Hedging Investment Risk: Strategies To Protect Your Portfolio

Investing is inherently risky, but there are strategies that can help reduce the risk of loss. One such strategy is hedging, which involves buying or selling an investment to reduce the risk of loss of an existing position. Hedging is not a commonly used strategy among individual investors, and it is typically implemented after an initial investment is made. There are several common hedging strategies, including short selling, buying put options, selling futures contracts, and using inverse ETFs. Hedging requires paying a premium for protection, and it often results in a reduction in potential profits. It is important to note that hedging is a complex strategy that may involve advanced investment vehicles and additional costs. While it can help protect against losses, it may not always be effective and can be challenging to implement correctly.

Hedging with derivatives

Derivatives are financial tools that derive their value from an underlying asset, such as stocks, bonds, commodities, or currencies. They are commonly used as a form of investment to reduce the risk of unexpected price changes of an asset, and they invariably move in the same direction as the underlying asset. Derivatives can be used to hedge against various types of risks, including interest rate risk, currency risk, and commodity price risk.

One of the most common methods of hedging is through derivatives such as options, swaps, futures, and forward contracts. The availability of various derivative contracts enables investors to hedge against almost any kind of investment, including stocks, commodities, indices, currencies, bonds, or interest rates. Derivatives are effective hedges against their underlying assets.

For example, an investor who owns shares of the S&P 500 index may wish to minimise the risk of a drop in the index's price. To do this, the investor could purchase a put option, which gives them the right to sell their shares at a preset price, known as the strike price. No matter how low the S&P 500 index falls before the option expires, the investor can sell their shares at the strike price, thus hedging their position and protecting themselves from losses below the strike price.

Another example is the use of currency derivatives to hedge against exchange rate risk. If a British investor with accounts in sterling wants to buy shares of a US company using dollars, they are exposed to exchange rate risk. To eliminate this risk, the investor can buy a currency derivative to secure a fixed exchange rate and protect their funds.

It is important to note that hedging with derivatives comes at a cost. Investing in hedging leaves less money to invest in the asset being hedged. Additionally, derivatives can increase or decrease the risk in a portfolio, depending on how they are used. When purchasing a put option for an asset, known as a protective put, the only potential downside is the cost of the premium paid for the option. On the other hand, selling a call option on a position you do not own could result in unlimited risk, as you may be forced to buy the underlying security at a higher price to fulfil your obligation to the contract holder.

To safely use derivatives as a hedge, your derivative exposure should never exceed the value of the underlying asset in your portfolio. For instance, if you hold $10,000 worth of the S&P 500, you should not sell more than $10,000 worth of S&P 500 futures to avoid risking more than you possess.

Hedging through diversification

Hedging and diversification are two strategies that work together to create a well-rounded risk management plan for investors and traders. While hedging involves taking an offsetting position to reduce the potential impact of adverse price movements, diversification involves spreading your investments across different asset classes, sectors, and geographical regions to reduce the impact of any single investment on your overall portfolio.

Benefits of Diversification

• Reduced Risk: By diversifying your portfolio, you can decrease the likelihood of being heavily impacted by a downturn in a particular sector or asset class. For example, if you invest in multiple industries, bonds, real estate, or alternative investments, a decline in one sector or asset class may be offset by gains in another.
• Enhanced Stability: Diversification helps to stabilise your portfolio by ensuring that not all your investments are performing well or poorly at the same time. This reduces your exposure to any one market, sector, or asset class.
• Long-Term Returns: While diversification may limit potential gains in the short term, it can also enhance your long-term returns by reducing the impact of adverse market movements.

Tips for Effective Diversification

• Research: Before diversifying your portfolio, conduct thorough research on the assets or investments you plan to include. Understand the fundamentals, market trends, and potential risks associated with each investment to make informed decisions.
• Regular Review and Rebalancing: Markets are constantly changing, so it's important to regularly review and rebalance your portfolio to ensure it aligns with your risk tolerance and investment goals. This may involve buying or selling investments to maintain the desired level of risk and diversification.
• Seek Professional Advice: If you are unsure about implementing a diversification strategy, consider seeking advice from a financial advisor or professional who specialises in risk management. They can help you assess your risk tolerance, develop a suitable strategy, and monitor your portfolio's performance.

