Bitcoin: Currency Or Investment?

Bitcoin is a decentralised digital currency that has sparked a debate about whether it should be classified as an investment or a currency. On the one hand, Bitcoin can be used as a medium of exchange for goods and services, and its credibility as a medium of exchange has been enhanced by the growing number of companies that accept it as a form of payment. On the other hand, Bitcoin is subject to high price volatility, which undermines its ability to serve as a stable store of value, a key function of currency. As a result, many people are buying Bitcoin as a speculative investment, hoping for returns as its value increases.

Bitcoin as a currency

Bitcoin is a decentralised digital currency that can be used for peer-to-peer transactions without the need for intermediaries like banks. It is a virtual currency stored in a digital wallet in cyberspace, which can be accessed with a computer or smartphone app.

Bitcoin can be used as a medium of exchange for a limited number of goods and services. Its credibility as a medium of exchange was given a boost when Richard Branson accepted Bitcoin as payment from the Winklevoss twins for a ride on his spacecraft. The number of companies that accept Bitcoin has been growing, but these transactions still represent a tiny part of the economy.

Bitcoin can be considered a currency because it meets the criteria of money. It is scarce, divisible, portable, and durable. It also has acceptability and uniformity. Bitcoin is also built on blockchain technology, which means that each transaction exists on a publicly accessible ledger, making it almost impossible to reverse or fake any transaction.

Bitcoin's value is determined by supply and demand. While the demand for Bitcoin has grown as people speculate on its future value, the supply of Bitcoin is set to grow at an inflexible, predetermined rate. As a result, as demand for Bitcoin has fluctuated, so has its price.

Bitcoin's characteristics as a financial asset have drawn the interest of many, but it is not a stable store of value and is highly volatile. Its value is not backed by any government or institution, and there is nothing to guarantee its value except the proof baked into the system.

Bitcoin as an investment

Bitcoin has been described as one of the best investments in the world since its creation in 2009. It is the most well-known and widely used cryptocurrency, with a market cap of over $360 billion. In a little over a decade, its value has skyrocketed, reaching a high of about $69,000 in November 2021.

Bitcoin's price is highly volatile, and its value can fluctuate drastically. This volatility presents opportunities for significant profits but also poses a risk of substantial losses. Its price is influenced by various factors, including market demand, government regulations, technological advancements, and investor sentiment.

One of the main attractions of Bitcoin as an investment is its decentralised nature and fixed supply, which means it is not subject to the same inflationary pressures as traditional currencies. Its limited supply also creates scarcity, making it a potentially attractive hedge against inflation and a store of value. However, its extreme volatility has limited its appeal in this regard.

Another advantage of Bitcoin is its liquidity. It is a highly liquid investment asset that can be easily traded for cash or other assets, with low fees. Additionally, Bitcoin's blockchain technology ensures secure transactions without the need for trusted third-party involvement.

However, there are several risks associated with investing in Bitcoin. Firstly, it is subject to regulatory risk as governments and regulators may impose restrictions on its use. Secondly, there is a significant security risk as Bitcoin exchanges are vulnerable to hacking, malware, and operational glitches. Thirdly, Bitcoin is not insured by the Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC) or the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), although some exchanges provide private insurance.

Furthermore, determining Bitcoin's true value is challenging due to its lack of cash flow, revenue, or physical assets. Its price is solely driven by investor sentiment, which can be unpredictable. Additionally, Bitcoin poses a significant environmental risk, as its mining process produces about 40 billion tons of carbon dioxide annually.

Despite the risks, some experts remain bullish on Bitcoin's long-term prospects. They argue that its decentralised nature and resistance to manipulation and fraud make it a secure investment. Additionally, its scarcity and the potential for widespread adoption could drive up demand and prices.

Overall, whether Bitcoin is a good investment depends on your financial profile, risk tolerance, and investment goals. It is crucial to carefully consider the risks and conduct thorough research before investing in this highly volatile asset.

