Portfolio Investments: Developing Countries' Failure

Portfolio investment flows have been the fastest-growing form of external finance for developing countries, accounting for one-fifth of all capital flows to the developing world. However, these investments are heavily concentrated in a few economies, mainly in Latin America. While portfolio investments can provide significant benefits to developing countries, there are also concerns about their volatility and sustainability. Developing countries need to carefully assess the potential impact of such investments and take steps to maximize their benefits, such as listing stocks internationally, strengthening regulatory policies, and improving settlement and clearing procedures. Additionally, developing countries should focus on improving the overall investment climate, including the functioning of markets and the protection of foreign investors, to attract more stable forms of investment, such as foreign direct investment (FDI).

Investor perceptions of country creditworthiness

Investor perceptions of a country's creditworthiness are key to understanding the flow of portfolio investments to developing countries. While portfolio investments have been the fastest-growing form of external finance for developing countries, their expansion to new markets is limited by investor perceptions of country creditworthiness and the size of emerging markets.

Investors tend to perceptions of country creditworthiness are key to understanding the flow of portfolio investments to developing countries. While portfolio investments have been the fastest-growing form of external finance for developing countries, their expansion to new markets is limited by investor perceptions of country creditworthiness and the size of emerging markets.

Investors tend to

Limited investment opportunities in small emerging markets

Small emerging markets often have limited investment opportunities due to their size and stage of development. These markets typically have a small number of large corporations with significant market capitalizations, resulting in relatively illiquid and concentrated equity markets. The limited supply of stocks and high concentration of market capitalization in a few companies can deter investors and make it challenging to diversify investment portfolios.

Additionally, small emerging markets may exhibit higher volatility compared to more developed markets. This volatility can be attributed to various factors, including political instability, economic risks such as insufficient labour or raw materials, high inflation or deflation, unregulated markets, and unsound monetary policies. Currency fluctuations can also significantly impact investment returns, especially when compared to more stable currencies like the US dollar.

To mitigate these risks, investors can consider diversifying their investments across different emerging markets and sectors. Mutual funds or ETFs that focus on emerging markets can offer a blend of stocks from various sectors and countries, reducing the impact of volatility in any single market. However, it is essential to maintain a long-term perspective, as emerging markets can be volatile in the short term but potentially rewarding in the long term.

Furthermore, small emerging markets may have less developed regulatory frameworks, which can pose additional challenges for investors. Weak regulatory environments may increase the risk of insider trading, irregular stock market activities, and inadequate accounting practices and disclosure requirements. Strengthening supervisory and regulatory policies, improving settlement and clearing procedures, and adopting internationally accepted accounting and disclosure standards can help address these issues.

While small emerging markets present challenges, they also offer growth opportunities. For example, countries with youthful populations and growing workforces, such as Mexico and India, may experience increased economic output, consumption, and foreign investment. Additionally, participation in global trade and investments in infrastructure can further enhance their growth prospects.

In summary, small emerging markets may offer limited investment opportunities due to their size, market concentration, volatility, and regulatory weaknesses. However, by adopting diversification strategies, maintaining a long-term perspective, and supporting regulatory improvements, investors can potentially benefit from the growth potential of these markets.

Foreign investors' long-term investment horizons

Foreign investors with long-term investment horizons are typically institutional investors, such as pension funds and life insurance companies. These investors are motivated by the potential for portfolio diversification and the prospect of stable, long-term growth in emerging markets. Their investments are often a small fraction of their overall holdings, and they tend to favour countries with a track record of domestic policy reforms, such as Chile and Mexico.

The benefits of foreign portfolio investment for developing countries are significant. Firstly, it provides access to external finance, which has been the fastest-growing form of external finance for developing countries, accounting for one-fifth of all capital flows. Secondly, it facilitates the transfer of technology, skills, and innovative capacity, as well as the diffusion of best practices in corporate governance, accounting, and legal traditions. Additionally, foreign portfolio investment can contribute to economic growth in developing countries, particularly through non-interest-bearing assets.

However, there are also challenges and risks associated with foreign portfolio investment in developing countries. The concentration of these investments in a handful of economies, mainly in Latin America, limits their expansion to other countries. Investor perceptions of country creditworthiness and limited investment opportunities in small emerging markets can further restrict the flow of funds. Moreover, developing countries may struggle with the management of large capital inflows and the potential for sudden outflows, which can impact exchange rates and monetary policies.

To maximise the benefits of foreign portfolio investment, developing countries can take several steps. These include listing stocks internationally, strengthening regulatory policies, conforming to accounting and disclosure standards, ensuring investor protection, and improving the efficiency of settlement and clearing procedures. By addressing these factors, developing countries can attract foreign investors with long-term investment horizons and promote sustainable economic growth.

Country risk and credit ratings

Country risk is a significant factor in the flow of portfolio investments to developing countries. Investors are often concerned about the volatility and sustainability of portfolio investments in emerging markets, which can be influenced by country risk factors such as economic and political stability, regulatory environment, and market liquidity.

Credit ratings play a crucial role in assessing country risk. Credit rating agencies, such as Standard & Poor's, Fitch, and Moody's, evaluate the creditworthiness of sovereign entities, including countries. These agencies assess a country's ability to repay its debts and provide a rating that reflects the level of risk associated with investing in that country.

The credit rating of a country can impact the cost and availability of capital for that nation. A high credit rating indicates a lower risk of default and can lead to more favourable borrowing terms, such as lower interest rates. On the other hand, a low credit rating, often referred to as "junk" status, can make it difficult for a country to access international capital markets and may lead to higher borrowing costs.

The impact of country risk and credit ratings on portfolio investments is evident in the concentration of these investments in specific regions, such as Latin America. Countries with stronger economic fundamentals, stable political environments, and favourable regulatory frameworks tend to attract more portfolio investments. Additionally, the size and liquidity of the local stock market can also influence investment decisions, as larger markets provide more opportunities for diversification and exit options.

To mitigate country risk and enhance their creditworthiness, developing countries can implement various measures. These include improving the efficiency of settlement and clearing procedures, strengthening regulatory frameworks, adopting internationally accepted accounting and disclosure standards, and ensuring investor protection. By addressing these factors, developing countries can maximise the benefits of portfolio investments and attract a broader range of investors.

The role of institutional investors

Institutional investors are companies or organisations that invest money on behalf of clients or members. They are considered to be more sophisticated than the average investor and are often subject to less regulatory oversight. They include public and private pension funds, insurance companies, savings institutions, investment banks, hedge funds, mutual funds, and endowment funds.

Institutional investors have access to large amounts of capital and specialised knowledge, allowing them to extensively research a variety of investment opportunities not available to retail investors. They are the largest force behind supply and demand in securities markets, performing a high percentage of transactions on major exchanges and greatly influencing security prices.

In the context of portfolio investments in developing countries, institutional investors have played a significant role in the unprecedented increase in private portfolio investment flows. These investors are attracted by the portfolio diversification benefits that come with investing a small portion of their holdings in developing country obligations. They tend to have a longer-term investment horizon and seek stability and long-term growth prospects.

However, institutional investors have only allocated a small fraction of their investable portfolios to developing countries, with less than 5% of their foreign equity holdings invested in developing country equities. This allocation is expected to increase if developing countries can demonstrate a sustained and proven commitment to sound economic management and financial sector regulation.

Frequently asked questions