Apple Stock: High Risk, High Reward?

Apple has been a dominant player in the tech world, with its iconic products like the iPhone and Apple Watch, but is investing in the company high risk? In recent years, Apple's stock has seen impressive gains, but there are several factors that investors should consider when evaluating the risks associated with investing in the company. One of the biggest risks is Apple's heavy reliance on iPhone sales, which account for a significant portion of its revenues. A slowdown in the smartphone market or increased competition from emerging players could impact Apple's performance. Additionally, Apple's supply chain concentration, particularly its reliance on China for manufacturing, has posed challenges in the past and continues to be a concern. While Apple has a strong financial position with substantial cash reserves, its high valuation and focus on financial engineering through stock buybacks rather than long-term investments may increase risk for investors.

Apple's reliance on iPhone sales

In India, Apple's reliance on iPhone sales is even more pronounced. In 2023, Apple sold 9.24 million iPhones in the country, contributing to a revenue of over INR660 billion (US$8 billion) in the first 11 months of fiscal 2024. Other Apple products, such as iPads, MacBooks, and Macs, witnessed declining sales in India, leading to a higher dependence on iPhones for the company's performance in this market. iPhone's share in Apple's Indian revenue increased from about 85% to over 90%, while in the global market, iPhones generated about 50% of Apple's sales.

The success of iPhone sales in India can be attributed to the surging sales of premium smartphone models, while other Apple products experienced declining sales. The strong performance of iPhones in India has benefited contract manufacturers such as Foxconn, Pegatron, and Wistron, who have met production targets under the Production Linked Incentive (PLI) scheme for large-scale electronics manufacturing. Apple's strategy of focusing on premium smartphone models in India has paid off, with the country's growing middle class showing a willingness to pay for higher-quality goods.

While Apple's reliance on iPhone sales has been a significant driver of growth, there are concerns about the sustainability of this strategy. Analysts worry that iPhone users are upgrading their handsets less frequently, which could impact sales. Additionally, Apple's concentrated production network, particularly its reliance on China for manufacturing, poses risks related to supply chain disruptions and geopolitical tensions. To mitigate these risks, Apple is working to diversify its supply chain, with India emerging as a potential solution. By increasing iPhone production in India, Apple can not only address supply chain concerns but also tap into the country's massive growth potential.

In conclusion, Apple's reliance on iPhone sales has been a critical aspect of its success, but the company recognizes the need to diversify its business lines and supply chain to ensure sustainable growth in the future. While iPhones continue to be a significant revenue driver, particularly in markets like India, Apple is exploring new avenues for growth, including financial services and expansion into new markets.

Apple's dependence on the Chinese market

In 2019, 47.6% of Apple's suppliers were based in China, and roughly 98% of the company's iPhones were made there. Apple's dependence on China is notably bigger than other US tech giants like Amazon, HP, Microsoft, Cisco Systems, and Dell Technologies.

This heavy reliance on China for its manufacturing poses risks for Apple investors. For example, China's strict COVID-19 lockdowns disrupted Apple's supply chain. Additionally, China's stance towards Taiwan and the potential for conflict in the region create further concerns. Recognising these risks, Apple has been working to diversify its supply chain, with India emerging as a possible solution. However, it will be challenging to reduce Apple's dependence on China significantly while preserving its high profit margins. Bloomberg Intelligence estimates that it would take about eight years to move just 10% of Apple's production capacity out of China.

Apple's CEO, Tim Cook, has acknowledged the importance of China in Apple's supply chain, stating, "There's no supply chain in the world that's more critical to us than China." Apple's good standing in China is partly due to its willingness to accommodate the Chinese government's security requirements, such as removing certain apps from its Chinese App Store and storing customer data on state-controlled servers. However, Apple is still subject to security rules and practices targeting foreign firms, such as the government campaign to reduce the use of iPhones by state employees.

In summary, Apple's dependence on the Chinese market is a significant factor in the company's operations and investment prospects. While Apple has recognised the need to diversify its supply chain, reducing its reliance on China will likely be a slow process due to the country's robust infrastructure, efficient transportation systems, and large workforce, which are challenging for other nations to replicate.

Apple's cash position and share buybacks

Apple's cash position and share buyback strategy are key components of its capital allocation strategy. As of May 2024, Apple reported a cash position of approximately $162 billion in cash, cash equivalents, and marketable securities. This significant cash balance provides Apple with financial flexibility and the capacity to invest in various initiatives, including share buybacks.

Share buybacks, also known as stock repurchases, are a strategy employed by Apple to return capital to shareholders and enhance shareholder value. By reducing the number of outstanding shares in the market, share buybacks can increase the value of the remaining shares. This is achieved because the company's earnings are then split among a smaller number of shares, resulting in a higher earnings-per-share (EPS) ratio.

