Home Sweet Home: Weighing The Benefits Of Selling Investments To Buy A House

There are many factors to consider when deciding whether to sell your investments to buy a house. Here are some key points to keep in mind:

- Tax implications: Selling investments can trigger capital gains taxes, which vary depending on how long you've held the investments and your tax status. It's important to understand the tax consequences before making a decision.

- Alternative financing options: There are other ways to finance a home purchase, such as low down payment mortgages, down payment assistance programs, or gift funds from family or friends. Explore these options before deciding to sell your investments.

- Financial goals: Consider your long-term financial goals and how selling your investments fits into them. Diversification is important, and selling all your investments to buy a house may reduce your overall portfolio diversification.

- Peace of mind: Owning a home outright can provide a sense of security and peace of mind, especially if you're averse to taking on high levels of debt.

- Opportunity cost: By selling your investments, you may miss out on potential gains in the stock market or other investment opportunities. On the other hand, keeping your investments may mean paying more in interest over time if you take out a mortgage.

- Market conditions: Evaluate the current state of the housing market and your local area. If housing prices are expected to rise, selling your investments to buy a house may make sense to avoid taking on a larger mortgage.

- Personal circumstances: Life events such as a new family member, a death in the family, or a job relocation can impact your decision. Consider your current and future needs, and whether selling your investments is the best option to meet those needs.

Tax implications

If you decide to sell your investments to buy a house, you will need to consider the tax implications of doing so. Here are some key points to keep in mind:

Capital Gains Tax:

• If you make a profit from selling your investments, you will likely be subject to capital gains tax on that profit. This tax applies even if you use the proceeds as a down payment for your new home.
• The capital gains tax rate is typically lower than the ordinary income tax rate. In the US, the IRS taxes capital gains at 0%, 15%, or 20%, depending on your taxable income, tax status, and how long you owned the investment.
• There are two types of capital gains tax: long-term and short-term. Long-term capital gains tax applies to profits from the sale of investments held for more than a year, while short-term capital gains tax applies to profits from the sale of investments held for less than a year. Short-term capital gains tax rates are usually higher.
• You can reduce your capital gains tax liability through tax-loss harvesting, which involves selling low-performing investments to offset the profits from the sale of other investments.

Alternative Minimum Tax:

If you sell a large amount of investments, you may trigger the alternative minimum tax, which could result in a higher tax bill.

Timing of Tax Payment:

The timing of the sale can impact your tax burden. By controlling the year in which the sale occurs, you can manage your overall tax liability.

Section 1031 Like-Kind Exchange:

• The IRS Code Section 1031 allows for the deferral of capital gains taxes when selling investment real estate if you reinvest the proceeds into a similar investment property. This is known as a "like-kind" exchange.
• To qualify for the Section 1031 exchange, the properties involved must be of a similar nature or character, even if they differ in grade or quality. The properties must also be held for business or investment purposes, not personal use.
• Timing is crucial for the Section 1031 exchange. The new property must be identified within 45 days of the sale of the original property, and the exchange must be completed within 180 days.

Primary Residence Exclusion:

• If you convert an investment property into your primary residence, you may be able to exclude a portion of the capital gains from taxes when you sell. According to the IRS, individuals can exclude up to $250,000 of capital gains, while married couples filing jointly can exclude up to $500,000.
• To qualify for the primary residence exclusion, you must have occupied the residence as your primary home for at least 24 months of the last five years. The two years do not need to be consecutive.

Tax Deductions:

• When selling a house, you can deduct various expenses from the capital gains, such as realtor fees, legal and escrow fees, advertising costs, and staging fees.
• Additionally, you can add certain costs to your cost basis, such as purchase expenses, closing costs, title insurance, and settlement fees. This will further reduce your capital gains tax liability.

Alternative financing options

There are several alternative financing options to consider if you're looking to buy a house without selling your investments. Here are some detailed explanations and instructions for a few of these options:

Down Payment Assistance Programs

Government or non-profit down payment assistance initiatives can help homebuyers with their down payment or closing costs. These programs usually have specific requirements, such as being a first-time homebuyer, having an income below a certain threshold, or living in the home for a set number of years. It's worth researching what programs are available in your state or city to see if you qualify.

Gift Funds

If you have a generous family member or friend, you could consider gift funds to help cover the down payment or closing costs. According to the IRS, gift funds under $17,000 are not taxed. This option could help you avoid selling your stocks while still securing the necessary funds for your home purchase.

Low Down Payment Mortgages

In certain circumstances, you may be eligible for a low or no down payment mortgage from federal programs such as FHA loans or conforming loans. These loans typically require a lower down payment, but you will need to pay additional private mortgage insurance (PMI) until you have built up more equity in the home. It's important to weigh the benefits of a lower initial payment against potentially higher monthly mortgage payments.

Borrowing from a Retirement Account

While financial advisors generally don't recommend it, you could consider borrowing from your 401(k) or IRA for a short-term solution. Keep in mind that if you're under 59 and a half years old, you'll incur a 10% penalty on the withdrawal, and it will be taxed as income. Additionally, if you lose your job, the money must be repaid within 60 days.

