Mutual Fund Risks: Is Your Money Safe?

Investing in mutual funds is generally considered a safe option, but there are some associated risks. Mutual funds are a type of market-linked security, and all market-linked securities are subject to some level of risk. While mutual funds are a good way to minimise risk when compared to investing in a single stock or bond, they are still vulnerable to changing market conditions. These changing conditions can be caused by a variety of factors, including economic developments, government policies, regulatory changes, interest rates, investor sentiment, and external shocks such as natural disasters or war.

There are also specific risks associated with mutual funds, including security risk, liquidity risk, and inflation rate risk. Security risk refers to the possibility of a company defaulting on its debentures, while liquidity risk refers to the ease of selling a security at a fair value. Inflation rate risk is the possibility of losing purchasing power due to an increase in consumer prices.

Additionally, mutual funds may not be suitable for investors who want total control over their holdings, as the funds are managed and regulated by fund managers. High fees and charges can also make mutual funds a less attractive investment option. However, with proper research and understanding of the different types of mutual funds, these risks can be mitigated.

High fees and charges

Types of Fees

Mutual fund fees generally fall into two categories: Annual Fund Operating Expenses and Shareholder Fees. Annual Fund Operating Expenses cover the cost of paying managers, accountants, legal fees, marketing, and other operational costs. Shareholder Fees, on the other hand, are sales commissions and other one-time costs incurred when buying or selling mutual fund shares.

Expense Ratios

Mutual funds charge an "expense ratio" as a percentage of the fund's net average assets, which covers the cost of managing the fund. This can vary greatly depending on the type of fund and its internal costs. Actively managed funds, small-cap funds, and international funds tend to have higher expense ratios compared to passively managed funds, large-cap funds, and domestic funds. Expense ratios for mutual funds typically range from 0.25% to 3%, with an industry average of around 0.54% to 1.5%.

Load Charges

Mutual funds may also have front-end or back-end load charges, also known as sales loads or commissions. Front-end loads are paid when purchasing shares, while back-end loads are paid when selling shares. These fees can range from 2% to 5% and are typically associated with different classes of shares offered by the fund.

Other Fees

In addition to the above, mutual funds may charge a variety of other fees, including redemption fees, exchange fees, account fees, and purchase fees. Redemption fees are charged when an investor sells shares shortly after purchasing them, while exchange fees apply when transferring shares to another fund within the same investment company. Account fees may be charged if an investor's balance falls below a specified minimum, and purchase fees are paid directly to the fund at the time of purchase.

Impact on Returns

Lack of control

Investing in mutual funds is considered relatively safe and a good way to diversify with minimal risk. However, there are certain risks involved with mutual funds, and one of them is the lack of control.

Mutual funds are managed funds, meaning that investors do not have total control over their holdings. The fund managers do all the picking and investing work, which may be unsuitable for investors who want to have complete control over their portfolios and regularly rebalance their holdings. Many mutual funds' prospectuses contain caveats that allow them to deviate from their stated investment objectives, and this can be a concern for investors who wish to have consistent portfolios.

Additionally, due to rules and regulations, many funds may generate diluted returns. Mutual funds are not allowed to have concentrated holdings exceeding 25% of their overall portfolio, which means they cannot focus all their resources on one best-performing holding as an individual stock would. As a result, mutual funds may produce diluted returns, limiting potential profits.

For investors who want more control over their investments, alternative options such as investing directly in stocks or bonds may be more suitable. These options provide greater autonomy in decision-making and allow for more active management of the portfolio.

It is important to note that while lack of control can be a disadvantage for some investors, others may view the managed nature of mutual funds as an advantage. Mutual funds are particularly attractive to those who are not experts in stock market dynamics, as the funds are operated by experienced fund managers.

Diluted returns

Mutual funds are also required to disclose how much they charge their investors annually to compensate for the costs of running investment businesses. This is known as the expense ratio and is expressed as a percentage of the fund's average net assets. The expense ratio is then deducted from the fund's returns, reducing the gross return. According to fund manager Vanguard, the industry-wide average expense ratio was 0.54% in 2020, but it can be as high as 3%.

In addition, many mutual funds charge load fees, which are imposed on investors when they buy or sell shares of a fund. These can be front-end or back-end loads, charged at the time of buying or selling, respectively. They can range from 2% to 4% and eat into the returns generated by mutual funds.

