Cryptocurrency And Islam: Halal Investment Opportunities?

The question of whether investing in cryptocurrency is halal or haram is a complex one, and has sparked intense debate among Islamic scholars, economists, and jurists. Cryptocurrency is a digital currency exchange and digital payments platform that uses blockchain technology. It is a high-risk, high-reward investment, and its decentralised nature means it is not controlled by a central authority such as a government.

One of the key issues in the debate is whether cryptocurrency constitutes Māl, or something that can be possessed or stored for later use according to Islamic law. Some argue that it does not, as it is not a physical entity, while others say that it is a digital asset with value to individuals and businesses, and therefore qualifies as Māl.

Another issue is that cryptocurrency can be used for illegal activities, and is often used for makruh or haram purchases. It is also highly volatile and speculative, which some argue makes it akin to gambling—an activity that is forbidden in Islam.

However, others argue that all financial assets are speculative, and that the absence of a central authority enhances the value of cryptos as currencies. They also point out that cryptocurrency does not generate interest, or riba, which is haram.

Overall, the question of whether investing in cryptocurrency is halal or haram remains unresolved, and the global Muslim investment community continues to be deeply divided on the issue.

Cryptocurrency is a high-risk investment similar to gambling

There are differing opinions on whether investing in cryptocurrency is halal or haram. One of the main reasons for this debate is that cryptocurrency is a high-risk investment, similar to gambling, which is forbidden in Islam.

Cryptocurrency is a high-risk investment because its value is extremely volatile. For example, between November 2021 and June 2022, the value of Bitcoin dropped from almost £50,000 to less than £15,500. This volatility means that investing in cryptocurrency is a gamble—you could make a lot of money, or you could lose everything. In fact, some experts compare it to the Wild West of gambling, with criminals running the gambling houses or even surrounding them.

Because of the high risk of losing money, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) considers cryptocurrency a high-risk investment. Additionally, if something goes wrong, you are unlikely to be protected. This is another reason why investing in cryptocurrency is like gambling—you are taking a chance and betting that nothing will go wrong.

However, it is important to note that the level of risk involved in investing in cryptocurrency depends on your strategy. If you are buying crypto for the sole purpose of trying to get rich overnight, then it is more like gambling. But if you truly believe that cryptocurrency is the way of the future and will be around for decades to come, then buying it now could be considered more of an investment. By being strategic and careful about how you invest in cryptocurrency, it is possible to reduce your risk.

It's not a true currency

Cryptocurrency is not a true currency because it is not issued by a central authority, such as a government or bank, and is not widely accepted as a medium of exchange.

Firstly, cryptocurrency is not issued by a central authority. It is created through a process called mining, which involves using computer power to solve complicated mathematical problems that generate coins. This means that cryptocurrency is not backed by any government or central bank, which is a key feature of traditional currencies.

Additionally, cryptocurrency is not widely accepted as a medium of exchange. While some businesses, such as Microsoft and AT&T, accept Bitcoin as a form of payment, it is not commonly used for daily transactions. This is partly because the value of cryptocurrency is highly volatile, making it a risky investment. The lack of widespread acceptance and the volatility of its value mean that cryptocurrency cannot be relied upon as a stable medium of exchange.

Furthermore, the use of cryptocurrency has been associated with illegal activities, such as money laundering and illicit purchases. This is because transactions made using cryptocurrency are difficult to trace and can be made anonymously. As a result, some countries, such as China, have banned the use of cryptocurrency, further limiting its acceptance as a legitimate form of currency.

Finally, the value of cryptocurrency is highly speculative and subject to significant price swings. This means that investing in cryptocurrency is risky and may not be suitable for all investors. The speculative nature of cryptocurrency also makes it similar to gambling, which is forbidden in Islam.

In conclusion, cryptocurrency cannot be considered a true currency because it lacks the key features of traditional currencies, such as being issued by a central authority and widely accepted as a medium of exchange. Instead, it is a speculative investment that may not be suitable for everyone.

It's not regulated by governments or financial bodies

The unregulated nature of cryptocurrency is one of the main reasons why some Muslims consider it haram. The lack of oversight from governments or financial bodies means that cryptocurrencies can be used for illegal activities, such as money laundering, contraband trade, and funding for drugs or other crimes.

Cryptocurrency is also highly volatile and speculative, making it similar to gambling, which is forbidden in Islam. The decentralised nature of cryptocurrencies means that they are not controlled by a legitimate central authority, and this lack of regulation can make it difficult to determine their intrinsic value.

