Direct Vs Regular Mutual Funds: Which Is The Better Investment Option?

Mutual funds are a popular investment vehicle that pools money from multiple investors to invest in various assets, such as stocks, bonds, and money market instruments. When investing in mutual funds, individuals have the option to choose between direct and regular mutual funds. Direct mutual funds are purchased directly from the fund house without any intermediaries, resulting in lower expense ratios and higher returns. On the other hand, regular mutual funds are bought through intermediaries like brokers or financial advisors, who provide continuous support and guidance to investors. These intermediaries charge commissions, leading to a higher expense ratio and slightly lower returns for regular mutual funds. The decision between direct and regular mutual funds depends on an investor's financial expertise, preferences, and investment goals.

Direct mutual funds have a lower expense ratio

The expense ratio represents the mutual fund's annual fees and operating costs. It is calculated as a percentage of the fund's total expenses relative to its assets under management (AUM). For example, if a direct mutual fund has an expense ratio of 0.5%, only 0.5% of the AUM is used to cover expenses. In contrast, regular mutual funds have higher expense ratios because they include distributor or broker commissions. A regular fund might have an expense ratio of approximately 1%, meaning that 1% of the AUM is allocated to cover expenses, including advisor commissions.

The lower expense ratio of direct mutual funds translates to a higher net asset value (NAV). NAV is a critical metric in mutual funds, representing the per-unit market value of the fund's securities. It is calculated by dividing the total fund assets by the number of units outstanding. Since direct mutual funds have a lower expense ratio, a larger portion of the investor's money actively generates returns, potentially leading to higher overall returns compared to regular funds.

For instance, consider an investor who puts INR 1 lakh in both direct and regular mutual funds with an average market return of 12.5%. The direct fund could yield a 12% return, while the regular fund might offer an 11% return. Thus, the lower expense ratio of direct mutual funds can result in a larger corpus over time.

In summary, direct mutual funds have a lower expense ratio because they eliminate intermediary commissions and distribution fees, leading to a higher NAV and potentially higher overall returns compared to regular mutual funds.

Direct funds have a higher Net Asset Value (NAV)

The expense ratio represents the total expenses of a mutual fund relative to its assets under management (AUM). It includes management fees, registrar's fees, trustee fees, marketing costs, and distribution costs. In the case of regular funds, the fund house pays intermediaries a commission, which is then passed on to the investor, impacting their overall gains.

The lower expense ratio of direct funds means that a larger portion of the investor's money is actively generating returns. This can lead to higher overall returns compared to regular funds, which have a higher expense ratio due to the inclusion of intermediary fees.

For example, if an investor puts the same amount of money into both direct and regular mutual funds with the same average market return, the direct fund could yield a higher return due to its lower expense ratio. This results in a larger corpus for direct mutual funds over time.

The higher NAV of direct funds is, therefore, a result of their lower expense ratio, which allows a greater proportion of the investment to generate returns and accumulate a larger corpus over time.

Direct plans offer higher returns

The expense ratio of a mutual fund is the fee charged for managing and operating the fund, and it is taken from the fund's assets. In regular mutual funds, the fund house must pay a commission to the intermediary, which is then passed on to the investor, impacting overall gains. Direct plans, on the other hand, have a lower expense ratio because there is no intermediary involved. This means that a larger portion of the investor's money is actively generating returns, potentially leading to higher overall returns.

For example, if an investor puts INR 1 lakh in both direct and regular mutual funds with an average market return of 12.5%, the direct fund could yield a 12% return, while the regular fund might offer an 11% return. This would result in a larger corpus for the direct mutual fund.

The Net Asset Value (NAV) of a mutual fund is another critical metric. NAV is calculated by dividing the total fund assets by the number of units outstanding, and it represents the per-unit market value of the fund's securities. Direct mutual funds typically have a higher NAV than regular funds due to their lower expense ratios.

