Stock Vs Bitcoin: Where Should You Invest Your Money?

Bitcoin and stocks are two very different investment options, each with its own set of advantages and disadvantages. While stocks are generally considered a more stable and traditional investment option, Bitcoin has gained popularity as a new and innovative investment opportunity. However, it's important to remember that both come with their own set of risks and potential rewards. When deciding whether to invest in stocks or Bitcoin, it's crucial to consider your financial goals, risk tolerance, and investment strategy.

Bitcoin's volatility

Bitcoin is considered a volatile asset, and its volatility is measured by how much its price fluctuates relative to the average price over a period of time. The volatility of Bitcoin is influenced by the speculative nature of the cryptocurrency industry, where investors bet on its price going up or down to make a profit. This causes sudden price increases or decreases, leading to volatility.

Volatility is a measure of the riskiness of holding an asset, as it may substantially increase or decrease in value over time. The more volatile an asset, the more people will want to limit their exposure to it. Volatility also increases the cost of hedging, which is a significant factor in the price of merchant services. If Bitcoin volatility decreases, the cost of converting into and out of Bitcoin will also decrease.

Despite its volatility, Bitcoin has historically provided high returns, with a Sharpe ratio of 0.96 from 2020 to early 2024, compared to the S&P 500's ratio of 0.65 over the same period. This indicates that investors have been more than compensated for taking on the additional risk associated with Bitcoin.

In summary, while Bitcoin is a volatile asset, its volatility has been declining as it matures, and investors have been rewarded for taking on the risk. However, it is still a risky investment compared to traditional assets, and its volatility should be carefully considered before adding it to an investment portfolio.

Bitcoin's risk vs stocks' risk

Bitcoins Risk vs Stocks Risk

Both stocks and cryptocurrencies carry risks. The market could crash, companies could go bankrupt, or stocks could soar. However, there are some differences in the risks between the two.

Bitcoin Risk

Bitcoin is a relatively new development and is not yet widely adopted. This adds a layer of risk because it could be replaced by other more efficient digital currencies or be regulated out of existence.

Bitcoin is also subject to significant price swings due to its limited supply and lack of a centralized authority. It's still a relatively young currency in its price discovery phase, and its value can change suddenly and dramatically as speculations over its worth shift.

Another danger is that Bitcoin does not undergo the same Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) scrutiny that regulated securities markets, like the stock exchange, do.

Additionally, stock markets have been around much longer than Bitcoin, so there is less history to base future performance on.

Stock Risk

With individual stocks, there is a risk that the stock won't grow, dividends might be cut, and the performance might be compared to the S&P 500, which means trying to keep up with the Joneses.

However, stocks are different from Bitcoin because there is some guidance available to understand where the price might go. For example, you can look at the ratio of a company's stock price to its earnings (the price-to-earnings or P/E ratio) to get a sense of the company's financial health.

Both Bitcoin and stocks carry risks, but the risks are different in nature. Bitcoin is more susceptible to price swings and is a newer, less established investment. Stocks, on the other hand, have been around longer and have more historical data to base predictions on, but individual stocks carry their own set of risks. Ultimately, the decision to invest in Bitcoin or stocks depends on your risk tolerance, investment goals, and time horizon.

Bitcoin's history vs stocks' history

The history of stocks is a long and winding road, with its origins dating back to 13th-century Europe. The concept of trading goods and commodities is ancient, but the first modern stock trading market was created in Amsterdam in 1611. The Dutch East India Company was the first publicly traded company, selling stock to raise capital. This marked the beginning of the stock market as we know it today. Over the centuries, the stock market has evolved and expanded globally, with major exchanges in cities like London, Tokyo, and Shanghai. The stock market has experienced significant events, including crashes and recoveries, and has become an integral part of the global economic landscape.

Bitcoin, on the other hand, is a much more recent development, having been created in 2009 by a computer programmer or group of programmers using the pseudonym Satoshi Nakamoto. Bitcoin is a cryptocurrency, a digital asset that uses cryptography to control its creation and management rather than relying on central authorities. It was designed as a medium of exchange and has since become a significant store of value, with some businesses accepting it as a form of payment. The value of Bitcoin has fluctuated wildly, rising as high as $69,000 in March 2024 and dropping as low as $3,000 in December 2018.