Bitcoin's volatility

Bitcoin's value has fluctuated wildly since its inception, with its price often rising and falling dramatically. For example, in 2017, Bitcoin experienced five episodes of at least 20% losses in what market watchers describe as a "bear market". This volatility has made it difficult for Bitcoin to serve as a stable store of value, a key function of currency. Economist Robert Shiller says this volatility damages Bitcoin's credibility as a store of value and is a major hurdle to its acceptance as a currency.

The volatile nature of Bitcoin is due in part to its decentralised structure. Unlike traditional currencies, which are typically backed by a government or central bank that can adjust the money supply to stabilise its value, Bitcoin is not controlled by any central authority. Instead, its value is determined solely by supply and demand. As a result, when demand for Bitcoin fluctuates, so does its price.

Another factor contributing to Bitcoin's volatility is its limited supply. There will only ever be 21 million bitcoins in existence, and as the supply of unrewarded coins diminishes, demand increases, driving up prices.

The speculative nature of Bitcoin investing also contributes to its volatility. Investors often buy and sell Bitcoin based on short-term price movements, hoping to profit from its fluctuations. This can lead to further price swings and increase the risk of large losses for those holding the asset.

While Bitcoin's volatility can be a drawback for those seeking a stable store of value, some investors view it as an opportunity for significant gains. However, it is essential to approach Bitcoin with caution and recognise that it is a highly speculative asset.

Bitcoin's advantages

Bitcoin is a decentralised digital currency that can be bought, sold, and exchanged directly without an intermediary like a bank. It was introduced to the public in 2009 by an anonymous developer or group of developers using the name Satoshi Nakamoto. Here are some advantages of using Bitcoin:

Cost-efficient transactions

Bitcoin transactions can be done anytime, anywhere, reducing the time and potential expense of any transaction. The transactional cost with the help of cryptocurrency can be minimal or zero as it eliminates the need for third parties like VISA to confirm transactions.

Privacy

Bitcoin transactions do not contain personal information, such as a name or credit card number. While it’s still possible to link a certain person to a certain wallet, transactions are generally more private than credit card transactions, for example.

Decentralisation

After the financial crisis and the Great Recession, some investors are eager to embrace an alternative, decentralised currency—one that is essentially outside the control of regular banks, governing authorities, or other third parties.

Growth potential

Some investors who buy and hold the currency are betting that once Bitcoin matures, greater trust and more widespread use will follow, and therefore Bitcoin’s value will grow.

Bitcoin's disadvantages

Bitcoin is a digital currency or "cryptocurrency" that enables person-to-person transactions independent of the banking system. However, it has several disadvantages. Here are some of the key drawbacks:

Not Widely Accepted

Bitcoins are still only accepted by a small group of online merchants, making it impractical to rely on them as a primary currency. There is also a possibility that governments might intervene and force merchants not to use Bitcoins to ensure transaction traceability.

Extreme Price Volatility

The value of Bitcoins is highly volatile and subject to constant fluctuations according to demand. This can cause confusion in refund situations and when comparing valuations. The constant price changes can also make it challenging for retailers to set prices, as they have to frequently recalculate their Bitcoin prices.

Irreversible Transactions

When goods are purchased using Bitcoins, and the seller fails to deliver the promised goods, there is currently no way to reverse the transaction. While this issue can be mitigated by using a third-party escrow service, it introduces an intermediary similar to traditional banking, defeating one of the key advantages of Bitcoin.

Security Risks and Technical Flaws

The Bitcoin system is susceptible to hacking attacks, thefts, and other security issues. Additionally, as a new system, there may be unknown technical flaws that, if exploited, could cause significant damage to the Bitcoin economy.

Environmental Concerns

Bitcoin mining, the process of verifying transactions and creating new blocks in the blockchain, requires solving complex mathematical problems, which demands significant computational power and energy consumption. As the Bitcoin network expands, energy consumption is likely to increase, leading to heightened environmental concerns.

Regulatory Uncertainty

The lack of central authority governing Bitcoins means there is no guarantee of a minimum valuation. If a large group of merchants or investors suddenly decides to abandon Bitcoin, its value could plummet, hurting those with significant wealth invested in Bitcoins.

Frequently asked questions