Clo Equity: Who's Investing And Why?

Collateralized loan obligations (CLOs) are actively managed investment products that consist of a diverse pool of leveraged loans that generate cash flow as they are repaid. CLO equity has emerged as a source of potentially robust returns for sophisticated investors. While CLO equity investors face the risk of absorbing losses if any of the underlying loans default, they are also positioned to capture the upside when a transaction outperforms. CLO equity typically provides double-digit annual distributions and has a history of withstanding market shocks, making it an attractive investment option for those seeking access to a diversified portfolio of leveraged loans.

CLO equity investors are first to absorb losses if underlying loans default

Collateralized Loan Obligations (CLOs) are complex investment vehicles that pool together a large number of leveraged loans made to non-investment-grade corporate borrowers. CLOs are divided into tranches, or slices, of risk. The equity tranche is the riskiest portion of the CLO structure and, therefore, the first to absorb losses if any of the underlying loans default.

The equity tranche is the last to receive cash flows from the leveraged loan pool. However, if all the loans continue to pay their principal and interest, the equity tranche will have the highest returns in the CLO structure.

Equity tranche investors have a degree of control over the CLO that is not available to debt investors. For example, they have the option to refinance the underlying CLO loans or reset the reinvestment period.

The high interest rate environment has dampened some enthusiasm for CLOs. However, CLO equity returns often unfold in unexpected ways. For example, CLO managers can respond to changing market and economic conditions to generate persistent equity distributions.

In summary, while CLO equity investors are first to absorb losses if underlying loans default, they are also positioned to capture the upside when a transaction outperforms.

CLO equity investors are positioned to capture the upside when a transaction outperforms

Collateralized Loan Obligations (CLOs) are actively managed investment products that consist of a diverse pool of leveraged loans that generate cash flow as they are repaid. CLO equity investors are those who invest in the equity tranche of a CLO.

The equity tranche is the riskiest portion of a CLO, as it is the first to experience losses if any underlying loans default. However, it also offers the potential for the highest returns. CLO equity investors are positioned at the bottom of the "payment waterfall", meaning they are the last to receive cash flows from the leveraged loan pool. However, if all the loans continue to pay their principal and interest, the equity tranche will have the highest returns in the CLO structure.

Because of their position in the CLO structure, CLO equity investors are well-positioned to capture the upside when a transaction outperforms. They benefit from the difference between what a CLO earns in loan interest and what it owes to CLO debtholders. This makes CLO equity a hybrid investment, combining the potential double-digit returns of private equity with the front-loaded cash flow of bonds.

The performance of CLO equity investments can be further enhanced by active management. CLO managers can buy and sell individual bank loans within the collateral pool to maximize gains and minimize losses. They can also take advantage of reinvestment periods to upgrade their loan portfolios and increase returns.

Additionally, CLO equity investors have a degree of control over the CLO that is not available to debt investors. They have the option to refinance the underlying CLO loans or reset the reinvestment period. This flexibility allows CLO equity investors to further optimize their returns and capture the upside when transactions outperform.

In summary, CLO equity investors are positioned to capture the upside when a transaction outperforms due to their claim on profits, the potential for high returns associated with the equity tranche, active management by CLO managers, and the flexibility to make strategic decisions.

CLO equity returns can exceed expectations

Collateralized loan obligations (CLOs) are actively managed investment products that consist of a diverse pool of leveraged loans that generate cash flow as they are repaid. CLO equity has emerged as a source of potentially robust and front-loaded returns for sophisticated investors.

While the high-interest-rate environment has dampened some enthusiasm for the asset class, CLO equity returns often unfold in ways that may defy investors' expectations. This is partly because of the lifespan of the average CLO investment, which is typically a minimum of five years and can extend beyond that. In addition, CLO managers have a robust toolkit for adapting their returns to broad changes in the market and economic environment.

Recent examples demonstrate how CLO equity returns may exceed expectations. For instance, despite the second half of 2022 being widely regarded as an unattractive time to issue a CLO due to accelerated rate hikes, loan price drops, soaring CLO debt costs, and decreased CLO issuance volumes, many CLO managers who issued CLOs during that time were able to generate very attractive returns for their equity investors.

The key to CLO equity's potential for exceeding expectations lies in its inherent optionality. CLOs provide considerable flexibility through their structural features and the potential for trading decisions within the portfolio. This enables managers to respond to changing market and economic conditions, potentially generating persistent equity distributions.

