Young Investors: Why The Hesitation?

Young people are not investing for a variety of reasons. Firstly, many have seen their parents' or their own investments collapse due to the 2008 market crash and other financial crises, making them wary of investing in stocks. Others feel they do not have enough money to invest, with student debt, rising housing costs and a lack of well-paying jobs making it difficult to put money aside each month. In addition, some young people lack financial knowledge and feel that investing is confusing, especially with the abundance of financial scandals in the news. Finally, there is a sense that the stock market is not appealing to young people, who would rather hold onto their cash or spend it on more immediate needs and enjoyable experiences.

Student debt and rising costs of living

Student debt and the rising cost of living are significant factors in young people's decisions not to invest. In the US, student loan debt has grown enormously in recent years and is now one of the largest forms of consumer borrowing. As of September 2023, 43 million borrowers collectively owed over $1.6 trillion in federal student loans, with the average graduate owing around $30,000. When combined with private loans, the total exceeds $1.7 trillion, surpassing auto loans and credit card debt.

The burden of student debt is causing young people to delay major life milestones, such as marriage, starting a family, and purchasing a home. It is also influencing their career choices, with many opting for higher-paying jobs in tech and finance instead of lower-paying but socially critical professions like early childhood education.

The rising cost of college tuition is a significant contributor to the student debt crisis. College tuition has increased several times faster than income, and the cost of college is now about a third of what it was just a few decades ago. As a result, more students are taking out larger loans to finance their education. This trend is particularly prominent in the US, where higher education is often free or heavily subsidised in other wealthy countries.

In addition to student debt, the rising cost of living, including housing costs, poses a challenge for young people trying to manage their finances. Young people today often face record levels of student loan debt and rising housing costs, causing them to focus on their immediate needs rather than long-term investments.

The combination of soaring tuition costs, recessions, and the impact of the 2008 financial crisis and the COVID-19 pandemic have particularly affected millennials and subsequent generations, preventing them from reaching their financial goals.

To address these issues, experts and policymakers have proposed various solutions, including large-scale debt cancellation, targeted debt relief, and systemic reforms to reduce college costs and increase financial aid. While there is no one-size-fits-all solution, it is clear that the burden of student debt and the rising cost of living are significant factors contributing to young people's reluctance to invest.

Lack of financial knowledge

Young people's lack of financial knowledge is a significant factor in their reluctance to invest. This is supported by a study from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign study, which found that many young adults lack financial literacy and money management skills. The study classified young adults into four groups based on their financial attributes and behavioural patterns: financially precarious, at risk, striving, or stable.

The "financially precarious" group, comprising 32% of the sample, had the poorest financial literacy and frequently used alternative financial services with high interest rates and fees. This group's lack of access to mainstream financial institutions and their frequent use of costly alternative services contribute to their financial instability.

The study also highlights that individuals with higher financial literacy are more likely to plan and manage their finances effectively. They are more likely to have savings accounts, less likely to use costly alternative financial services, and are generally more confident about their financial knowledge.

Additionally, a survey by Harris Poll for the investing app Stash found that 34% of millennials said they didn't know how to invest. This lack of financial knowledge and understanding of investment options can be a significant barrier for young people considering investing.

Furthermore, a Bankrate survey found that only 23% of millennials preferred investing to other methods like cash or real estate. This hesitancy to invest in the stock market may be due to their preference for more immediate financial needs, such as managing student loan debt and rising housing costs.

The lack of financial knowledge among young people has lasting effects on their financial stability and decision-making. It is essential to address this issue through educational programs and initiatives to empower young people to make informed financial choices and improve their economic well-being.

Fear of losses

Young people are increasingly hesitant to invest in the stock market, with only 23% of millennials preferring stocks over cash, real estate, or bitcoin. This is a significantly lower percentage compared to older generations, such as Gen X and Baby Boomers. The main reason underlying this trend is the fear of losing money, which is a primal instinct deeply ingrained in our psyche.

This fear of loss is reflected in the concept of "loss aversion," where the psychological pain of losing money is twice as powerful as the pleasure of gaining the same amount. As a result, young people tend to avoid investing due to the potential losses they might incur. This fear of losing money can manifest as indecision, inaction, inertia, apathy, inattention, and internal resistance. It is important to note that even successful and wealthy individuals find investing scary.

The fear of losing money can be attributed to several factors. Firstly, evolution has wired our brains to focus on short-term survival rather than long-term planning. Additionally, our ancestors' experiences taught them to avoid risks and preserve resources, as losing resources could mean life or death. Secondly, the recent financial crises, such as the 2008 market crash and the dot com crash of the early 2000s, have left a significant impact on young people's perception of investing. Many have witnessed the collapse of investments and are wary of the potential risks involved.

