Understanding Reasonable Invested Equity: Your Smart Money Move

Investors are an integral part of any startup, providing the capital necessary to get businesses off the ground. However, it is important to understand what investors want from a business. They are not merely interested in owning a piece of the company; they are also looking for a return on their investment. This typically comes in the form of equity, which gives them a portion of ownership and rights to potential future profits. The more equity an investor holds, the more clout they have in the business, and they will want enough influence to ensure the company is eventually sold so they can make a profit. However, giving away too much equity can be detrimental to a business, as it may lead to interference from unsophisticated investors who could hinder the company's growth. Therefore, it is crucial for entrepreneurs to carefully consider how much equity they are willing to give up and to whom.

Investors buy a piece of the company

When investors put money into a startup, they are buying a piece of the company. This is known as equity financing, where investors gain shares in a company in exchange for their capital. The more money an investor puts in, the larger their share of the company tends to be.

For example, if an investor provides $40,000 in funding for a small business, they may receive a 25% stake in the business. This means the investor now owns a quarter of the company and will receive a proportional amount of the profits. If the company makes a $20,000 profit, the investor will receive $5,000, having already made back 20% of their initial investment.

However, if the company performs poorly, the investor will lose the money they have invested. This is why startup equity is considered a high-risk, high-reward asset class.

It is important to note that investors are not just providing capital but are also forming a partnership with the startup. They will want to have a say in how the company is run to ensure it is successful and they make a return on their investment.

Investors will also want to be able to exit the partnership and recoup their investment plus profits. This is usually done through a liquidity event, such as an IPO or acquisition, where the investor sells their portion of ownership in the company.

When deciding how much of their company to offer to investors, entrepreneurs need to consider the needs of the investor as well as their own. Investors are generally looking for a credible exit strategy within three to five years and enough clout to ensure the company is eventually sold.

It is also important to remember that giving away equity means giving away a portion of control over the business. This is why it is generally advised not to give equity to anyone you don't want permanently involved in the business.

Determining how much equity to offer in exchange for a certain amount of capital also requires understanding the math of equity and valuation. This involves calculating how much the company is worth and, therefore, how much of the company the investment is worth.

Liquidity is harder with startup equity

Liquidity refers to how easy it is to convert a security (something that you own with economic value) into cash. Equity in a startup is relatively illiquid, as it is more difficult to sell. This is because startup equity is considered a high-risk, high-reward, and highly illiquid asset class.

There are several reasons why liquidity is harder with startup equity:

• Startups are typically smaller operations that are less established than public companies, and therefore have fewer potential buyers for their equity.
• Startups often have complex capital structures, with multiple rounds of funding and different types of shares outstanding, which can make it difficult to find buyers who are willing to take on the risks associated with the investment.
• Startups are often subject to greater regulatory requirements and restrictions, such as lock-up periods during which existing shareholders cannot sell their shares.
• Startups may not have the same level of analyst coverage as public companies, which can make it more difficult for potential buyers to access the information they need to make an informed investment decision.
• Startups are generally less liquid than public companies because they are not traded on a public exchange, and therefore there is no established market for their shares.

The illiquidity of startup equity can have significant implications for investors. It can make it more difficult for them to exit their investments, and can also increase the risk of losing money if the startup fails. However, it is important to note that the potential for high returns in startup investing can outweigh the risks for some investors.

Sweat equity is different from market value

Sweat equity is distinct from market value in several ways. Firstly, sweat equity refers to non-monetary contributions, typically in the form of physical labour, mental effort, and time, whereas market value is usually associated with monetary investments. Sweat equity is often utilised by cash-strapped startups, entrepreneurs, and business owners who may not have the financial resources to pay salaries or hire external services. They rely on the sweat equity of founders, employees, or themselves to build and grow the company. On the other hand, market value is determined by the monetary worth of a company, product, or service in the marketplace.

Another difference lies in the calculation and valuation methods. Sweat equity is valued based on the amount of time and effort spent on an activity or developing a business. It compensates for the shortage of cash, allowing companies to raise funds without accumulating debt. The value of sweat equity is calculated by assessing the increase in value brought about by the labour and time invested. In real estate, for example, sweat equity is reflected in the increase in property value due to unpaid work and improvements. On the contrary, market value is influenced by various factors such as market conditions, comparable companies, exit potential, future capital needs, and other financial metrics.

Additionally, sweat equity and market value differ in terms of risk and reward. Sweat equity carries a higher level of risk since the final value of the equity may not always be commensurate with the effort expended. In the case of startups, employees or founders who accept sweat equity take on the risk of the company failing, which could render their sweat equity worthless. Conversely, market value investments are typically associated with more established companies or products, where the risks may be lower, and the value is more tangible and predictable.

Furthermore, sweat equity and market value differ in their tax implications. In some jurisdictions, sweat equity is considered a form of income by tax authorities, and it may be taxed accordingly. On the other hand, market value investments often have different tax treatments, such as capital gains taxes or investment income taxes, depending on the nature of the investment.

While sweat equity and market value differ in these ways, they both contribute to the overall value and success of a business venture. Sweat equity plays a crucial role in the early stages of a company, especially when financial resources are limited, while market value becomes more prominent as the company matures and seeks external investments.

Debt financing is cheaper than equity financing

When raising capital, companies can choose between debt financing and equity financing. Debt financing involves taking out loans from creditors, while equity financing involves selling shares of the company to investors.

Debt financing is generally cheaper than equity financing for several reasons. Firstly, debt financing lowers income tax as interest payments on loans are tax-deductible. This effectively reduces the cost of borrowing compared to the stated interest rate. Secondly, debt financing does not dilute ownership of the company, allowing the business owner to retain full control and avoid interference from investors. Thirdly, debt financing is often quicker and easier to obtain than equity financing, which typically requires significant effort and time to pitch to investors. Lastly, debt financing provides a fixed repayment obligation that can be planned for in advance, whereas equity financing involves sacrificing a portion of future profits that are uncertain and could potentially be higher than the interest payments on a loan.

However, debt financing also has its drawbacks. The fixed-interest nature of debt increases the company's risk as it becomes a fixed expense that must be paid regardless of the company's earnings. If the company fails to generate enough cash, the debt burden may become too high to manage. Therefore, debt financing is more suitable for companies in stable industries with consistent cash flows, while equity financing may be a better option for riskier businesses or those with high uncertainty.

Returns depend on risk

For example, the average annual return for stocks since 1926 has been 10.1%. However, this figure is reduced by inflation, which decreases the value of currency over time. Investors in the stock market can expect to lose 2% to 3% of their purchasing power every year due to inflation.

The stock market is volatile, and returns can vary significantly from year to year. While the market has returned an average of 10% per year over the long term, this has only occurred eight times between 1926 and 2024. Returns have more often been much lower or much higher.

Startups are another example of high-risk, high-reward investments. Startup equity is considered a high-risk, illiquid asset class. Many startups fail, and investors lose their money. However, if a startup succeeds, investors can expect a very large return on their investment.

Debt financing and equity financing are two other types of investments with different risk profiles. Debt financing involves taking out a loan from a bank or other lender, while equity financing involves selling shares in a company to raise capital. Debt financing usually has a lower effective cost than equity financing, as interest on debt is tax-deductible. However, debt financing also presents more risk, as it creates a fixed expense that increases a company's risk. If a company fails to generate enough cash, the fixed cost of debt can become too burdensome.

Overall, investors need to understand the relationship between risk and return. Higher-risk investments will demand higher returns, while lower-risk investments will offer lower returns. It's important for investors to carefully consider their risk tolerance and investment goals when deciding where to put their money.

Frequently asked questions