Understanding California's Carryover Limitation On Investment Interest

Pease, which reduces certain itemized deductions, is no longer in effect federally, but it still applies in California. This means that in California, investment interest expense can be limited. This is because California's Itemized Deductions Worksheet subtracts out the federal investment interest deduction figure, not the state figure. However, there is some debate over whether this is correct, as California law does not provide any further instruction beyond stating that federal law applies.

Pease limits investment interest in California

The Pease reduction can be avoided by ensuring that the same amount is deducted at the federal and state levels, and letting the rest carry over instead of taking the larger state deduction right away. This may be a better option than taking the larger state deduction right away, as the benefit of avoiding the Pease reduction may outweigh the cost of delaying the California deduction to a future year.

California law states that the federal law applies, with no further instruction. This means that Section 68 of the Internal Revenue Code, relating to the overall limitation on itemized deductions, shall apply.

Federal law vs state law

California law states that federal law applies when it comes to carryover limitations on investment interest. However, there is some complexity due to the Pease provision, which reduces certain itemized deductions and is no longer in effect federally, but still applies in California. This can result in a reduction in investment interest expense, even though federal law expressly excludes this deduction from its reach.

California's Itemized Deductions Worksheet subtracts the federal investment interest deduction figure, not the state figure, which can lead to discrepancies. For example, a client's deduction may be limited at the federal level by the amount of their investment income, while such a limitation would not apply at the state level because California treats all income equally.

To optimise their tax strategy, individuals in California may consider ensuring they deduct the same amount at the federal and state levels and carry over the rest, rather than taking a larger state deduction right away. This approach could provide benefits that outweigh the cost of delaying the California deduction to a future year.

Overall, while California defers to federal law on carryover limitations for investment interest, the application of the Pease provision and differences in how federal and state figures are treated can create complexities that taxpayers should carefully navigate.

California's Itemized Deductions Worksheet

One of the key considerations in completing California's Itemized Deductions Worksheet is the treatment of investment interest expense. In California, Pease, which reduces certain itemized deductions, still applies. This includes a reduction in investment interest expense, even though federal law expressly excludes this deduction from its reach. The discrepancy arises because California's worksheet subtracts out the federal investment interest deduction figure, not the state figure. As a result, taxpayers may find that their deduction is limited at the federal level by the amount of their investment income, while no such limitation exists at the state level.

To optimise their tax position, taxpayers in California may consider aligning their federal and state deductions. This can be achieved by carrying over deductions to future years instead of taking larger state deductions right away. By doing so, taxpayers may be able to avoid the Pease reduction, which could outweigh the cost of delaying the California deduction.

It is important to note that California law generally defers to federal law on tax matters, with limited additional instructions. As such, taxpayers should carefully review the applicable laws and regulations, as well as consult with tax professionals, to ensure accurate completion of California's Itemized Deductions Worksheet and maximise their tax benefits.

Avoiding the Pease reduction

Pease, which reduces certain itemized deductions, is no longer in effect federally, but it still applies in California. This can reduce investment interest expense, even though the law expressly excludes that deduction from its reach. This is possible because California's Itemized Deductions Worksheet subtracts out the federal investment interest deduction figure, not the state figure.

You might be better off ensuring you deduct the same amount at the federal and state levels and letting the rest carry over instead of taking the larger state deduction right away. The benefit of avoiding the Pease reduction may outweigh the cost of delaying the California deduction to a future year.

One way to ensure the federal and state numbers align would be to make sure you only pay the portion of the accrued interest that you want to deduct for that year, as you may not be able to voluntarily deduct less than paid at the California level.

Deducting at the federal and state level

Pease, which reduces certain itemized deductions, is no longer in effect federally, but it still applies in California. This can reduce investment interest expense, even though the law expressly excludes that deduction from its reach. This is possible because California's Itemized Deductions Worksheet subtracts out the federal investment interest deduction figure, not the state figure.

California law basically says that the federal law applies, with no further instruction. However, there may be wiggle room on the interpretation.

To avoid the Pease reduction, you might be better off ensuring you deduct the same amount at the federal and state levels and letting the rest carry over instead of taking the larger state deduction right away. The benefit of avoiding the Pease reduction may outweigh the cost of delaying the California deduction to a future year.

The only way to ensure the federal and state numbers align would be to make sure you only pay the portion of the accrued interest that you want to deduct for that year.

Frequently asked questions