Equity Investment: Why It's Better Than Convertible Debt

Convertible securities are a type of financial instrument that can be converted into equity or ownership in a company at a future date. They are often used by startups as a way to raise capital without having to set a valuation, which can be challenging for early-stage companies. While convertible securities can provide benefits such as faster and cheaper fundraising, there are also potential downsides, including unexpected dilution and complex negotiations. For investors, convertible securities can offer an attractive opportunity that combines the potential for future equity ownership with the security of a debt instrument. However, it's important to consider the potential limitations and risks associated with convertible securities before making any investment decisions.

Equity offers greater investor protection than convertible debt

Equity investments are often preferred by investors because they provide voting rights and a say in company decisions. In contrast, convertible debt instruments like convertible bonds initially give investors the status of creditors, and they do not have voting rights. While convertible debt can be converted into equity at a later date, this conversion is not guaranteed and is often at the discretion of the company. This means that investors in convertible debt may not have a say in the company's operations or direction, which can be a significant disadvantage for those who want to actively influence the business.

Equity investments also provide a clearer picture of ownership and control. With equity, investors know exactly what percentage of the company they own and can make informed decisions about buying or selling based on this information. In contrast, with convertible debt, it is challenging to determine the exact ownership percentage, especially if multiple rounds of convertible debt are issued at different prices. This lack of clarity can lead to unexpected dilution for investors.

Additionally, equity investments offer a more straightforward exit strategy. When an investor wants to exit their position, they can simply sell their equity stake on the market. With convertible debt, the exit process can be more complex and may involve converting the debt into equity before selling, or there may be restrictions or buyback clauses that limit the investor's ability to exit.

Furthermore, equity investments provide a more direct claim on the company's assets and profits. Equity investors typically have priority over debt holders in the event of liquidation or bankruptcy. They are higher up in the capital structure and are more likely to recoup their investment, even in unfavourable scenarios.

Lastly, equity investments often provide a more stable investment with less risk of loss. Convertible debt, being a hybrid instrument, combines the risks of both debt and equity. If the company performs poorly, convertible debt holders may face losses as creditors, and if the company performs exceptionally well, they may miss out on gains compared to pure equity holders. Equity investments offer a more direct participation in the company's performance, for better or worse, providing greater transparency and potentially reducing overall risk.

While convertible debt has its advantages in certain scenarios, equity offers greater investor protection through voting rights, clear ownership stakes, simpler exit strategies, higher priority in the capital structure, and a more direct participation in the company's performance.

Convertible debt is a more flexible option for funding rounds

Convertible debt is a flexible option for funding rounds, offering benefits to both startup founders and investors.

For startups, convertible debt provides a way to secure financing without immediately determining the company's value, which can be challenging for early-stage companies. It allows them to raise capital without giving up too much equity too early on, helping them maintain control and attract future investors.

Convertible debt is also a flexible tool that can be used in various funding scenarios, such as bridge financing or funding rounds, including seed funding and Series A, B, and C rounds. It is particularly useful for intra-round financing or as a bridge between larger rounds of equity.

Additionally, convertible debt is simpler and quicker to execute from a legal perspective, resulting in lower legal fees. It avoids the need to place a valuation on the startup, which is especially beneficial for seed-stage companies that may not have sufficient operating history to set an accurate valuation.

For investors, convertible debt offers an attractive opportunity to combine the potential for future equity ownership with the security of a debt instrument. It provides the safety and security of debt, typically considered less risky than equity investments, as the investor's initial investment is secured by the company's assets, and they receive a fixed rate of return.

Convertible debt also allows investors to benefit from the company's growth without taking on the same level of risk as pure equity investments. It offers the flexibility to convert debt into equity at a later date, providing the opportunity to participate in the company's growth and potential equity appreciation.

Convertible debt is quicker and cheaper to execute

Secondly, convertible debt allows companies to delay placing a value on themselves. This is particularly useful for startups and early-stage companies that have not had time to establish a track record or revenue stream. By giving investors a discount on the price that is set later, the company can push that decision to a later date.

Thirdly, convertible debt is a flexible option that can be used in a variety of funding scenarios, such as bridge financing or funding rounds. It is a good option for companies that need to raise capital between larger rounds of equity. For example, a company might use convertible debt to raise a smaller amount of funds to quickly ramp up staff before a larger equity round.

Finally, convertible debt is a good option for companies that need to raise capital quickly. It requires fewer terms to be discussed, meaning less time spent negotiating and lower legal fees.

Convertible debt can be used as a bridge to equity

Convertible debt is often used by high-growth early-stage companies as it allows them to secure funding without giving up too much equity too early on. It is also easier to issue than equity investments as it does not require changes to the company's shareholder agreement. This makes it faster and cheaper, with lower fees involved.

For investors, convertible debt offers the potential for future equity ownership while providing the stability of a debt instrument. It also provides protection against heavy losses and pays higher income than common stock.

Convertible debt is particularly useful as a bridge to equity in the context of bridge financing. This type of financing is used to provide capital to a private issuer that may not have access to traditional debt markets, in anticipation of an equity financing transaction. The anticipated equity financing could be an issuance of equity or a public offering, such as an initial public offering (IPO).

Bridge convertible debt instruments typically have a short-term maturity, usually two years or less, and they become convertible on the occurrence of specified events, such as an IPO that results in a market capitalization exceeding a certain threshold. The conversion price is highly variable and may be set at a discount to the price in the qualified public event.

In summary, convertible debt is a valuable tool for companies and investors, offering a flexible and attractive option for bridge financing. It allows companies to access capital quickly and provides investors with the potential for equity ownership and the safety of debt.

Convertible debt can be a safer option for investors

Safety and Security of Debt

Convertible debt provides investors with the safety and security of debt. This is because the investor's initial investment is secured by the company's assets, and they are guaranteed a fixed rate of return. Additionally, if the company is unable to pay back the debt, the investor may have the option to convert it into equity. This means that investors can benefit from the company's growth without taking on the same level of risk as pure equity investment.

Potential for Future Equity Ownership

Convertible debt offers investors the potential for future equity ownership. This means that investors who purchase convertible debt can benefit from potential equity ownership while still receiving the safety and security of debt. The conversion feature provides the opportunity for upside participation, while the fixed-income features of convertible debt can cushion the impact of equity market drawdowns.

Reduced Interest Rate Risk

The equity characteristics of convertible debt have made them less susceptible to rising interest rates than non-convertible bonds. Many investors may welcome the reduced duration risk of shorter maturities as well.

Reduced Dilution

Simpler and Cheaper

Convertible debt financings are generally simpler to document from a legal perspective, making them less expensive and quicker to execute. This is because the company and investors are putting off some of the trickier details to a later date. In most equity financings, numerous corporate documents need to be updated, adding to the time and expense of completing the round.

Frequently asked questions