One of the key differences between Bitcoin and stocks is their level of volatility. Bitcoin has been highly volatile since its creation, with its value fluctuating dramatically over time. In contrast, stock growth has been generally more stable, with indices like the S&P 500 and the Dow Jones Industrial Average showing steady growth over the years. Another difference lies in their level of adoption. Stocks have been around for centuries and are widely accepted and established, while Bitcoin is still relatively new and not as widely adopted.

In terms of risks, both Bitcoin and stocks carry inherent risks. With stocks, there is the risk of company bankruptcy or overall market crashes. With Bitcoin, there is the risk of it being replaced by other digital currencies or being regulated out of existence. Additionally, Bitcoin has been subject to security breaches and theft, with hackers stealing millions of dollars worth of Bitcoin.

Despite their differences, both Bitcoin and stocks can be valuable additions to an investment portfolio. Stocks have historically provided steady returns and are considered a more stable investment. Bitcoin, on the other hand, offers the potential for dramatic growth but also carries a higher level of risk. Ultimately, the decision to invest in stocks or Bitcoin depends on an individual's financial goals, risk tolerance, and investment horizon.

Who is a good fit for Bitcoin?

Bitcoin's price volatility, inefficiency as a means of payment, environmental impact, association with criminal activity, and lack of intrinsic value have all been cited as reasons not to invest in the cryptocurrency. However, advocates argue that many of these concerns are being addressed by innovations in blockchain technology.

Bitcoin's price volatility is understandable given that it is still in the early stages of adoption. As the market grows, advocates expect volatility to decrease. In addition, the introduction of more secure and efficient third-party solutions, such as the Lightning Network, is helping to improve the speed and cost of transactions.

Bitcoin's environmental impact is also being addressed, with an increasing proportion of mining operations now being powered by renewable energy sources. According to the Bitcoin Mining Council, over 58% of bitcoin mining used sustainable electricity in early 2022.

While critics argue that Bitcoin's lack of intrinsic value makes it a risky investment, advocates believe that its decentralised nature is its most valuable feature. The fact that it can't be controlled by a single government, central bank, or company means that it is protected from both inflation and dictators, making it revolutionary.

Bitcoin also has a role as a form of resistance. In countries with unstable governments or financial systems, it can provide an emergency exit for those looking to protect their savings.

Overall, Bitcoin may be a good fit for those who are comfortable with the risks associated with its price volatility and regulatory uncertainty. It may also appeal to those who value the decentralised nature of blockchain technology and its potential to challenge autocratic regimes and traditional financial institutions. Early adopters, institutions, and high-net-worth individuals have been among the key buyers of Bitcoin.

Who is a good fit for stocks?

If you're considering investing in stocks, you likely fall into one of these categories: you're comfortable with some level of risk and volatility, and you're in it for the long haul. Traditional stock market investing appeals to those who want to build wealth over time, generally with a time frame of years or decades. This longer-term approach can smooth out the ups and downs of the market and potentially deliver steady, solid returns.

Stock market investors also tend to be those who like the idea of owning a piece of a company and having some level of influence over its direction. Through stocks, you can gain voting rights and have a say in major company decisions. This aspect appeals to those who want a more active role in their investments and who believe in the potential of specific companies or industries.

Another type of person suited to stocks is someone who wants a more diverse range of investment options. The stock market offers an incredibly wide array of choices, from large, established companies to small, up-and-coming businesses, and across a variety of sectors and industries. This diversity allows investors to tailor their portfolios to their interests, beliefs, and risk tolerances.

Additionally, stock market investors often have the option to invest in funds, which are baskets of carefully selected stocks (and sometimes other assets). These funds, such as mutual funds or exchange-traded funds (ETFs), can provide instant diversification and are managed by professionals. This aspect suits those who want a more hands-off approach but still want the potential benefits of stock market investing.

Finally, stocks can be a good fit for those who want more liquidity in their investments. While it's generally recommended to hold stocks for the long term, they are typically more liquid than other investments, like property. This means you can usually sell your stocks and access your money relatively quickly, which is appealing to those who want the flexibility to respond to market changes or need access to their funds for other opportunities or emergencies.

Frequently asked questions