Mcdonald's Risks: What Investors Need To Know

Investing in McDonald's stock carries risks, and investors should carefully consider their investment goals and risk tolerance before making any decisions. One of the primary risks is the company's ability to attract younger consumers, as it has been facing a millennial problem. McDonald's has implemented a healthier menu, but younger consumers still view its primary meal as a headwind to their health. The company also faces intense competition in the fast-food industry, with consumers opting for more high-end experiences like Panera Bread, Starbucks, and Shake Shack. Additionally, there is the risk of management instability, as evidenced by the abrupt departure of former CEO Steve Easterbrook. From a financial perspective, McDonald's has a relatively low net profit margin of 0.32%, which means a small decline in revenue could result in net losses. The company's stock volatility measures how much its price varies over time, and it has a beta of 0.53, indicating that its shares generally do not fluctuate as wildly as the broader markets.

A millennial problem and competition from healthier fast-food options

McDonald's has been facing a millennial problem, with the fast-food giant not ranking among the top 10 restaurant chains for millennials. This is a concern for the company, as millennials are a huge and influential cohort that values choice and customisation. In response, McDonald's launched its biggest product of the year, McWrap, to appeal to this demographic. However, it has been noted that millennials are opting for "better burger" options that use fresher ingredients, such as those offered by Shake Shack and Smashburger. This has resulted in a decline in traffic from millennials to hamburger chains, including McDonald's.

To address this issue, McDonald's has started testing made-to-order burgers with premium beef and different cooking techniques to attract health-conscious consumers. They have also hired 200 new digital team members to leverage social media in their efforts to win back millennial customers.

In addition to the millennial problem, McDonald's faces competition from healthier fast-food options. The company's primary meal of a burger, fries, and a soda is perceived as unhealthy by younger consumers. As a result, McDonald's has implemented a healthier menu, but it is still facing competition from fast-food restaurants that offer more high-end experiences, such as Panera Bread, Starbucks, and Shake Shack. These restaurants provide more variety and customisation, which is valued by millennials.

To stay competitive, McDonald's has introduced promotions such as McPick 2, a revamped value menu, and all-day breakfast. They have also made heavier investments in technology and mobile ordering. However, it is important to note that getting a grip on younger consumers has proven elusive for McDonald's, and this could be a risk factor for investors.

Currency and financial risks

McDonald's financial health should be examined by analysing its balance sheet, income statement, and cash flow statement. Key financial ratios such as Price-to-Earnings (P/E), Price-to-Sales (P/S), and Price-to-Book (P/B) can help determine if the stock is fairly valued or over/undervalued. The company's profitability can be assessed through metrics like net profit margin, return on assets, and free cash flow.

The company's debt obligations, as indicated by its bonds, are also a factor to consider. McDonald's issues bonds to finance its operations, and investors should be aware of the associated risks. The beta coefficient, which measures the volatility of McDonald's stock relative to the market, is relatively low at 0.53, indicating that the stock generally does not fluctuate wildly. However, it's important to monitor the company's financial performance and market sensitivity to manage the risk of potential losses.

The impact of inflation on McDonald's business model is another financial risk to consider. While the company's low-cost options may attract customers during inflationary periods, the ability to maintain profitability while managing rising costs is crucial. Changes in interest rates can also affect McDonald's borrowing costs and the spending behaviour of its customers.

In summary, currency and financial risks associated with investing in McDonald's include exposure to currency fluctuations, economic downturns, and the company's financial health and debt obligations. It's important to monitor these risks and their potential impact on the company's performance and stock price volatility.

Rising labour costs

McDonald's has faced challenges in managing labour costs effectively, with some store managers complaining about high labour expenses. This issue is partly due to the company's practice of hiring numerous new employees instead of utilising existing staff willing to take on additional hours. This approach can lead to an excess of staff during slower periods, resulting in higher labour costs relative to business needs.

The COVID-19 pandemic also impacted labour availability, with up to 10% of McDonald's stores in the US limiting hours during the surge of the Omicron variant in December 2021. While this impact eased over time, labour availability challenges continued into 2022, affecting service times in the drive-thru and requiring additional focus on staffing and positioning.

Furthermore, McDonald's has experienced issues with employee retention, as employees frequently quit due to unfavourable working conditions. This turnover can lead to increased training costs and further strain on labour expenses as the company continually hires and trains new staff.

