Understanding Rental Property Mortgage Debt On Your Fafsa

When it comes to applying for financial aid for college, a student's assets are scrutinized much more harshly than their parents' assets. The FAFSA (Free Application for Federal Student Aid) asks about income and assets, but not all funds are treated equally. For example, a primary residence or family farm is not included as an asset on the FAFSA, but a second home or investment property is. Rental properties are usually considered investments, not businesses, unless they are part of a formally recognized business that provides additional services. If a rental property is reported on Schedule C of the IRS 1040 form, it is likely a business asset and can be excluded from the FAFSA. However, if it is reported on Schedule E, it is an investment that must be included in the FAFSA.

Rental properties are considered investments, not businesses

Rental properties are generally considered investments, not businesses, by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). This classification is important, as it impacts the tax deductions that landlords can receive.

The IRS deems a rental real estate enterprise (RREE) to be a trade or business if the taxpayer meets certain requirements, including maintaining separate books and records, performing at least 250 hours of rental services per year, and keeping logs and time reports. However, in practice, landlords who own a small number of rental properties and do not actively manage them are often considered investors by the IRS.

For example, in the case of Grier v. United States (1954), the IRS and court found that a single rental property was an investment, not a business, as the landlord's activities were minimal. The court noted that the landlord only had one rental property and did not spend a significant amount of time managing it, which led to the conclusion that it was an investment.

Similarly, if a landlord rents to friends or family, or if the rental property is vacant most of the time, the IRS may consider the landlord an investor rather than a business owner. This is because the landlord is not actively involved in managing the property and does not spend a substantial amount of time dealing with it.

In contrast, landlords who actively manage their rental properties, spend a significant amount of time and effort on maintenance and management, and aim to earn a profit are more likely to be considered a business by the IRS.

It is important to note that the distinction between investment and business can impact tax deductions and financial aid eligibility, so landlords should carefully consider their classification and seek professional advice if needed.

Rental property mortgage debt impact on eligibility for need-based financial aid

When determining eligibility for need-based financial aid, colleges consider a family's income and assets. While a family's primary residence is not included as an asset on the FAFSA, the net worth of any rental properties is.

Rental properties are usually considered investments, not businesses, unless they are part of a formally recognised business that provides additional services, such as a hotel with a maid service. If a rental property is reported on Schedule C of the IRS 1040 form, it is likely a business asset and can be excluded from the FAFSA. However, colleges will still want to ensure it qualifies as a business.

If a rental property is reported on Schedule E, it is considered an investment and must be included in the FAFSA. To obtain the net worth of a rental property, subtract the property's value from its outstanding debt. If the debt exceeds the value, report zero, not a negative number. If multiple properties are owned and one has a negative net worth, do not subtract that value from the net worth of the other properties. It is still treated as having a net worth of zero.

Any mortgages secured by investment real estate will reduce the net worth of the asset. However, if a mortgage on the primary residence was used to buy a rental property, that mortgage does not reduce the net worth of the rental property because it is not secured by the rental property.

Additionally, it is important to note that parental assets may have some impact on financial aid eligibility, but they typically have a smaller impact than student-owned assets. Furthermore, the FAFSA formula protects a portion of parents' non-retirement assets, so these may have an even lesser impact. To maximise financial aid eligibility, it is crucial to understand which assets are counted by FAFSA and to avoid declaring unnecessary assets. One strategy to shelter assets is to move funds into a custodial 529 college savings plan.

Rental property reported on Schedule C of the IRS 1040 form

When it comes to financial aid applications, real estate can take different forms, including a primary residence, a second home or investment, or a business property. While a family's primary residence is not included as an asset on the FAFSA, rental properties are typically considered investments, not businesses, unless they are part of a formally recognised business that provides additional services, such as a hotel with maid service.

Rental income and expenses are generally reported using Schedule E (Form 1040), Supplemental Income and Loss. This form is used to report income or loss from rental real estate, royalties, partnerships, S corporations, estates, trusts, and residual interests in real estate mortgage investment conduits (REMICs). However, if a rental property is reported on Schedule C of the IRS 1040 form, it is likely considered a business asset and can be excluded from the FAFSA. Schedule C (Form 1040) is used to report income and expenses for those in the business of renting personal property and providing substantial services primarily for the tenant's convenience.

It's important to note that colleges will still want to ensure that the rental property qualifies as a business. The taxpayer must provide "significant services," such as regular cleaning, to exclude the rental property from the FAFSA. On the other hand, if a property is reported on Schedule E, it is considered an investment and must be included in the FAFSA.

When determining financial aid, colleges use the asset information from the FAFSA to calculate financial aid eligibility. However, not all funds are treated equally. While parental assets may have some impact on financial aid eligibility, they generally have a more limited impact than student-owned assets, as parents are expected to contribute a smaller proportion of their wealth to their child's college education.

Rental property reported on Schedule E of the IRS 1040 form

The FAFSA (Free Application for Federal Student Aid) is used to determine federal financial aid, including grants, loans, and work-study. Colleges use the asset information from the FAFSA to calculate financial aid eligibility. However, not all funds are treated equally. Determining financial aid is based on a family's "need", which is determined by looking at a family's income and assets.

Rental properties are typically considered investments, not businesses, unless they are part of a formally recognized business that provides additional services, such as a hotel with maid service. If a rental property is reported on Schedule C of the IRS 1040 form, it is likely a business asset and can be excluded from the FAFSA. However, if a rental property is reported on Schedule E, it is considered an investment and must be included in the FAFSA. Schedule E (Form 1040) is used to report income or loss from rental real estate, royalties, partnerships, S corporations, estates, trusts, and residual interests in real estate mortgage investment conduits (REMICs). It is important to note that rental properties are not considered small businesses, and their value must be reported on the FAFSA, along with any outstanding debts.

Primary residence not included as an asset on the FAFSA

The net worth of a family's primary residence is not reported as an asset on the FAFSA. This is because the Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA) is used to determine federal financial aid, including grants, loans, and work-study, based on a family's "need". However, the net worth of the primary residence is reported as an asset on the College Board's CSS Profile application, which is used by some colleges to determine financial need.

On the CSS Profile, families are asked to provide details to determine the home equity value of their primary residence. This is because some colleges want a more complete picture of a family’s financial status. Not all CSS Profile universities handle home equity in the same way. Some ignore it, some cap the home equity value at double the family’s income, and others don’t cap the amount. If a college calculates home equity, 5% is added to the Expected Family Contribution (EFC).

The FAFSA formula protects a portion of parents' non-retirement assets, so these may have a limited impact on financial aid eligibility. This is because parents are expected to contribute a smaller proportion of their wealth to pay for their child's college education. The FAFSA assumes parents should use up to 5.64% of their unprotected assets to help their child pay for college.

To shelter assets on the FAFSA and maximize financial aid eligibility, parents can employ several strategies. These include shifting reportable assets into non-reportable assets, reducing reportable assets by using them to pay down debt, and shifting reportable assets from the student’s name to the parent’s name. Necessary expenses, such as maintenance and replacement of equipment, may also be accelerated so that the money is spent before the FAFSA is filed.

Frequently asked questions