China Funds: Invest Or Avoid?

Investing in China has been a hot topic for years, with financial advisors touting the benefits of having exposure to the country's growing economy and massive consumer base. However, recent events, including regulatory crackdowns and unpredictable government intervention, have made investors wary of the risks associated with investing in Chinese companies. So, what are the pros and cons of investing in China, and is it still a good idea?

Pros and cons of investing in China

Pros

China has the world's fastest-growing economy and is the second-largest economy in the world. It has strong economic growth, with a predicted 4.5% rise in 2024, and a massive population of 1.35 billion people, which is 17.39% of the world's population. This has led to a huge middle class with increased consumerism, which is driving the economy. China's urbanization is also expected to continue until 2030, which will lead to further economic growth.

China's dividend yields also look attractive, with companies responding to shareholder pressure by offering higher dividends. The country also has large foreign exchange reserves and is a key buyer of gold.

Cons

The Chinese government's unpredictable intervention in the market is a huge concern for investors. The government has cracked down on private businesses and entrepreneurs, and its common prosperity agenda has investors worried about the future of the free market in China. The government's unpredictable nature makes investing in China a risky proposition.

China's demographics are also a large threat. The one-child policy, introduced in 1978, will soon cause a slowdown in the economy as fewer people will be contributing to the public purse through taxes, and an ageing population will spend less.

There are also concerns about the sustainability of China's economic growth, the country's mounting debt, and the lack of transparency and poor corporate governance in Chinese companies.

China's unpredictable government

China's government has been described as unpredictable and heavy-handed, with its decision-making and policies causing concern for investors. The country's leader, Xi Jinping, has been consolidating power and is now considered to have amassed more power than any leader since Mao Zedong. This has led to concerns about the stability and predictability of China's political system, with the future considered ""more unpredictable than usual".

Xi's government has been characterised by a crackdown on private businesses and entrepreneurs, a shift towards common prosperity and socialism, and increased censorship and control over the internet and the economy. These actions have triggered a fall in stock market valuations and caused alarm among foreign investors, who own over $800 billion in financial assets in China.

The unpredictability of the Chinese government was highlighted by its sudden and disruptive bans and restrictions in various sectors, including online tutoring, consumer internet companies, and energy. The government's focus on common prosperity and addressing inequality could also have significant implications for investors, particularly in the real estate sector.

The centralisation of power under Xi Jinping and the unpredictable nature of the Chinese government present risks for investors. The future under Xi is expected to be unpredictable, with potential economic slowdowns and growing frustration among citizens due to COVID-19 restrictions and the government's policies.

In summary, China's unpredictable government, led by Xi Jinping's consolidation of power, poses risks and challenges for investors. The government's heavy-handed policies and unpredictable decision-making have caused concern, and the future path under Xi remains uncertain, with potential economic and social implications.

The impact of COVID-19 on China's economy

The COVID-19 pandemic has had a significant impact on China's economy, with the country grappling with a range of challenges in the aftermath of the crisis. One of the key issues has been a protracted property crisis, with the country's real estate industry, which accounts for about a quarter of its GDP, facing difficulties. This has resulted in a decline in property prices and a decrease in new investment, acting as a drag on China's overall economic growth.

Another consequence of the pandemic has been a decrease in consumer spending and confidence. This has led to a drop in demand for goods and services, affecting various sectors, including the food delivery market, which experienced a boom during the lockdowns. The reduction in consumer spending has also impacted the performance of delivery workers, who are now facing longer working hours and lower earnings due to cheaper orders.

The pandemic has also contributed to a rise in unemployment, particularly among youth, with China's youth unemployment rate soaring to 18.8% in August 2024. This has led to increased competition for jobs, further exacerbating the challenges faced by workers in industries like food delivery.

China has also faced challenges in its relationship with the United States, which has resulted in a geopolitical battle between the two countries. This has had economic implications, with some investors expressing concerns about doing business in China due to government intervention and unpredictability.

However, despite these challenges, China's economy remains relatively strong, with a GDP growth of 4.6% to 4.9% in the third quarter of 2024. The country has also maintained solid exports and a stable currency. Beijing has implemented various stimulus measures to support economic growth, including large cuts to interest and mortgage rates, and the situation may improve as the effects of the pandemic continue to subside.

China's Belt and Road Initiative

The BRI is considered a centerpiece of Xi Jinping's foreign policy and is intended to enhance regional connectivity and embrace a brighter future. The project has a target completion date of 2049, which will coincide with the centennial of the People's Republic of China's founding.

The BRI has been praised for its potential to boost global GDP, particularly in developing countries. However, there have also been criticisms over human rights violations, environmental impact, and concerns of debt-trap diplomacy resulting in neocolonialism and economic imperialism.

The initiative has two main components: the Silk Road Economic Belt and the 21st Century Maritime Silk Road. The Silk Road Economic Belt refers to the proposed overland routes for road and rail transportation through landlocked Central Asia, while the 21st Century Maritime Silk Road refers to the Indo-Pacific sea routes through Southeast Asia to South Asia, the Middle East, and Africa.

The BRI has stoked opposition in some countries, particularly those that have experienced debt crises as a result of the initiative. There have also been concerns about the potential for China to gain geopolitical leverage over participating countries, as well as the opaque nature of the funding for the initiative.

Despite these criticisms, the BRI has the potential to accelerate economic growth and reduce trade costs. It remains to be seen whether the initiative will lead to the establishment of a new, Chinese-led world order, but it has already led to increased Chinese influence and investment in participating countries.

The risks of investing in Chinese stocks

There are several risks associated with investing in Chinese stocks that investors should be aware of before making any decisions.

Firstly, the Chinese government's crackdown on privately-owned companies and entrepreneurs has caused dismay among portfolio investors. Beijing's emphasis on the political slogan "common prosperity" to address inequality has led to increased intervention and unpredictability in the market. This has resulted in a precipitous fall in stock market valuations of tech, digital, and other companies, impacting foreign investors with financial assets in China.

Secondly, there are concerns about weak governance and unpredictability in China. The regulatory environment is subject to abrupt changes, as seen in the case of Ant Financial, an arm of Alibaba, which was abruptly cancelled, signalling a campaign to exert control over the private sector. The focus on "common prosperity" could also lead to financial punishment of high-income earners and those with "unreasonable" incomes, creating economic uncertainty.

Thirdly, the high volatility of the Chinese market is a significant risk factor. With 86% of trading volume conducted by retail investors, the market is highly volatile, with an average standard deviation of monthly returns of 11.5%. This makes it difficult for investors to predict and manage their investments effectively.

Additionally, corporate governance risks are heightened in China. These include a reliance on government subsidies, the risk of arbitrary government interference, large transactions or M&A activity with related companies, and a higher risk of accounting fraud. Active management and a focus on corporate governance are critical when investing in Chinese stocks to mitigate these risks.

Finally, there is a risk of delisting Chinese companies from U.S. exchanges, which could result in potential losses for U.S. fund managers with significant investments in Chinese stocks. The possibility of such a move by the U.S. government remains a concern for investors, exposing them to more volatility during periods when Chinese markets are closed for holidays.

In conclusion, while investing in Chinese stocks may offer potential opportunities, it is essential to carefully consider and mitigate the risks outlined above. The current regulatory environment, market volatility, corporate governance issues, and geopolitical tensions between the U.S. and China are critical factors that investors should closely monitor when making investment decisions.

Frequently asked questions