Furthermore, young people often have more immediate financial concerns, such as student loan debt and rising housing costs, which can make long-term investing seem less appealing. They may also feel that they do not have enough money to invest or lack the knowledge and confidence to make informed investment decisions. Additionally, the traditional image of an investor being an "old white man" may also deter young people, especially young women, from entering the world of investing.

To overcome the fear of losing money, it is crucial to change one's mindset. Investing is not like gambling but involves making calculated decisions based on research and analysis. Diversifying one's portfolio by investing in a broad index or mutual funds can also help mitigate the risk of losses. Maintaining an emergency fund that covers living expenses for 3-6 months can provide peace of mind and reduce the fear of losing money in the short term.

Distrust of Wall Street

Young people's distrust of Wall Street is a significant factor in their reluctance to invest, with only 14% of respondents aged 18-29 saying they trust Wall Street to "do the right thing all or most of the time". This lack of trust is illustrated by the small number of millennials who invest in equities, with only 26% doing so according to a 2015 survey. This is despite the unprecedented returns offered by the stock market, with the S&P 500 rising 210% since its March 2009 low.

The 2008 financial crisis is often cited as the root cause of millennials' and young people's distrust of Wall Street. The recession had a significant impact on millennials, who were coming of age during this time and witnessed the collapse of some of the world's biggest financial institutions, as well as high unemployment and losses in their parents' investments. This experience has left many young people with a trust issue when it comes to Wall Street and the stock market, with a preference for cash savings over riskier investments.

The trauma of the 2008 crisis is not the only factor influencing young people's distrust and reluctance to invest. For older millennials, the dot-com crash of the early 2000s was also a significant event, and the volatility of the markets since then has further contributed to their wariness. Additionally, young people often have more immediate financial concerns, such as student loan debt and rising housing costs, which can make long-term investments seem less appealing or feasible.

The impact of these factors is evident in the investment choices of young people. While only 23% of millennials prefer investing to cash, this number increases to 33% for Gen X and 38% for baby boomers. The preference for cash over investments may be detrimental in the long run, as the buying power of cash savings is likely to decrease due to inflation. However, the memory of financial crises and a lack of trust in Wall Street continue to shape young people's investment decisions.

Preference for cash

Young people's preference for holding cash over investing in stocks or other assets is a well-documented phenomenon. There are several reasons why younger generations may opt for cash, including a focus on immediate financial needs, a lack of trust in the economic system, and a desire for financial stability.

One of the primary reasons young people prefer cash is to meet their immediate financial needs. Many young people struggle with record levels of student loan debt and rising housing costs. As a result, they may feel they cannot afford to tie up their money in long-term investments and prefer the liquidity that cash provides. This preference for cash may also be driven by a desire for financial stability. After witnessing the financial crises of 2008 and the dot-com crash of the early 2000s, it is understandable that young people want to protect their money and ensure they have access to it when needed.

Another factor influencing young people's preference for cash is a deep-rooted distrust in the economic system. Having grown up during a time of significant economic uncertainty and seeing their parents' retirement investments affected by the 2007 financial crisis, it is natural for younger generations to question the stability of traditional investment vehicles. This skepticism extends to the entities managing these investments, such as financial advisors and institutions. As a result, they may feel that holding cash is a safer and more reliable option.

Furthermore, young people's preference for cash may also be influenced by their investment goals and risk tolerance. Many young people are saving for major life events, such as a down payment on their first home or an upcoming wedding. With a shorter investment horizon, holding cash or cash equivalents can be a sensible choice to ensure they have the necessary funds when needed. Additionally, young people may be more risk-averse and view cash as a less risky option compared to volatile stock markets or other investments.

However, it is important to note that holding too much cash can have drawbacks. Cash holdings are subject to inflation, which can erode purchasing power over time. Young investors who choose to hold cash may miss out on the potential returns offered by other investments, such as stocks or real estate. While cash provides stability and liquidity, it may not be the best option for long-term wealth accumulation.

In conclusion, young people's preference for cash over investing can be attributed to a combination of factors, including a focus on immediate financial needs, distrust in the economic system, and a desire for financial stability. While holding cash can provide security and flexibility, young people should also consider the potential benefits of investing to ensure their money grows and keeps up with inflation. Striking a balance between liquidity and long-term wealth accumulation is crucial for building a secure financial future.

Frequently asked questions