Some Muslims are open to the idea of cryptocurrency becoming accepted if it were better regulated. For example, regulation could enable governments and banks to treat crypto as sharf—the exchange of foreign currency (crypto) into local currency (cash). This could reduce the uncertainty and risk associated with crypto and make it more permissible according to Islamic law.

The unregulated nature of cryptocurrency is a significant concern for those who consider it haram. However, it is important to note that the views on this matter vary among Islamic scholars and jurists, with some arguing that the absence of a central authority enhances the value of cryptos as currencies.

It can be used for illegal activities

The anonymous nature of cryptocurrency transactions makes it an attractive option for those looking to engage in illegal activities. While transactions are recorded on a public blockchain, the identities of those involved are kept hidden, allowing for seemingly anonymous trading of drugs, weapons, explosives, and child pornography. This anonymity also enables terrorists to ask for funding and donations for extremist organizations without revealing their identities.

The peer-to-peer nature of cryptocurrency transactions means that no prior acquaintance or third-party mediator is required, making it easier for criminals to sell drugs or digital data, such as child pornography, and transfer funds across borders for terrorist activities. Cryptocurrency transactions are also incredibly fast and irreversible, enabling new types of crimes such as scams and social media hacks. For example, in 2020, a Twitter hack compromised several high-profile accounts, including those of Joe Biden, Barack Obama, and Bill Gates, to promote a cryptocurrency scam, resulting in the fraudsters receiving over $100,000 worth of Bitcoins.

The ease of storage and transfer of cryptocurrencies further adds to their appeal for illegal activities. As digital assets, they require no physical storage space and can be easily stored in a crypto wallet, reducing the risk of theft or detection by authorities. Cryptocurrencies can also be quickly and easily transferred globally, enabling international trading and trafficking. For instance, Lazarus Group, a cybercrime organization with ties to North Korea, stole $275 million in cryptocurrency from the KuCoin exchange in 2020, laundering the funds through mixers and decentralized platforms.

The lack of central authority and regulation in the cryptocurrency space has made it challenging for law enforcement agencies to track and investigate illicit transactions. However, there have been some successes, such as the seizure of over $3.5 billion worth of cryptocurrency by the IRS Criminal Investigations division in 2021. While the growth of legitimate cryptocurrency usage has far outpaced the growth of criminal usage, the increasing sophistication of cybercriminals and the large volume of illicit transactions remain significant concerns.

It has no intrinsic value

The debate on whether cryptocurrencies are halal or haram under Islamic law is ongoing. One of the main points of contention is that cryptocurrencies lack intrinsic value. Here is a detailed exploration of this issue.

The Argument Against Cryptocurrency

Some Islamic scholars argue that cryptocurrencies may not qualify as true currency under Islamic finance rules because they lack intrinsic value. This is because cryptocurrencies are intangible and are not backed by any precious metal or commodity. In other words, they are not based on any "real value". This is in contrast to gold, silver, or real estate, which are considered tangible assets with intrinsic worth.

The Impact on Shariah Compliance

The lack of intrinsic value in cryptocurrencies poses challenges in aligning them with Islamic finance principles. Islamic finance emphasizes the importance of tangible assets, and this raises concerns about the acceptance of cryptocurrencies in compliance with Shariah law.

The Counterargument

On the other hand, some scholars argue that the lack of intrinsic value in cryptocurrencies does not necessarily make them haram. For example, Ziyaad Mahomed, Shariah Committee Chairman of HSBC Amanah Malaysia Bhd, claims that while gold and silver are unambiguously permissible as currencies in Islam, the Sharia doesn’t require that a currency have intrinsic value. Instead, all that is important is that there is social acceptance of the currency's value and that it can be used in transactions.

A Note of Caution

While Mahomed acknowledges the validity of this argument, he also points out that when cryptocurrencies become excessively volatile, with retail investors driving irrational increases in price, the trading in cryptocurrencies could be seen as more questionable. This highlights the importance of considering the level of volatility and social acceptance of a cryptocurrency when determining its permissibility under Islamic law.

In conclusion, while the lack of intrinsic value in cryptocurrencies may be a cause for concern from an Islamic perspective, it is not necessarily a determining factor in their permissibility. Other factors, such as the level of volatility and social acceptance, also play a role in evaluating their compliance with Islamic finance principles.

Frequently asked questions