Understanding Zero Cash Flow Investment Strategies In 1031 Exchanges

Zero cash flow properties, also known as Zero Coupon DST Offerings or simply Zeros, are highly leveraged assets with long-term financing that produce no cash flow to the owner. In a 1031 exchange, investors can defer capital gains taxes by reinvesting the proceeds from the sale of an investment property into a like-kind property. Zero cash flow properties are often used in 1031 exchanges as they can help investors satisfy high debt replacement requirements while also achieving equity growth. These properties are typically triple-net leased commercial real estate assets with tenants that have strong balance sheets and investment-grade credit ratings. While they offer no cash flow to the investor, zeros can be attractive to those with little or no equity who are seeking to replace a significant amount of debt with minimal equity investment.

Zero cash flow properties explained

Zero cash flow properties, also known as Zero Coupon DST Offerings or "Zeros", are highly-leveraged assets with long-term financing that produce no cash flow to the owner. Instead, all net operating income (NOI) is received by the lender in the form of principal or interest payments.

Zeros are typically long-term, triple-net leased commercial real estate assets with tenants that have stellar credit ratings. They are highly leveraged, with a loan-to-value ratio (LTV) of 80-90%, and require minimal equity for acquisition. This means that investors can buy a much larger amount of real estate with a small amount of equity. For example, a $100,000 equity investment in a zero-coupon offering at a 90% LTV could result in the purchase of $1,000,000 of total real estate.

Who Buys Zero Cash Flow Properties?

Zero cash flow properties are particularly attractive to investors with a 1031 exchange need, especially those with little or no equity who are seeking to replace a significant amount of debt with minimal equity. They can also be appealing to cash investors who want to own commercial property without a significant starting investment, as well as those looking for potential tax benefits.

Benefits and Drawbacks

One of the main benefits of zero cash flow properties is that they can help investors satisfy high debt replacement requirements, such as those that may arise in a 1031 exchange transaction. They also offer the potential for equity growth and capital preservation through ongoing principal paydown. Additionally, zeros can provide above-market returns when calculated over extended periods.

However, a potential drawback is that they offer no cash flow to investors. The asset may be producing cash flow in the form of rent from the tenant, but once the mortgage principal, interest, and taxes are paid each month, there is no cash flow to distribute to investors due to the high leverage associated with the offering.

Example of a Zero Cash Flow Transaction

An investor with a traditional investment property worth $20 million wants to exchange it for a zero cash flow property. The original property has a debt obligation of $5 million and $15 million of equity. The investor identifies a zero cash flow property they can purchase for $20 million, with $2 million as equity and assuming $18 million of debt. The investor applies the full $15 million in cash to purchase the zero cash flow replacement property, meeting the equity obligations of the 1031 exchange. The debt obligation is also covered as the assumed debt is higher than the original debt. After closing, the investor notifies the lender of their intent to exercise the paydown readvance feature in the loan documents. The investor then closes on the sale of the zero cash flow property, and their 1031 exchange is complete. The next day, the investor engages the lender and provides notice of their intent to exercise the paydown readvance option. Of the $15 million in equity, $13 million is available as excess, which the lender readvances, resulting in $13 million of nontaxable proceeds from the transaction.

Who buys zero cash flow properties?

Zero cash flow properties are typically bought by investors with a 1031 exchange need. These are investors with little or no equity who want to replace a significant amount of debt with minimal equity.

A 1031 exchange buyer with a larger amount of equity may also be interested in a zero cash flow property to take advantage of the paydown readvance feature. This allows them to resize the debt and equity requirements of the trade and extract a significant amount of tax-free equity once the 1031 exchange is completed.

Non-exchange buyers may also be interested in zero cash flow properties if they are looking to produce net tax losses to offset income elsewhere in their portfolio.

How are zero cash flow properties priced?

Zero cash flow properties are priced based on the equity investment over the existing debt, expressed as a percentage of equity over the debt. This is because the high-leverage structure of zero cash flow properties results in no cash flow, so the typical method of pricing net lease investments using a cap rate is ignored.

Pricing of zero cash flow properties will vary due to factors including the loan structure (fully amortizing vs. balloon), maturity of the loan/lease, perceived residual value, and availability of paydown readvance, among others. While many other structures are declining in value, zeros remain near their all-time high pricing at a range of 12 to 24 percent equity over the debt.

