India's Future: Defense, Agriculture, Or Education?

India's defence sector is crucial for its national security and self-reliance in defence production. With the world's second-largest army, India has a robust defence capability to protect its borders and citizens. The sector covers areas such as aerospace, land and naval systems, with both public and private companies contributing to manufacturing defence equipment. The defence industry plays a vital role in safeguarding the nation by producing and maintaining military equipment, and it has seen a surge in stock prices as investors show strong confidence in its potential.

On the other hand, India's agriculture sector is also significant, contributing 18.3% to the country's total economy in FY 2022-23. India is a leading producer and exporter of various agricultural products, including wheat, rice, fruits and vegetables, and its exports in this sector are increasing.

Both the defence and agriculture sectors are important for India's economy and development. The decision to invest more in either sector would depend on various factors, including the government's priorities, budgetary allocations, and the need to strengthen different areas of the country's overall well-being and security.

India's defence industry and its indigenous production

India's defence industry is strategically important, and the country has one of the world's largest military forces, with over 1.44 million active personnel and the largest volunteer military of over 5.1 million personnel. However, India has been heavily dependent on defence imports, ranking as the second-largest importer behind Saudi Arabia, making up 9.2% of global arms imports. This dependence on imports is due to skewed incentives among key stakeholders and a lack of policy predictability.

To reduce this dependence, the Indian government has implemented several initiatives to promote indigenous defence production and enhance the growth of domestic defence companies. The "Defence Production Policy of 2018" (DPrP-2018) aims to make India one of the top five global producers of aerospace and defence manufacturing, with an annual export target of $5 billion by 2025. The government has introduced policies such as "Make in India" and the Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) to boost indigenous production and reduce imports.

The defence industry in India covers a wide range of areas, including aerospace, land, and naval systems, with both public and private companies contributing to the manufacturing of defence equipment and supplies. The public sector includes entities such as NTRO, CSIR, PRL, DRDO and its labs, defence shipyards, and defence public sector undertakings (PSUs). The private sector also plays a significant role, with companies like Adani Defence & Aerospace, Alpha Design Technologies, and Astra Microwave Products involved in defence manufacturing.

Despite these efforts, India still faces challenges in achieving self-reliance in defence production. The defence public sector is resistant to ceding space to private competitors, and the decision-making process is influenced by inherent conflicts of interest. Additionally, the economics of the defence industry, with precise specifications, high exposure to risk, and uncertain demand, further complicate the situation.

To address these challenges, India needs to implement policies that facilitate indigenisation and provide long-term predictability. This includes establishing long-term requirements, objective assessment criteria for technology, transparent and predictable processes, and partnerships between the armed services, research establishments, and industry.

In conclusion, India's defence industry and its indigenous production have come a long way, but there is still room for improvement. By addressing the challenges and implementing policies that promote self-reliance, India can reduce its dependence on defence imports and strengthen its domestic defence capabilities.

The role of the government in India's defence industry

Overview

The Indian defence industry is strategically important and has a large military force with over 1.44 million active personnel and the world's largest volunteer military of over 5.1 million personnel. The country has a domestic defence industry, 60% of which is government-owned. The public sector includes entities such as the DRDO and its labs, defence shipyards, and defence public sector undertakings (PSUs).

Government Initiatives

The Indian government has implemented various initiatives to boost indigenous manufacturing and reduce imports, such as the "Atmanirbhar Bharat" initiative and the Defence Production Policy of 2018, which aims to increase domestic manufacturing and exports. The government has also launched the "Make in India" initiative and eased export regulations to encourage domestic production and exports.

Budget Allocations

The Indian government has consistently allocated a significant budget to the defence sector, with a total budget of ₹4.78 lakh crore (approximately US$67 billion) in 2021. In the 2024-25 budget, defence was allocated ₹6.22 lakh crore, with capital spending increasing by 9.4% to ₹1.72 lakh crore. The defence budget accounts for about 12.9% of the total budget outlay for 2024-25.

Performance of the Public Sector

The public sector has been the primary supplier of major arms and equipment to the armed forces but has faced challenges in meeting their growing requirements. The public sector's contribution to India's defence procurement has been around 57%, while the overall contribution of the Indian industry is about 72%. The public sector also has a high dependency on imported inputs, with a significant portion of their sales coming from non-defence clients and exports.

Reform in the Defence Public Sector

The government has taken steps to reform the public sector, including the corporatisation of ordnance factories into DPSUs, intending to improve efficiency, autonomy, and innovation. The government has also announced the privatisation of BEML and the listing of several DPSUs on the stock exchange to improve corporate governance and accountability.

Competition from the Private Sector

The private sector's role in defence production and R&D is slowly increasing, with the government providing a level playing field and dedicated procedures for their participation. The private sector has been successful in obtaining orders for complex equipment and competing directly with foreign companies. The government has identified 18 items for industry-led design and development, with enhanced funding support for R&D.

Challenges and Future Prospects

While the Indian defence industry has made progress, it faces challenges in scaling up production to match procurement needs and reducing dependence on external sources for technology and input materials. The government needs to expedite procurement decision-making and fully implement the announced reforms to translate them into actual production and delivery. The goal is to achieve a production target of ₹1,750 billion (US$26 billion) by 2025, including exports of ₹350 billion (US$5 billion).

India's agricultural exports

The country's agricultural production is highly dependent on seasonal rainfall, and farm yields are generally below world averages due to various factors such as inadequate farmer education, heavy government regulation, poor infrastructure, and small average farm sizes. However, India is among the world's leaders in terms of production volume for commodities such as rice, wheat, cotton, sugar, horticulture, and dairy.