Furthermore, CLO equity investors benefit from structural advantages. Unlike some alternative strategies, CLOs typically issue callable debt with a longer duration, reducing the volatility associated with rising short-term rates. The stability of the relationship between assets and liabilities results in more stable equity returns for long-term investors.

In summary, CLO equity has the potential to deliver returns that surpass expectations due to its long-term nature, the optionality it offers to managers, and the structural advantages that benefit investors.

CLO equity can be an attractive option for investors

Collateralized loan obligations (CLOs) are actively managed investment products that consist of a diverse pool of leveraged loans that generate cash flow as they are repaid. CLO equity can be an attractive option for investors for several reasons:

Attractive Returns

CLO equity has historically generated high cash-on-cash returns, with an average annual CLO equity distribution of around 16%. All CLO vintages have achieved a positive return, with an average return of about 13% for realized deals.

Strong Underlying Collateral

CLOs consist of diversified portfolios of broadly syndicated, liquid, senior secured corporate loans. Each CLO typically holds over 200 distinct loans across various industries. These loans are senior to bonds and equity and have first priority over the underlying collateral pledged by the borrower, resulting in a high recovery rate.

Large Asset Class

The CLO market, particularly in the US, is substantial, with a size of over $1 trillion and continues to grow. CLOs account for more than 60% of the US leveraged loan market, and their growth is driven by investors seeking exposure to actively managed portfolios of first-lien loans and the performance of CLO securities over time.

Attractive Financing Structures

CLOs offer long-term financing, typically with a duration of 13 years. They are not subject to covenants that require margin calls or forced liquidations triggered by decreases in collateral value. The financing is locked in for an extended period, allowing CLOs to benefit from volatility by purchasing loans at discounted prices or higher spreads to increase returns.

Benefit from Volatility

CLOs are actively managed vehicles with five-year reinvestment periods, allowing for ongoing portfolio optimization. They can take advantage of market volatility by purchasing loans at attractive prices, as seen during the Federal Reserve's rate hikes in the second half of 2022.

Structural Advantages

CLO equity investors benefit from structural advantages, such as issuing callable debt with longer maturities than short-term financing markets. This reduces the volatility associated with rising short-term rates and provides a more stable relationship between assets and liabilities, leading to more stable equity returns.

Optionality

CLO managers have a robust toolkit to adjust their returns according to broad changes in the market and economic conditions. They can make trading decisions within the portfolio and take advantage of optionality through structural changes, such as refinancing or resetting the CLO.

Low Correlation with Other Asset Classes

CLO equity cash flows exhibit low correlation with other risk assets, including high-yield bonds. This diversification benefit enhances the overall risk-adjusted returns of an investment portfolio.

Direct Benefits from Active Management of Credit Risk

The ability of CLO managers to actively manage credit risk and navigate different market conditions is a key driver of CLO equity performance. Experienced managers can leverage their expertise to optimize returns by reacting to and capitalizing on factors like movement in loan and CLO debt credit spreads, credit losses, net trading activities, and changes in interest rates.

CLO equity has historically generated high cash-on-cash returns

Collateralized loan obligations (CLOs) are actively managed investment products that consist of a diverse pool of leveraged loans that generate cash flow as they are repaid. CLOs are often corporate loans with low credit ratings or loans taken out by private equity firms to conduct leveraged buyouts.

The CLO equity tranche has historically generated high cash-on-cash returns, with an average annual distribution of around 16%. All CLO vintages have achieved a positive return, with an average of about 13% for realized deals. CLO equity has the potential for double-digit returns, combining the prospective double-digit returns of private equity with a quarterly distributed cash flow more akin to bonds.

The high returns of CLO equity can be attributed to its position in the CLO structure. The equity tranche is the riskiest portion of the CLO, as it is the first to absorb losses if any underlying loans default. However, it also has the highest returns if all the loans continue to pay their principal and interest. The equity tranche captures the net spread and residual principal value generated by active management.

Additionally, CLO managers have the flexibility to respond to changing market and economic conditions, which can lead to persistent equity distributions. They can buy and sell individual bank loans within the collateral pool to maximize gains and minimize losses. CLOs also benefit from volatility as they can purchase loans at discounted prices or higher spreads to increase returns.

Furthermore, CLO equity investments have a short expected weighted average life (WAL) compared to other asset classes with similar return profiles. They provide quarterly cash distributions and have a low correlation with fixed-income and equity over the long term.

Frequently asked questions