Mutual Funds Vs Real Estate: Where Should You Invest?

Deciding where to invest your money can be tricky, especially when it comes to mutual funds and real estate. Both have their pros and cons, and it's important to understand the differences between them before making any decisions. Mutual funds offer diversification, liquidity, and professional management, while real estate provides tangible assets and the potential for rental income. Mutual funds also tend to be less expensive to start investing in, whereas real estate often requires a large sum of money upfront. Another thing to consider is the level of risk – mutual funds are subject to market risk, liquidity risks and credit risks, while real estate investments are generally considered less volatile but come with their own set of risks, such as property damage and legal disputes.

Mutual funds offer better consistency and higher returns than real estate

Mutual funds have shown better consistency and provided inflation-beating returns over the last few years. Although they come with a risk, this can be contained by investing in moderate-risk funds such as debt funds or hybrid funds, which are involatile and offer steady returns. The power of compounding in mutual funds also helps generate higher returns when compared to real estate investments, which fail to perform during inflation.

The performance of real estate investments falls behind that of mutual fund investments. Real estate investments are considered similar to fixed deposits now, as the returns generated are comparable. Mutual funds, on the other hand, have proven to be a common option for investors who wish to accumulate wealth despite inflation.

The returns generated by investing in mutual funds are also comparatively higher than those of real estate investments. While the rate of returns on real estate can range from 7% p.a. to 11% p.a., mutual funds offer returns ranging between 14% p.a. and 19% p.a., depending on the type of fund. This allows investors to generate high returns that bear the effect of inflation and accumulate wealth.

In addition, mutual funds require small amounts to be invested, whereas real estate demands a large amount upfront. For most people, this makes mutual funds a more accessible investment option. With mutual funds, you can invest through a Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) by allocating a small portion from your bank account, which will be auto-debited monthly.

Both real estate and mutual funds investments give you tax exemptions. However, mutual funds are more advantageous in this regard, as they are also recognised as tax-saving investments. Under Section 80C of the Income Tax, 1961, you can be eligible for tax benefits of up to a maximum of Rs 1,50,000 on investments made towards mutual funds.

One of the main benefits investors expect from their investments is liquidity. Mutual fund investments are highly liquid. Their units can be redeemed at any time with the click of a few buttons, and the money will be deposited into your bank account within a few business days.

In contrast, it can take months to find a buyer for real estate, and you may fail to sell the property at a fair price. Moreover, even if you need a smaller amount of money than the price of the property, you will likely have to sell the entire property to get the funds.

Mutual funds are also advantageous in terms of ease of investment. Investing in mutual funds is a straightforward process that can be completed in just a few minutes. All you need to do is invest through a SIP, and the amount will be debited automatically from your bank account each month. There are also no additional expenses involved in these investments.

In summary, mutual funds offer better consistency and higher returns than real estate. They provide inflation-beating returns, higher investment liquidity, and greater ease of investment with lower financial barriers to entry.

Real estate investments are illiquid and require large amounts of capital

Real estate investments typically require a large amount of capital upfront. For example, buying a three-bedroom apartment in Noida, India, would cost at least 70 to 75 lakhs, and a similar property in Gurgaon would cost between 1 and 1.5 crores. Even if you opt for a home loan, you will still need to pay a 20% down payment from your own pocket, as well as registration fees. In contrast, mutual funds require a much smaller initial investment, with some Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs) starting from as little as Rs 100 or 500 per month.

Real estate investments are also illiquid assets, meaning it can take a long time to convert them into cash. It can take months to find a buyer for a property, and even then, you may have to settle for a lower price than you wanted. There are also various fees involved in selling a property, such as brokerage and other charges, which can eat into your profits. On the other hand, mutual fund investments are highly liquid and can be redeemed with just a few clicks, with the money deposited into your bank account within a few business days.

The illiquid nature of real estate investments means that they are not a good option if you need access to your money in a short space of time. If you are investing for the long term and are willing to wait for the right opportunity to sell, then real estate may be suitable. However, if you need your money quickly, for example, in a financial emergency, mutual funds are a better option.

