Share Repurchases: Impact On Short-Term Investment Strategies

A share repurchase would reduce a company's cash holdings and total asset base by the amount of cash spent on the buyback. This would simultaneously shrink shareholders' equity on the liabilities side by the same amount. As a result, performance metrics such as return on assets (ROA) and return on equity (ROE) typically improve subsequent to a share buyback.

Repurchasing shares depletes cash reserves

On the balance sheet, a share repurchase would reduce the company’s cash holdings—and consequently its total asset base—by the amount of cash expended in the buyback. It will simultaneously shrink shareholders’ equity on the liabilities side by the same amount.

Repurchasing shares does not create value for shareholders, though on the surface it raises the earnings per share. Part of the rewards for managers may be tied to targets on share price or earnings per share. Using cash to repurchase shares means either reducing the firms' investments or increasing its borrowing, both of which reduce future earnings.

The short-term price increase after buybacks is modest and does not reverse on average. Share repurchases have been critically evaluated since the 1970s when the Securities and Exchange Commission ascertained "that a large volume of stock buybacks would manipulate the market". Rule 10b-18 has been criticized for leaving stock repurchases "virtually unregulated".

Repurchases may also be used to signal and/or take advantage of undervaluation. If a firm's manager believes their firm's stock is currently trading below its intrinsic value, they may consider repurchases. An open market repurchase, whereby no premium is paid on top of the current market price, offers a potentially profitable investment for the manager.

Short-term price increase does not reverse

Share repurchases have been critically evaluated since the 1970s when the Securities and Exchange Commission ascertained that a large volume of stock buybacks would manipulate the market. Rule 10b-18 has been criticized for leaving stock repurchases virtually unregulated. According to Lenore Palladino, an economist at the Roosevelt Institute, stock buyback programs are "one of the drivers of our imbalanced economy, in which corporate profits and shareholder payments continue to grow while wages for typical workers stay flat".

The short-term price increase after buybacks is modest and does not reverse on average. Repurchasing shares depletes the company's cash reserves, putting it in a precarious position if the economy takes a downturn or the corporation faces unexpected financial obligations. Apple (AAPL) spent an astounding $100 billion repurchasing its stock during its fiscal 2024 year. There's no guarantee that this pace will continue but the company is sitting on $65 billion in free cash flow and short-term investments. Two other tech giants, Alphabet (GOOG) and Meta (META), engaged in massive share buybacks in 2024.

Investors tend to reward firms that report consistent earnings growth, meet analysts' earnings forecasts, and avoid earnings disappointments. However, using cash to repurchase shares means either reducing the firms' investments or increasing its borrowing, both of which reduce future earnings. Part of the curiosity of a company repurchasing its own shares is the fact that such behavior does not create value for shareholders, though on the surface it raises the earnings per share. Managerial incentives may cloud the company's larger goals. "Though some managers just want a short-term gain, we ideally want managers to care about the long term," says Wong.

Repurchases may signal undervaluation

Repurchases may also be used to signal and/or take advantage of undervaluation. If a firm's manager believes their firm's stock is currently trading below its intrinsic value, they may consider repurchases. An open market repurchase, whereby no premium is paid on top of the current market price, offers a potentially profitable investment for the manager. That is, they may repurchase the currently undervalued shares, wait for the market to correct the undervaluation whereby prices increase to the intrinsic value of the equity, and re-issue them at a profit. Alternatively, they may undertake a fixed price tender offer, whereby a premium is often offered over the current market price; this sends a strong signal to the market that they believe that the firm's equity is undervalued, which is proven by their willingness to pay above market price to repurchase the shares.

Apple (AAPL) spent an astounding $100 billion repurchasing its stock during its fiscal 2024 year. There's no guarantee that this pace will continue but the company is sitting on $65 billion in free cash flow and short-term investments. Two other tech giants, Alphabet (GOOG) and Meta (META), engaged in massive share buybacks in 2024.

The Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) of 2022 introduced a 1% excise tax on share repurchases of over $1 million of any U.S. corporation trading on an established exchange.

Repurchasing shares depletes the company's cash reserves, putting it in a precarious position if the economy takes a downturn or the corporation faces unexpected financial obligations.

The short-term price increase after buybacks is modest and does not reverse on average. Share repurchases have been critically evaluated since the 1970's when Securities and Exchange Commission ascertained "that a large volume of stock buybacks would manipulate the market". Rule 10b-18 has been criticized for leaving stock repurchases "virtually unregulated". According to Lenore Palladino, an economist at the Roosevelt Institute, stock buy back programs are "one of the drivers of our imbalanced economy, in which corporate profits and shareholder payments continue to grow while wages for typical workers stay flat".

Repurchases reduce cash holdings

Repurchasing shares depletes the company's cash reserves, putting it in a precarious position if the economy takes a downturn or the corporation faces unexpected financial obligations.

Apple (AAPL) spent an astounding $100 billion repurchasing its stock during its fiscal 2024 year. There's no guarantee that this pace will continue but the company is sitting on $65 billion in free cash flow and short-term investments.

Two other tech giants, Alphabet (GOOG) and Meta (META), engaged in massive share buybacks in 2024.

The Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) of 2022 introduced a 1% excise tax on share repurchases of over $1 million of any U.S. corporation trading on an established exchange.

Performance metrics improve post-buyback

Share repurchases can have a significant positive impact on an investor’s portfolio. Performance metrics such as return on assets (ROA) and return on equity (ROE) typically improve subsequent to a share buyback. Companies generally specify the amount spent on share repurchases in their quarterly earnings reports. You also may get the amount spent on share buybacks from the statement of cash flows (in the financing activities section) and the statement of changes in equity, which is also known as the “statement of retained earnings.”

Repurchasing shares depletes the company's cash reserves, putting it in a precarious position if the economy takes a downturn or the corporation faces unexpected financial obligations. Investors tend to reward firms that report consistent earnings growth, meet analysts' earnings forecasts, and avoid earnings disappointments. However, using cash to repurchase shares means either reducing the firms' investments or increasing its borrowing, both of which reduce future earnings.

The short-term price increase after buybacks is modest and does not reverse on average. Share repurchases have been critically evaluated since the 1970's when Securities and Exchange Commission ascertained "that a large volume of stock buybacks would manipulate the market". Rule 10b-18 has been criticized for leaving stock repurchases "virtually unregulated". According to Lenore Palladino, an economist at the Roosevelt Institute, stock buy back programs are "one of the drivers of our imbalanced economy, in which corporate profits and shareholder payments continue to grow while wages for typical workers stay flat".

An open market repurchase, whereby no premium is paid on top of current market price, offers a potentially profitable investment for the manager. That is, they may repurchase the currently undervalued shares, wait for the market to correct the undervaluation whereby prices increase to the intrinsic value of the equity, and re-issue them at a profit. Alternatively, they may undertake a fixed price tender offer, whereby a premium is often offered over current market price; this sends a strong signal to the market that they believe that the firm's equity is undervalued, which is proven by their willingness to pay above market price to repurchase the shares.

Frequently asked questions