The Indian agricultural sector is slowly shifting from traditional farming to horticulture and livestock production. The demand for fresh and processed products is increasing due to urbanization, rising incomes, and changing consumption habits. The growth of an efficient cold chain network will help curb spoilage rates and improve the quality of agricultural output.

India has also developed export competitiveness in specialized agricultural and related products, becoming the world's 9th largest exporter in this sector. In 2021, India achieved an $11.8 billion global trade surplus in agricultural and related products, with leading exports including Basmati rice, prawns, shellfish, carabeef, spices, and refined sugar.

To promote indigenous manufacturing and reduce foreign dependence, the Indian government has launched initiatives such as "Atmanirbhar Bharat," which has contributed to a defence production value of over $15 billion in 2023-24. India's defence sector is the fourth largest globally, with a budget allocation of USD 74.7 billion in 2024.

India's agricultural policies

Enhancing Agricultural Productivity, Competitiveness, and Rural Growth:

• India aims to promote new technologies and reform agricultural research and extension systems. This includes improving infrastructure, personnel, and access to state-of-the-art technologies.
• There is a need to better manage water resources and irrigation, especially with increasing competition for water from industry and domestic use. This involves enhancing productivity per unit of water ("more crop per drop"), adopting efficient delivery mechanisms like drip irrigation, and managing groundwater usage.
• Diversification to higher-value crops and developing competitive value chains are essential to increase productivity and reduce marketing costs.

Poverty Alleviation and Community Actions:

• Agricultural growth alone may not be sufficient to address poverty, and additional measures are required.
• Promoting rural livelihoods programs that empower communities to become self-reliant has been effective. This includes forming self-help groups, increasing community savings, and encouraging local initiatives to boost incomes and employment.
• These self-help groups are particularly beneficial in reaching and empowering women and impoverished families.

Environmental Sustainability and Future Agricultural Productivity:

• Over-pumping of water for agriculture is causing falling groundwater levels in some parts of India, while water-logging is leading to soil salinity in irrigated areas.
• Watershed management programs are crucial to addressing these issues by engaging communities in land planning and adopting agricultural practices that protect soils, increase water absorption, and raise productivity through crop diversification.
• Climate change considerations, including more extreme weather events, will also impact agricultural practices, especially in rain-fed areas.

Government Initiatives and Support:

• The Indian government has introduced initiatives like "Make in India" and "Atmanirbhar Bharat" to boost indigenous production and reduce foreign dependence.
• The government has also relaxed FDI norms, allowing up to 74% FDI through the automatic route to encourage foreign investment and technology enhancements.
• The World Bank's agriculture and rural development program in India is the largest in the world, with net commitments of $5.5 billion. This includes support for R&D in agricultural technology, dissemination of agricultural technology, improved access to rural credit, and agricultural insurance, among other areas.

Challenges and Risks:

• One of the main challenges is raising agricultural productivity per unit of land, especially with limited water resources and competition for water from other sectors.
• Reducing rural poverty and ensuring that agricultural growth addresses food security needs are also crucial.
• Additionally, there is a need to manage overexploited and degrading forest land through mitigation measures.

India's agricultural infrastructure

Government Support

The Indian government has recognised the importance of agriculture, which is the primary source of livelihood for about 55% of the country's population. Various initiatives have been implemented to support the sector, such as the National e-Governance Plan in Agriculture, the creation of Digital Public Infrastructure, and the introduction of the Pradhan Mantri Kisan Samman Nidhi Yojana (PM-Kisan) scheme, which provided financial assistance to farmers. The government has also made significant allocations to the agriculture and allied sectors in the Union Budget for 2024-25, amounting to Rs. 1.52 lakh crore (US$18.26 billion).

Food Processing Industry

India's food processing industry is one of the largest in the country, accounting for 32% of the total food market. It is ranked fifth globally in terms of production, consumption, export, and expected growth. The government has introduced schemes such as Pradhan Mantri Kisan Sampada Yojana (PMKSY) to enhance the food processing infrastructure and create modern infrastructure for food processing and preservation. The food processing industry also allows 100% Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) under the automatic route, attracting foreign investment.

Digital Initiatives

The Indian government has implemented several digital initiatives to modernise the agricultural sector. This includes the National e-Governance Plan in Agriculture, the construction of Digital Public Infrastructure, and the update of the Soil Health Card site with a Geographic Information System (GIS). These initiatives aim to provide farmers with access to the latest agricultural technologies and market information.

Export Promotion

India has been promoting its agricultural exports through various policies and initiatives. The Agricultural and Processed Food Products Export Development Authority (APEDA) has been instrumental in boosting exports, particularly in commodities such as basmati and non-basmati rice, spices, marine products, and sugar. The government's Agriculture Export Policy, 2018, aimed to increase agricultural exports to US$60 billion by 2022 and US$100 billion in subsequent years.

Investment in Infrastructure

The Indian government has made significant investments in agricultural infrastructure, such as irrigation facilities, warehousing, and cold storage. The Pradhan Mantri Krishi Sinchai Yojana (PMKSY) was launched with an investment of Rs. 50,000 crore (US$7.7 billion) to develop irrigation sources and provide a permanent solution to drought. Additionally, the government has committed Rs. 6,000 crore (US$729 million) for investments in mega food parks under the Scheme for Agro-Marine Processing and Development of Agro-Processing Clusters (SAMPADA).

Private Investment

Private investment in agriculture has also increased in recent years. From 2017 to 2020, India received approximately US$1 billion in agritech funding, ranking third in terms of agritech funding and the number of agritech startups. By 2025, Indian agritech companies are expected to attract investments worth US$30-35 billion.

Frequently asked questions