To address rising labour costs, McDonald's has implemented strategies such as limiting overtime and reducing employee hours, which can help control expenses but may also affect employee morale and productivity. However, these measures may not be sufficient to offset the impact of rising labour rates and could potentially harm the customer experience if staffing levels are insufficient.

In summary, rising labour costs present a notable risk for investors in McDonald's. The company's approach to staffing and employee retention directly influences its financial performance, and effective management of labour expenses is crucial for maintaining profitability and competitiveness in the fast-food market.

Retail traffic decline

Retail traffic to McDonald's restaurants has been declining, and this has been a contributing factor to the company's sales performance in recent years. Several factors have influenced this trend, including:

• Economic conditions and consumer behaviour: Persistent inflation and economic downturns have led consumers, especially lower-income ones, to reduce their spending on eating out. They are opting for more affordable food options at home, impacting fast-food chains like McDonald's.
• Competition and consumer preferences: McDonald's faces intense competition from other fast-food chains, including Burger King, Wendy's, and Taco Bell, which offer similar value meals. Additionally, younger consumers are increasingly choosing more high-end fast-food experiences like Panera Bread, Starbucks, and Shake Shack. This shift in preferences has resulted in a perceived ""millennial problem" for McDonald's, with millennials generally less inclined to patronise the chain.
• Health concerns: McDonald's has introduced healthier menu options, but some consumers, particularly health-conscious ones, still view the classic burger, fries, and soda meal as a "headwind" to their health. This perception has led to a resistance to choosing McDonald's, despite their healthier alternatives.
• Impact of discounts on profits: While McDonald's has relied on value meals and discounts to attract budget-conscious consumers, this strategy may not be sustainable in the long term. As Northcoast Research analyst Jim Sanderson noted, "Value is helping McDonald's recover traffic from lower-income consumers, but that expansion of value will pressure store profits, which will make it difficult to drive stronger earnings longer-term."
• Boycotts and geopolitical conflicts: McDonald's has faced consumer boycotts linked to geopolitical events, such as the Gaza war, which impacted sales in the Middle East markets.

To mitigate the risk of retail traffic decline, McDonald's has implemented various strategies, including introducing value meals, discounts, and promotions, such as the $5 meal deal and the McPick 2 deal. They have also focused on luring more affluent consumers with their Signature Crafted menu. However, the success of these initiatives has varied, and the company continues to navigate the challenges of shifting consumer preferences and economic headwinds.

Regulatory compliance

One area of regulatory compliance that has been particularly prominent for McDonald's is nutrition and marketing. In recent years, there has been a growing trend towards healthier eating, and McDonald's has had to adapt its menu and marketing strategies to comply with changing regulations and consumer demands. For example, the company has committed to the EU Pledge, agreeing to fulfil specific nutritional criteria for items advertised to children under 12 and refraining from communicating with primary schools in Europe. This is in response to increasing regulatory scrutiny on the food industry's marketing practices towards children.

Labour laws and regulations are another critical area of compliance for McDonald's. The company has faced labour strikes and protests from its workforce demanding higher wages and the right to unionize. These incidents have occurred in various countries, including the United States and the United Kingdom. As labour laws vary across different markets, McDonald's must carefully navigate these regulations and ensure that it complies with the specific requirements of each jurisdiction.

Environmental regulations are also a significant consideration for McDonald's. As a large consumer of agricultural products and a major producer of food waste, the company has a significant environmental impact. McDonald's has implemented various initiatives to reduce its environmental footprint, such as committing to source all its electricity from renewable sources by 2030 and working towards sustainable packaging solutions. However, as environmental regulations evolve and consumer awareness of environmental issues grows, McDonald's will need to continue adapting its operations to remain compliant and maintain its social license to operate.

Lastly, data privacy and cybersecurity regulations are becoming increasingly important for McDonald's and other large companies. With the implementation of regulations such as the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) in Europe and the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) in the United States, McDonald's must ensure that it handles customer data securely and in compliance with the relevant regulations. As data privacy and cybersecurity become more prominent concerns for consumers and regulators alike, McDonald's will need to stay abreast of evolving regulatory requirements in this area.

Frequently asked questions