Zero cash flow properties are often leveraged between 80 and 90 percent, and are structured so that all net operating income flows to the lender as part of the principal and interest payment. The high level of debt assumption is a potential drawback of zero cash flow properties, as it means that the majority of the monthly rental income from the tenant goes towards mortgage payments and interest. This is why they are called "zero cash flow".

Zero cash flow properties are also known as Zero Coupon DST Offerings or simply “Zeros”. They are typically long-term, triple-net leased commercial real estate properties, such as industrial centers, corporate office headquarters, and necessity-based retail power centers. These properties are usually backed by tenants with stellar credit ratings.

Zero cash flow properties can be used as an investment strategy, particularly in the form of a Delaware Statutory Trust (DST). They can provide investors with an opportunity to achieve equity growth and capital preservation through ongoing principal paydown. This is done as part of satisfying high debt replacement requirements.

What is the paydown readvance feature?

The paydown readvance feature is a loan structure that allows borrowers to pay down their loan balance and then re-borrow the same amount. This feature is particularly useful in 1031 exchanges, where investors can defer capital gains, access a large portion of their principal, and benefit from leverage and tax advantages.

The paydown readvance option is especially attractive to 1031 exchange buyers with a large amount of equity who want to take advantage of the tax-free equity extraction. This feature allows buyers to right-size the debt and equity requirements of the trade.

Here's how it works: the paydown option enables buyers to purchase real estate that meets the equity conditions of a 1031 exchange. After acquiring these assets, buyers can use the readvance option to extract available equity. The paydown readvance is a revolving credit feature within the existing loan, and it provides financial flexibility without the need for additional loans or services.

The steps involved in a paydown readvance process include determining the equity in your property, contacting a lender, providing necessary paperwork, signing the loan agreement, and making regular payments according to the loan terms.

While the paydown readvance feature offers benefits, it's important to understand the associated risks. Borrowers may end up paying more in interest over the life of the loan, and they may need to take out additional loans if the project or purchase doesn't generate enough income to cover the payments.

Tax benefits of zero cash flow investments

Zero cash flow investments are a subset of commercial real estate (CRE) that can be beneficial for certain investors. While they may not be suitable for everyone, they offer several advantages, including tax benefits. Here are some key points to understand about the tax advantages of zero cash flow investments:

Depreciation and Tax Liability

One of the main tax benefits of zero cash flow investments is the ability to offset income through depreciation. As the physical asset naturally depreciates over time due to wear and tear, investors can "expense" a portion of the property's value each year to account for this deterioration. This depreciation is a non-cash expense that appears on the property's income statement. As a result, the taxable income of the investment turns negative, and this loss can be used to reduce the investor's overall tax liability. This benefit is particularly valuable for high-income earners as it helps lower their tax bill.

Tax-Free Equity

Zero cash flow investments, especially in the form of Delaware Statutory Trusts (DSTs), offer the opportunity to pull out tax-free equity. Through the paydown/readvance feature, investors can pay down the loan balance during the term of the loan and then refinance it back to the original balance and terms. This allows them to access built-up equity tax-free. This strategy is particularly useful in the context of 1031 exchanges, where investors can meet debt and equity requirements while also pulling out tax-free proceeds.

Interest Deductions and Phantom Income

Zero cash flow properties often involve high-interest loans, and the interest payments on these loans can be used as deductions to offset income. Additionally, investors can take advantage of depreciation and interest deductions to minimize "phantom income." Phantom income refers to taxable income generated by the property, even though it is not actually received by the investor. Proper tax planning is crucial to utilizing these deductions effectively.

Tax Deferral in 1031 Exchanges

Zero cash flow investments are often considered in the context of 1031 exchanges, where investors seek to defer capital gains taxes and depreciation recapture. By directing the proceeds from the sale of one property into the purchase of another, investors can achieve tax deferral. Zero cash flow properties can be attractive in these exchanges as they can satisfy the high debt replacement requirements and help investors avoid immediate tax liabilities.

Long-Term Tax Benefits

While zero cash flow properties may not generate positive cash flow in the short term, they can provide substantial returns in the long run. These properties are typically located in well-established or high-growth areas, increasing the likelihood of appreciation over time. Additionally, leases are often entered into with strong credit tenants, enhancing the potential for long-term gains.

In conclusion, zero cash flow investments offer several tax benefits, including depreciation, tax-free equity, interest deductions, and tax deferral in 1031 exchanges. However, it is important to carefully consider the risks and consult with tax professionals before making any investment decisions.

Frequently asked questions