Rent Or Invest: The Great Property Dilemma

Paying off a rental property mortgage is a complicated question and the answer depends on a number of factors. For example, your reasons for investing in real estate, your long-term goals, and your current financial situation.

On the one hand, paying off a rental property mortgage can increase your cash flow and equity. It can also be a good idea if you're approaching retirement and want to reduce your risk. On the other hand, keeping the mortgage can offer tax benefits and allow you to take advantage of its numerous tax write-offs, such as depreciation and mortgage interest. Additionally, if you use cash to pay off the mortgage, you may lose leverage and have less opportunity to invest in other properties.

There are no definitive right or wrong answers, and the decision depends on your unique circumstances and financial goals.

The pros of paying off rental property

Paying off a rental property mortgage can have several advantages. Here are some of the pros of paying off a rental property:

• Increased cash flow and reduced costs: One of the most significant benefits of paying off a rental property mortgage is the increase in monthly cash flow. Without mortgage payments, you can retain a larger portion of the rental income, leading to higher profits. This increased cash flow can also provide peace of mind and reduce financial burdens.
• Debt elimination: Paying off the mortgage eliminates debt associated with the rental property, reducing risk and worry. This can be especially beneficial for individuals approaching retirement, as it provides a more stable financial situation.
• Equity and ownership: Paying off the mortgage leads to 100% equity in the rental property, providing full ownership. This can be advantageous if you ever decide to sell the property, as it will result in a higher cash return.
• Reduced risk of eviction: Without a mortgage, there is less risk associated with evicting tenants. If a tenant stops paying rent, you won't have to worry about covering the mortgage payments yourself.
• Protection of equity: In most states, the equity in a rental property is protected from bankruptcy and creditor claims. Paying off the mortgage can provide an added layer of security for your investment.
• Retirement planning: Paying off the rental property mortgage can make retirement planning easier. It reduces ongoing expenses and provides a stable source of income for your retirement years.
• Hiring a property manager: With the extra cash flow from paying off the mortgage, you may be able to hire a property manager to take care of the property for you, especially if you have multiple rental properties. This can free up your time and reduce the workload associated with managing the property yourself.
• Increased flexibility: Paying off the mortgage can provide more flexibility in finding and retaining good tenants. You won't be as dependent on rental income to cover mortgage payments, so you can be more selective in choosing tenants and can afford to keep rental rates lower if needed.
• Preparation for financial storms: Paying off the mortgage reduces your liabilities, making it easier to handle disruptions in rental returns or other financial challenges.

While there are several benefits to paying off a rental property mortgage, it's important to consider your unique financial situation and goals before making a decision. There may be other investment opportunities or strategies that align better with your objectives.

The cons of paying off rental property

There are several drawbacks to consider before paying off a rental property loan. Here are some key disadvantages:

• Loss of liquidity: Paying off a rental property loan can result in fewer liquid assets, making it challenging to access cash in the event of an emergency or investment opportunity. It may take time to pull money back out of the property through a sale or refinance, leading to unnecessary stress and limited financial flexibility.
• Lower cash-on-cash returns: Not having leverage on a rental property can lead to lower cash-on-cash returns. This means that the return on your investment, calculated as the annual before-tax cash flow divided by the total cash invested, may decrease.
• Loss of tax write-offs: Mortgage interest on a rental property loan is often tax-deductible, and this benefit would be lost upon paying off the loan. This is especially relevant for investors in upper-income brackets, as the tax benefit of writing off interest expenses can be significant.
• Reduced diversification: Paying off the rental property loan can result in a less diversified investment portfolio. By using cash to pay off the mortgage, investors effectively increase their exposure to the real estate market, which may negatively impact their net worth if property values decline.
• Higher borrowing costs in the future: Refinancing the property in the future, such as taking out a new mortgage, could be more costly if interest rates rise. There is a risk that interest rates may increase, leading to higher borrowing costs compared to the current favourable rates.
• Limited leverage and velocity: Paying off the rental property mortgage reduces the ability to generate money from property equity. Refinancing and taking equity out of the property allows for rapid diversification and leveraging of investments, which are crucial for creating wealth.
• Inflation's impact on debt: Inflation erodes the value of debt over time, and by paying off the mortgage early, investors lose the benefit of inflation reducing the real value of their debt.
• Increased taxes: Paying off the rental property mortgage may result in higher taxes on rental income. Without the ability to deduct mortgage interest, investors may need to pay more taxes, depending on their specific tax bracket and circumstances.

The pros of investing in another property

Investing in another property can be a great way to build wealth and generate passive income. Here are some of the pros of investing in another property:

Stable and recurring income

One of the most significant advantages of investing in real estate is the potential for a stable and recurring income stream through rental payments. Renting out a property can provide a consistent cash flow that covers expenses, such as the mortgage, insurance, property taxes, and repairs, with some money left over as passive income. Over time, as the mortgage is paid off, this positive cash flow increases, and it can eventually become a primary source of income.

Long-term capital appreciation

Property values tend to appreciate over time, leading to long-term capital gains. This can result in significant profits when it's time to sell. Real estate values often increase faster than the rate of inflation, and investors tend to view real estate as a hedge against inflation, driving up prices during inflationary periods.

Tax benefits

Real estate investors can take advantage of numerous tax breaks and deductions. Many expenses associated with owning and operating a rental property, such as property management fees, maintenance, repairs, property taxes, insurance, mortgage interest, and depreciation, can be deducted from taxable income. Additionally, capital gains taxes on property sales can be deferred if the proceeds are reinvested into another property through a 1031 exchange.