It is worth noting that mutual funds are considered relatively safe investments, keeping risk at a minimum compared to stocks or bonds. However, the fees and charges associated with them can make them an unattractive investment option.

Returns not guaranteed

Mutual funds are not guaranteed to generate returns. While they are considered a relatively safe investment, they are not without risk. The value of a mutual fund's portfolio depends on the performance of the securities it invests in, and these are subject to market fluctuations.

The deciding factors for the returns generated by a mutual fund scheme include the movement of the specific market in which the money is invested, the performance of individual securities held, and the skills of the investment management team. Out of these, the fund manager can only work on improving their skills; the other factors are beyond their control.

Mutual funds are not an investment in and of themselves but a vehicle to invest in various avenues. The money put into a mutual fund is invested by professional fund managers in line with the scheme's objective. The performance of these investments impacts the returns generated by the mutual fund scheme.

Mutual funds are also not allowed to have concentrated holdings, with regulations preventing them from holding more than 25% of their overall portfolio in a single investment. This means they may tend to generate diluted returns as they cannot concentrate their portfolios on one best-performing holding.

Mutual funds are also subject to various fees and charges, including annual fees, expense ratios, and commissions, which will lower their overall returns.

Mitigating Risk

While mutual funds do carry risk, there are ways to mitigate this. Diversification is one of the advantages of investing in mutual funds, as a diversified portfolio will include securities with different capitalizations and industries and bonds with varying maturities and issuers.

Mutual funds also provide access to dollar-cost averaging, which involves putting away a set amount periodically, regardless of market changes.

Additionally, investors can build a portfolio that matches their risk appetite, factoring in their age, financial standing, risk appetite, and financial goals.

Risk of non-compliance

Investing in mutual funds is generally considered a safe option, but there are still risks involved. These risks can be mitigated by understanding the investment and investing based on your financial goals, time horizon, and risk tolerance.

One of the risks associated with mutual funds is the risk of non-compliance. Non-compliance can lead to legal and regulatory issues, which can result in fines, penalties, and reputational damage. Here are some key considerations regarding the risk of non-compliance in mutual funds:

• Regulatory Requirements: Mutual funds are heavily regulated by organizations such as the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) and the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA). These regulatory bodies enforce rules related to advertising, sales practices, fees, portfolio transactions, and investor protection. Non-compliance with these regulations can result in legal consequences and damage to the fund's reputation.
• Disclosure and Transparency: Mutual funds are required to disclose various types of information to investors, such as portfolio details, performance, investment strategy, and risk factors. Non-compliance with disclosure requirements can mislead investors and result in regulatory penalties. For example, the SEBI has mandated that fund houses disclose their portfolio and performance every six months and disclose fund performance monthly.
• Investor Protection: Regulatory bodies have guidelines in place to protect investors' interests. For instance, the SEBI requires new investors to undergo the Know Your Customer (KYC) process, which helps prevent money laundering. Non-compliance with investor protection regulations can leave investors vulnerable and expose the fund to legal consequences.
• Fee Structures: Mutual funds charge various fees, such as sales charges, front-end and back-end load charges, and management fees. Non-disclosure or misrepresentation of these fees can lead to investor dissatisfaction and regulatory penalties. For example, FINRA Rule 2341(d) prohibits firms from selling mutual funds if their sales charges are deemed excessive.
• Fund Diversification: To be considered a diversified fund, mutual funds must ensure that the majority of their financial assets are represented by specific types of holdings, such as cash, government securities, and holdings from diverse issuers. Non-compliance with diversification regulations can increase risk exposure and negatively impact fund performance.
• Compliance Programs: Mutual funds are expected to have comprehensive compliance programs in place. This includes appointing a Chief Compliance Officer (CCO), conducting regular risk assessments, developing written policies and procedures, and conducting annual reviews. Inadequate compliance programs can lead to regulatory scrutiny and an increased risk of non-compliance.
• IRS Qualifications: In the United States, mutual funds must pass qualifying tests set by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). These tests relate to diversification, income sources, and distribution of taxable income to shareholders. Non-compliance with IRS regulations can result in tax-related consequences for the fund and its investors.

To summarize, the risk of non-compliance in mutual funds is significant and can lead to legal, regulatory, and reputational issues. By adhering to regulatory requirements, disclosing information transparently, prioritizing investor protection, and implementing robust compliance programs, mutual funds can mitigate the risk of non-compliance and promote a secure investment environment for their investors.

Frequently asked questions