The high capital requirements and illiquidity of real estate investments mean that they are generally only suitable for investors with large amounts of capital to invest. Mutual funds, on the other hand, are a more accessible option for those with limited capital who want to start investing with a small amount.

Mutual funds are highly liquid and can be started with a small amount of money

Liquidity is a key factor when deciding between investing in mutual funds or real estate. Mutual funds are highly liquid, allowing investors to redeem their units at any time and access their money within a few business days. This is especially beneficial if you need quick access to funds in an emergency. On the other hand, real estate investments are illiquid and it can take months or even years to find a buyer and finalise the sale.

Mutual funds offer the advantage of being able to start investing with a small amount of money. You can begin a Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) with as little as Rs. 100 per month, or $500, making it accessible to those with limited capital. Real estate, on the other hand, requires a large upfront investment and significant down payments. For example, purchasing a three-bedroom apartment in certain areas of India can cost upwards of Rs 70 lakh, with a 20% down payment needed.

The high liquidity of mutual funds also means that investors can easily adjust their investment amount. If your income increases, you can choose to invest more each month. Conversely, if your financial situation changes, you can decrease your contributions without incurring penalties. Real estate, on the other hand, typically does not offer this flexibility.

Mutual funds are also more accessible to investors due to their low initial investment requirements. With mutual funds, investors can choose from a wide range of schemes that suit their risk profile and investment objectives. Real estate, on the other hand, offers limited options, as your budget and location will dictate the type of property you can afford.

In summary, mutual funds offer high liquidity, flexibility, and accessibility, making them a good option for investors who want to start investing with a small amount of money and have the ability to adjust their contributions over time.

Real estate investments are physical assets that require regular monitoring

The security of real estate investments is a key consideration. Instances of land grabbing and illegal encroachments have been reported, so investors must weigh the factor of regular monitoring to protect their assets. Despite the potential for more maintenance, real estate can be a good long-term investment.

In addition, real estate investments may be influenced by various factors such as location, demand and supply, infrastructure development, and economic conditions. For example, real estate in an area with rising property values due to new developments may be a good investment. On the other hand, increased traffic and poor access to the city in a previously undeveloped area could reduce the value of your property over time.

Compared to other types of investments, such as mutual funds, real estate may offer a more stable and consistent return. While the performance of mutual funds can be monitored online, real estate investments may require more physical oversight.

Overall, real estate investments can be a good option for those seeking a tangible asset, regular income through rent, and potential property appreciation. However, investors should be prepared to monitor and maintain their physical assets regularly.

Mutual funds are regulated by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI)

In India, the SEBI MF Regulations of 1996 govern the working of mutual funds. These guidelines treat mutual funds like Public Trusts that fall under the Indian Trust Act of 1982. For handling mutual funds and ensuring accountability on the trustees, the guidelines specify a three-tier set up comprising of the fund managers, the investors, and the representatives.

The structure of mutual funds as per SEBI guidelines:

• Guarantor: One who generates revenues by putting together a mutual fund and handing it to the fund manager.
• Sponsor: Sets up the mutual funds as per the guidelines of the Indian Trust Act, 1882, for Public Trust. They are responsible for listing with the SEBI, having provisions for resource management, and ensuring the functioning of the fund.
• Trustee or Trust: Established through a trust deed that is implemented by the sponsors of the funds and is accountable to all the investors of the mutual fund. The trustee company is regulated by the Indian Companies Act 1956, while the firm and the board members are overseen by the Indian Trust Act 1882.
• Asset Management Company: The investment management of the trust is done through an Asset Management Company, which is to be listed as per the regulations of Companies Act of 1956.

SEBI has categorised mutual funds into five groups – Equity, Debt, Hybrid, Solution-Oriented, and Others – to facilitate standardisation and bring about uniformity in similar schemes. This categorisation helps investors evaluate their risk options and make informed decisions.

SEBI guidelines regulate Indian mutual funds, treating them as Public Trusts under the 1996 MF Regulations. They oversee fund managers, investors, and representatives. SEBI categorizes funds into equity, debt, hybrid, solution-oriented, and other schemes for clarity.

Frequently asked questions