Apple has a history of substantial share buyback programs. In May 2024, Apple announced a $110 billion share buyback authorization, the largest in corporate history. This follows a consistent pattern of large buybacks, including a $100 billion buyback in 2018 and $90 billion annually from 2021 to 2023. From 2012 through the end of 2022, Apple spent over $572 billion on share repurchases, making it the biggest player in the buyback market during that period.

The rationale behind Apple's focus on share buybacks is multifaceted. Firstly, Apple may choose to invest extra cash through share buybacks rather than new product development or business expansion. This strategy provides shareholders with additional cash to invest elsewhere if they prefer. Secondly, Apple may view its shares as undervalued and, therefore, buy them back at discounted prices, believing it to be a good use of their money. Additionally, share buybacks can help restore share value diluted by employee stock options and tweak the debt-equity balance by reducing shareholder equity.

Share buybacks have been an integral part of Apple's long-term investment thesis. By reducing its outstanding share count by 37.8% over the last decade, Apple has significantly boosted its EPS. For example, in fiscal 2023, Apple's diluted EPS was $6.13. Without its share buyback program, the company's EPS would have been only $3.85. As a result, Apple's share buybacks have contributed to its valuation remaining reasonable and attractive to investors.

Apple's competition in India

India has been identified as a huge potential growth market for Apple, with its rising middle class and increasing smartphone market. Apple's revenue in India has been growing, with sales in the 12 months ending in March 2024 reaching almost $8 billion, a 33% increase from the previous year. This growth is attributed to the company's focus on older iPhone models and affordability offers such as 24-month no-cost EMI options.

However, Apple faces intense competition in India, particularly from lower-priced smartphone manufacturers. Chinese companies like Xiaomi, Oppo, and Vivo have been gaining ground in the global smartphone market, and Apple's market share has slipped slightly as a result. In India, Apple has a small share of the smartphone market, which is dominated by lower-priced devices. While Apple's sales are growing, they still account for a relatively small portion of the company's overall revenue.

Apple's iOS powered only about 3.5% of smartphones in India as of mid-2024, with the rest using Android. However, Apple's smartphone base in the country has grown significantly, becoming five times larger in the last five years. The company's focus on domestic manufacturing, distribution, and premiumisation has helped it secure a place among the top five smartphone brands in India as of the September-December quarter of 2024.

In addition to competition from other smartphone manufacturers, Apple also faces antitrust scrutiny in India. The Competition Commission of India (CCI) found that Apple abused its dominant position in the market for app stores on its iOS operating system, engaging in "abusive conduct and practices". The case was filed by a non-profit group called "Together We Fight Society", which argued that Apple's in-app fee of up to 30% hurts competition and raises costs for developers and customers. Apple has denied any wrongdoing, claiming it is a small player in India compared to Google's Android system.

Despite the challenges, Apple is working to diversify its revenue streams and supply chains by focusing on India as a key market. The company plans to increase its manufacturing in India, with the goal of producing 25% of its iPhones in the country in the coming years. With its growing middle class and increasing smartphone adoption, India offers a significant opportunity for Apple to expand its customer base and drive future growth.

Apple's supply chain concentration

Apple's supply chain is a complex global network involving over 50 countries and millions of people. However, the company has faced scrutiny for its supply chain concentration, particularly its heavy reliance on manufacturing in China. This concentration has led to risks associated with US-China trade tensions and the country's strict COVID-19 lockdowns, which caused significant supply chain disruptions.

To address these challenges, Apple has been actively working to diversify its supply chain and reduce its dependence on China. As of 2024, 30% of Apple's suppliers were located in mainland China, down from 48% in 2019. The company is gradually shifting production to other countries, including India, Vietnam, Mexico, and the United States. This diversification strategy not only helps mitigate geopolitical risks but also ensures that Apple is not solely dependent on one country for manufacturing, which could lead to vulnerabilities in its supply chain.

Apple's supply chain strategy focuses on maximising efficiency, fostering innovation, and providing a seamless customer experience. They achieve these goals through just-in-time manufacturing, strategic supplier relationships, vertical integration, and the use of advanced analytics and AI. By maintaining long-term partnerships with over 200 suppliers globally, Apple ensures a steady supply of high-quality components while benefiting from the expertise of specialised manufacturers.

Apple also sets stringent standards for its suppliers, with regular audits and assessments to ensure compliance with labour, environmental, and human rights standards. Any supplier found to be in violation of these standards faces consequences, including removal from Apple's supply chain. The company has a zero-tolerance policy for retaliation and actively encourages supplier employees to raise concerns, providing hotlines for anonymous reporting.

By diversifying its supply chain and maintaining strong supplier relationships, Apple aims to build a resilient and sustainable network that can adapt to changing market demands and global challenges. This continuous improvement and innovation in supply chain management contribute to Apple's overall success and ability to drive profitability.

Frequently asked questions