Case Study: 2008 Financial Crisis

The 2008 financial crisis is a notable example of the importance of diversification. Many investors heavily concentrated in the housing market suffered significant losses. In contrast, those who had diversified their portfolios across different asset classes, such as stocks, bonds, and commodities, were better positioned to weather the crisis.

Diversification is a powerful tool for mitigating risks in financial markets. By spreading your investments and reducing your exposure to any one investment, you can enhance the stability of your portfolio and potentially improve your long-term returns. Remember to conduct thorough research, regularly review and rebalance your portfolio, and consider seeking professional advice to ensure your diversification strategy aligns with your financial goals.

Hedging with options

There are two main types of options: call options and put options. Call options allow investors to buy an asset at a predetermined price and are typically purchased when there is an expectation of the asset's price increase. Put options, on the other hand, give investors the right to sell an asset at a predetermined price, usually when a drop in the asset's price is anticipated.

When hedging with options, investors open one or more positions that offset the risk associated with an existing trade. While hedging strategies cannot completely eliminate risk, they can limit it to a known amount. The key idea is that if one position declines in value, the other position(s) will ideally make a profit, creating a net zero effect or even a net profit.

To implement a hedging strategy with options, investors should follow these steps:

• Identify the Risk: Assess your investment portfolio to identify assets that are exposed to significant risk, such as stocks, exchange-traded funds (ETFs), commodities, or other assets.
• Choose the Right Option: Determine whether a call or put option aligns with your hedging needs. For example, if you want to hedge against a stock price drop, buying a put option may be suitable.
• Select the Strike Price and Expiry: Choose a strike price, which is the price at which the option can be exercised, and an expiry date that aligns with your anticipated timeline and price level for the potential risk.
• Monitor and Adjust: Once the hedge is in place, monitor it regularly and make adjustments as necessary to maintain the desired level of protection.

It is important to remember that options come with their own risks and costs. The premium paid for the option could result in a loss if the price movement doesn't align with expectations. Additionally, there is a timing risk, especially with European options, where you can only exercise the option on the expiration date.

Hedging with volatility indicators

Volatility indicators are a popular hedging strategy to reduce market risk. Investors can make trades based on market volatility by tracking the volatility index indicator, the VIX, often referred to as the "fear index" or "fear gauge" due to its tendency to spike during periods of greater volatility. The VIX measures the implied volatility of at-the-money calls and puts on the S&P 500 index. Generally, a level below 20 indicates low volatility, while a level of 30 is very volatile.

There are exchange-traded funds (ETFs) that track the VIX, and investors can use ETF shares or options to go long on the VIX as a volatility-specific hedge. Volatility strategies are often attractive for diversification, as volatility is broadly negatively correlated to economic growth. When the economy is growing, economic and financial volatility tend to decline, and vice versa.

However, it is important to note that while these tools are powerful, they cannot eliminate all market risk. Additionally, hedging strategies come with costs, such as premium amounts and lost profits, and may reduce potential profits. Therefore, investors should carefully consider if the potential benefits of hedging justify the expenses.

Hedging with portfolio construction

Hedging is a risk management strategy employed to offset losses in investments by taking an opposite position in a related asset. In the context of portfolio construction, hedging involves using financial instruments or market strategies to protect against adverse price movements and reduce exposure to risk.

For example, a portfolio manager may utilise derivatives such as options and futures contracts to hedge against potential losses. By employing these strategies, the manager can construct a portfolio that is better protected against negative events, thus reducing the impact on their finances.

One technique is to use a 'safe harbour' portfolio with a low directional market tilt and low leverage. This type of portfolio construction aims to minimise volatility and reduce the overall costs associated with the manager's beta. Absolute return hedge funds often use this approach to create a stable component within their overall strategy.

Another approach is to use optimisation tools to build a long/short equity basket. This basket is designed to reduce the portfolio's net exposure to market factors or to prevent unwanted style drift. By doing so, traders can construct books that are more aligned with their initial market or company-specific views, leading to a clearer allocation of the risk budget.

Additionally, hedging can be achieved by investing in multiple players within a given industry. While this doesn't eliminate industry-wide risks, it helps address company-specific risks. For instance, investing in competing airlines can offset losses if one airline underperforms, as the other may benefit from increased market share.

It is important to remember that hedging requires paying a premium, and the reduction in risk typically results in a reduction in potential profits. Therefore, hedging is primarily a technique to mitigate potential losses rather than maximise gains.

Frequently asked questions