide any factual information that addresses your specific concerns to expedite this process.

Collateral value and how it's determined

The term collateral value refers to the fair market value of the assets used to secure a loan. Lenders use this value to estimate the level of risk associated with a particular loan application. For instance, in the case of a mortgage loan, lenders traditionally offer 80% financing, which means the borrower will need to provide a 20% down payment. The collateral value of the house is typically determined by relying on an appraiser who specializes in real estate. Other valuation metrics, such as recent tax assessments or comparable transactions, may also be consulted.

Collateral value is typically determined by looking at the recent sale prices of similar assets or having the asset appraised by a qualified expert. Various methods estimate collateral value, including reviewing comparable transactions, relying on tax assessments, and consulting with subject-matter experts. For example, if a loan is secured by publicly-traded stock, then the current market price of those securities can be used when estimating its collateral value.

Appraisers can value all kinds of assets, including used equipment, vacant land, and patents, that may eventually become loan collateral. In some cases, an appraiser may need to use specialized valuation methods, such as calculating the value of private shares by using discounted cash-flow analysis (DCF). Fine art and other rare items may need to be appraised by specialists familiar with the private collector and auction markets for those types of assets.

Appraisal boils down to three primary techniques: First, to determine the value of an asset, examine the cost to replace or reproduce it. Second, when valuing investments in private company stock, subtract liabilities from the combined fair market values of the company's assets. Third, an asset is worth as much as other assets with similar utility in the marketplace.

Loan-to-value ratio and its impact on lending decisions

The loan-to-value (LTV) ratio is a critical metric in lending decisions, particularly for secured loans. It represents the relationship between the loan amount and the value of the underlying collateral. A higher LTV indicates that the loan amount is closer to the collateral value, while a lower LTV suggests a safer distance between the loan and the collateral value.

Lenders rely on the LTV ratio to assess the risk associated with a loan application. A high LTV indicates a higher risk for the lender, as it implies that the borrower's equity in the collateral is limited. In contrast, a low LTV provides a greater cushion, reducing the lender's potential loss if the borrower defaults. For example, consider a home with a market value of $150,000. If the borrower takes out a mortgage loan of $130,000, the LTV is 87% ($130,000 / $150,000 * 100). This LTV suggests that the borrower has 13% equity in the property, which is the lender's protection against potential losses.

The LTV ratio is influenced by various factors, including the collateral value, the loan amount, and the down payment. Lenders typically seek an LTV that aligns with their risk appetite and the specific loan product. For instance, mortgage loans traditionally have an LTV of around 80%, requiring a 20% down payment from the borrower. However, the actual LTV offered can vary based on market conditions, the borrower's credit rating, and the reliability of the collateral value.

Appraisals play a pivotal role in determining the LTV ratio. An appraisal provides an independent assessment of the collateral's fair market value. Lenders rely on these valuations to ensure they don't lend more than the collateral is worth. Accurate appraisals are essential, as they directly impact the loan amount the borrower can qualify for and help protect the lender from excessive risk exposure. If a borrower believes an appraisal is inaccurate, they can request a reconsideration of value or file a complaint with the lender or the relevant regulatory body.

In summary, the LTV ratio is a cornerstone of lending decisions, guiding lenders in assessing the risk associated with a loan application. By comparing the loan amount to the collateral value, lenders can make informed choices about the loan's viability and set appropriate terms to mitigate potential losses. A diligent appraisal process is crucial to establishing a reliable LTV ratio, ensuring that lending decisions are grounded in accurate valuations of the collateral.

The role of appraisers and their qualifications

An appraiser is a professional who determines the market value of an asset. They are expected to act independently of the buying and selling parties in a transaction, and their opinion about the real and fair value of an appraised asset must be unbiased. They use their analytical skills to evaluate and assign value to a product, piece of machinery, intellectual property, real estate, or commercial entity.

Appraisers play a critical role in the real estate industry by providing an unbiased opinion of property values, which is essential to buyers, sellers, and lenders. They have in-depth knowledge of the real estate market and the laws governing them. Their job is to provide unbiased opinions of value, backed by data and analysis. The appraisal report includes all the essential details an interested party would want to know regarding the property's value, including its current condition, location, upgrades, and relevant market data.

Appraisers can also help evaluate reorganization alternatives, including the long-term effects on future cash flow. They can help lenders understand how much cash a borrower is likely to receive under various liquidation scenarios. Appraisers can also help determine the value of a business or specific items of value within a business.

The role of an appraiser requires specific qualifications and training. Appraisers must be licensed by their state to practice their profession. This means having a certain degree of education and experience and taking and passing an exam by the state licensing board. The Appraiser Qualifications Board (AQB) establishes minimum educational requirements, which include 75 hours of education for a licensed residential appraiser, 150 hours for a certified residential appraiser, and 200 hours for a certified general real property appraiser. Appraisers must also complete continuing education courses to maintain their licensure.

Regulatory requirements for collateral evaluations

In 1992, the FCA issued subpart F of part 614, "Collateral Evaluation Requirements", which sets out the minimum regulatory standards for performing appraisals and evaluations of collateral that secures extensions of credit (lending and leasing) by Farm Credit banks and associations. The 1992 rulemaking applied many of the evaluation standards used by the banking industry under Title XI of FIRREA, including requiring the use of USPAP in certain loan transactions.

The FCA's collateral evaluation regulations define an "evaluation" as either a collateral valuation or a collateral appraisal. An appraisal is a written statement of opinion on the market value of a property, while a valuation is an estimate of a property's value. A qualified evaluator is defined as an individual who is competent, reputable, impartial, and has demonstrated sufficient training and experience in evaluating property of the type that is the subject of the collateral evaluation.

The regulations provide a basic framework for policies, but it is an institution's responsibility to address the timing and frequency of new or updated collateral evaluations and the level of detail each type of evaluation must have to support credit decisions. Institutions must also monitor market conditions, loan risk, and collateral conditions to determine the frequency of new and/or updated valuations or appraisals.

The FCA's collateral evaluation regulations do not require the use of specific underwriting ratios except as required by statute, such as an 85% loan-to-value ratio on long-term real estate loans. Institutions may include industry-established norms and value guides in their internal guidelines, but the FCA expects them to document the sources of such information if used to establish and support a market value.

The FCA proposes that System lenders provide a copy of a collateral appraisal or evaluation within 7 days of the request. This fixed time ensures that applicants and borrowers receive the report within a reasonable time to make informed decisions or exercise review rights. The FCA also proposes that the appraisal or evaluation copies provided to applicants and borrowers contain all the information required by regulation or USPAP.

Reviewers of collateral appraisals do not need to meet State certification or licensing requirements. However, to adjust an appraisal, the reviewer must meet the respective State certification or licensing requirements, comply with USPAP Standard 3 (Appraisal Review, Development, and Reporting), and have the appropriate expertise to make adjustments.

Frequently asked questions