While direct plans offer higher returns, it is important to consider the level of financial expertise and comfort with self-directed management that an investor has. Direct plans may not be suitable for those who are new to investing or who prefer the guidance and support offered by regular mutual funds.

Direct plans are for investors who don't need financial advisors

Direct mutual funds are ideal for investors who are comfortable with independent decision-making and do not require the services of a financial advisor. These funds are purchased directly from the fund house or asset management company (AMC), eliminating the need for intermediaries such as brokers, distributors, or financial advisors. By cutting out the middleman, direct plans offer a lower expense ratio, as there are no commission fees or distribution charges involved. This structure results in higher returns for investors.

When investing in direct mutual funds, individuals take full control of their investment decisions, including asset allocation, portfolio management, and market research. It empowers investors to make informed choices, enhancing their financial literacy and understanding of the market. This approach suits those who prefer autonomy and are confident in their ability to manage their investments independently.

In contrast, regular mutual funds are procured through intermediaries, who provide various services such as investment advice, portfolio evaluation, and transaction assistance. These services come at a cost, as the fund house pays the intermediary a commission or distribution fee, which is ultimately passed on to the investor. As a result, regular mutual funds have a higher expense ratio and slightly lower returns compared to direct plans.

Regular mutual funds cater to investors who seek comprehensive support and guidance from financial professionals. Intermediaries assist in identifying suitable funds based on risk appetite and investment objectives, providing a personalized approach to goal-based planning. They also offer regular monitoring of the portfolio, suggesting adjustments as needed. This level of service can be advantageous for new investors or those who prefer a more hands-on approach from their advisors.

The decision between direct and regular mutual funds depends on an investor's preferences, financial expertise, and goals. Direct plans offer lower costs and higher returns but require a certain level of financial knowledge and comfort with self-directed management. On the other hand, regular plans provide access to expert advice and support, making them a prudent choice for those new to investing or seeking continuous guidance.

Regular funds are for investors who need continuous support

Regular mutual funds are an excellent option for investors who need continuous support and guidance from financial advisors in making investment decisions. Here are some reasons why regular funds are ideal for investors seeking ongoing assistance:

Financial Advisor Assistance

Regular mutual funds offer the benefit of financial advisor assistance. These advisors help investors identify suitable funds based on their risk appetite, financial goals, and investment objectives. For new investors who are unsure about investing, regular funds provide valuable guidance and support. Advisors help investors navigate the complexities of the market and make informed decisions about where and how much to invest.

Regular Monitoring

With regular mutual funds, investors don't have to worry about constantly monitoring their investments. Financial advisors or distributors monitor and review the investor's portfolio on their behalf. They keep track of market fluctuations and suggest portfolio changes when necessary, ensuring that the investor's financial goals stay on track. This proactive approach helps investors stay focused on their long-term objectives.

Goal-Based Planning

Regular funds offer a personalized approach to investing. Financial advisors or distributors help investors create customized investment plans tailored to their unique financial goals. This goal-based planning helps investors make investment decisions that align with their specific objectives, whether it's saving for retirement, buying a home, or investing for their child's education.

Simplified Investment Process

Regular mutual funds are ideal for investors who want a simplified investment process. Intermediaries, such as financial advisors or distributors, handle the paperwork and documentation involved in investing. They assist with submitting application forms, cheques, and Know Your Client (KYC) documents to the relevant authorities. This takes the burden off the investor, making the entire process more accessible and less daunting.

Access to Market Insights

Financial advisors and distributors in regular funds have a wealth of knowledge and insights about the market. They can provide investors with valuable information and analysis, helping them make more informed investment decisions. This access to market insights can be especially beneficial for investors who are new to the world of investing or who don't have the time to conduct their own extensive research.

Convenience and Peace of Mind

Regular mutual funds offer convenience and peace of mind to investors. By having a financial advisor handle their investments, investors can focus on other aspects of their lives. They don't have to worry about constantly monitoring the market or making investment decisions on their own. This can be a significant advantage for busy individuals or those who prefer a more hands-off approach to investing.

Frequently asked questions