Diversification

Real estate is an excellent way to diversify an investment portfolio beyond traditional stocks and bonds. It often has a low correlation with other asset classes, helping to reduce portfolio volatility and enhance overall stability.

Control and leverage

Investing in real estate allows for a more hands-on and controllable approach compared to other investments. Investors can actively search for deals, control costs, choose tenants, and decide when to sell. Real estate also provides leverage, as it can be purchased with a substantial mortgage, magnifying the returns on the down payment.

These pros make investing in another property an attractive option for those looking to build wealth and generate stable, passive income. However, it's important to remember that real estate investment also comes with its own set of challenges and risks, including high initial costs, property management responsibilities, and market volatility.

The cons of investing in another property

Investing in another property can be a great way to build wealth, but it's not without its drawbacks. Here are some cons to consider before investing in another property:

Lack of Liquidity

Property is not a liquid asset, meaning it can take a long time to sell. If you need to access your money quickly, property may not be the best investment option as it could take weeks or even months to sell. This lack of liquidity can put you at a disadvantage compared to more liquid investments like stocks or bonds.

High Entry Cost

Investing in property typically requires a significant amount of upfront capital. In addition to the down payment, there are also closing costs, property inspections, and potential renovation expenses to consider. Property prices are constantly on the rise, making it harder for new investors to enter the market.

Time-Intensive

Investing in property is a time-consuming process. It requires a significant amount of time to research the market, identify suitable properties, and deal with maintenance issues. Even if you hire a property manager, you will still need to spend time overseeing the investment and dealing with any issues that arise.

Market Volatility

While the property market is generally less volatile than the stock market, it is still subject to market fluctuations. Economic downturns can lead to decreased property values and increased vacancies, impacting your rental income and overall return on investment.

Risk of Bad Tenants

Finding and retaining reliable tenants can be challenging. Bad tenants can cause emotional and financial stress, with potential damage to your property and missed rent payments. Dealing with evictions and property damage can be a costly and time-consuming process.

Ongoing and Additional Costs

Property carries ongoing costs such as insurance, council rates, mortgage repayments, maintenance, and renovations. These costs can be unpredictable and may put a strain on your cash flow, especially if you experience vacancies or rising interest rates.

How to minimise the risk of investing in another property

Investing in property comes with a certain degree of risk, but there are ways to minimise this risk and still reap the rewards. Here are some strategies to help you minimise the risk when investing in another property:

Diversify Your Portfolio

Diversification is a key risk-management strategy. This means investing in a variety of assets, such as shares, bonds, savings accounts, and both residential and commercial property. By spreading your investments across different asset classes, you reduce the impact of any single investment. For example, consider investing in different types of properties (apartments, townhouses, units) in various locations, catering to different demographics, and with some budget variance.

Do Your Research

Conduct thorough research before investing. Understand the real estate market in multiple cities, not just your own. Look for cities with rising incomes and populations, but where property prices are not too high relative to incomes. Also, research the micro-market, considering factors like transportation access, socio-cultural infrastructure (schools, shopping, hospitals), and whether the area is well-established or up-and-coming.

Understand Your Risk Appetite

Your risk tolerance depends on factors like your age and financial goals. If you're younger, you may be more comfortable with risk and can invest more in high-risk, high-return assets like equity. As you get closer to retirement, shift your focus to fixed-income assets, which are considered less risky.

Take a Long-Term Approach

Patience is key in investing. Avoid making impulsive decisions during market volatility. Remember that investments have the potential to recover and grow over time. A long-term investment strategy helps you ride out short-term fluctuations.

Regularly Review Your Portfolio

Keep a close eye on your investments. Review your portfolio at least annually to ensure it aligns with your goals and risk tolerance. This will help you identify any necessary adjustments and avoid unnecessary risks.

Buy Stable and Sound Properties

Conduct proper building and pest inspections before purchasing a property to identify any issues. Regular maintenance and fixing minor problems are crucial to maintaining the integrity of the structure.

Get Adequate Insurance

Buy building insurance as soon as you sign the contract to ensure you're covered. Consult a qualified insurance broker to get the best insurance cover for your needs. Additionally, consider landlord insurance to protect against malicious activity or rent loss.

Manage Cash Flow Risk

Cash flow risk is a significant concern in property investing. Forecast your income and expenses, allowing for contingencies. Build a substantial property portfolio to support your financial requirements. Consult a property strategist to help you manage your cash flow effectively.

Be Aware of Interest Rate Risk

An increase in interest rates can adversely affect variable-rate mortgages, straining your cash flow. To minimise this risk, opt for fixed-rate mortgages, and shop around for the best interest rates. Negotiate with your lender, and take advantage of promotional rates offered by different lenders.

Mitigate Vacancy Risk

Vacancies are a natural part of property management, but extended vacancies can be problematic if you rely on rental income to cover expenses. To minimise this risk, invest in areas with amenities like schools, hospitals, malls, and parks, and ensure easy access to public transportation. Keep tenants happy by responding to reasonable requests, especially regarding improvements.

Select a Good Property Manager

Choose an experienced and proactive property manager who understands the local market. They should have stringent tenant selection standards to reduce the risk of bad tenants, who can cause damage, fail to pay rent, or create other issues.

Understand Your Financial Time Horizon

Real estate is a long-term, illiquid investment. Ensure you have the financial capacity to hold the property for the long term, considering factors like project completion and exit timelines.

By following these strategies, you can minimise the risk of investing in another property and improve your chances of a successful and rewarding investment journey.

Frequently asked questions