Borrowing from Your Parents or a Co-Signer

Another option is to borrow from your parents or ask them to co-sign your loan. However, borrowing from family can change the dynamic of your relationship, so it's important to get the loan in writing with the help of a lawyer and an accountant to ensure it doesn't appear as a gift, which would be subject to the gift tax. Getting a co-signer can also make it easier to qualify for a loan and secure more favorable terms, especially in a competitive market.

Seller Financing

Seller financing is an arrangement where the home seller acts as the bank and holds the mortgage while you make payments directly to them. The terms of these agreements can vary and are often negotiable, including details such as interest rates and repayment schedules. This option may be suitable for individuals who face challenges securing a traditional mortgage due to credit issues or unconventional financial circumstances.

Peace of mind

Pros of selling your investments to buy a house:

• You will never have to worry about a monthly mortgage payment, which can be a huge weight off your shoulders, especially if you dislike taking on high levels of debt.
• You give yourself a nice margin of safety in your personal finances with no mortgage payment.
• You will save a lot of money on interest payments over time. For example, on a $350,000 loan over 30 years at a 3% interest rate, you would pay more than $181,000 in interest.
• If you get into a bidding war, paying with cash will likely make it easier to buy the house.
• Paying in cash means you save some costs on the transaction and could close on the house faster.
• You can avoid the stress of dealing with tenants and maintenance issues, which can be time-consuming and challenging, especially as your life gets more complicated with age.

Cons of selling your investments to buy a house:

• Your money is essentially trapped in an illiquid asset. You can't spend your house, and it may be difficult to access your investment dollars in times of financial hardship.
• Owning shares in the stock market offers far more diversification than a single house, which has more idiosyncratic risk.
• Taking on a mortgage can reduce your tax bill as you can take the mortgage interest deduction on your taxes.
• Interest rates are currently near generational lows. After accounting for inflation and tax deductions, you're essentially borrowing for free at today's mortgage rates.
• There could be a massive opportunity cost if you sell out of the market and it continues to rise. The compounding benefits of a combination of leverage in a house and dividends/earnings growth in the stock market could be significant.
• It can be difficult to make a level-headed decision about selling your investments, as a home is the most emotional asset you'll ever buy.

Liquidity

When it comes to selling investments to buy a house, liquidity is important to consider as it affects your ability to access cash. If you need to sell your investments quickly, liquidating illiquid assets like real estate may not be the best option.

• Real estate transactions are often private, making it time-consuming for buyers to research and complete the purchase process.
• Finalizing a real estate sale involves multiple parties, including buyers, sellers, lawyers, real estate agents, and others, which can prolong the process.
• Market fluctuations can impact the price of real estate assets, and there may be concerns about the ability to quickly liquidate these assets.
• Liquidity is crucial when unexpected expenses arise, and it is important to have liquid assets to cover short-term obligations and avoid a liquidity crisis.
• When selling investments, consider the time it will take to convert them into cash and the potential impact on the market price.
• Stocks, bonds, and other exchange-traded securities are generally more liquid than real estate, but liquidity can vary within these asset classes as well.

Diversification

A well-diversified portfolio can mitigate exposure to market risk. Diversification works by spreading investments among a variety of asset classes, such as stocks, bonds, cash, treasury bills, and real estate. These different assets should have a low correlation to each other, meaning they move in exact opposition. For example, if one asset's value increases, the other's decreases, and vice versa.

Real estate is an ideal opportunity to diversify assets due to its low correlation with conventional equity and bond investments. There are several ways to diversify within real estate, including by sector, geography, or strategy.

Research has shown that adding real estate to a mixed-asset portfolio can reduce portfolio risk by 10% to 20%, with the optimal allocation being in the 15% to 25% range.

Diversifying by sectors involves investing in residential, industrial, and commercial properties. Residential properties have a relatively stable demand due to the need for housing, but they also carry a degree of risk as they tend to have shorter leases, averaging about 12 months. Industrial properties, such as factories and warehouses, typically have longer leases of up to 10 years, making them a more secure investment. Commercial properties, like office buildings and malls, tend to have higher income returns, with yields ranging from 5% to 10%.

Geographical diversification is another strategy, where investors put their money into different countries, cities, and regions. This helps to lessen the overall impact on investment portfolio returns if a particular market performs poorly.

Finally, diversifying by strategy involves adopting a core, value-add, or opportunistic approach. Core investments are usually lower-risk, well-maintained properties with low vacancy rates, generating stable cash flows. Value-add strategies involve higher-risk properties that require physical upgrades or better property management to improve their quality and, therefore, their rental income. Opportunistic strategies target underperforming properties, such as distressed assets or undeveloped land, which can be acquired at a lower cost and then "flipped" for a higher price after renovations.

Overall, diversification is a key way to reduce risk in an investment portfolio, and real estate offers a range of options for achieving this.

Frequently asked questions