Young Investors: Why The Reluctance?

Young people are investing more than ever, but many are not investing in the stock market. There are several reasons for this, including a lack of financial literacy, the impact of the 2008 market crash, and the complex financial landscape. Financial literacy rates among young people are low, with less than 50% financially literate globally. This makes it difficult for young people to navigate the various investment options and make informed decisions. The 2008 market crash also left a lasting impression, with young investors witnessing the loss of trillions of dollars and becoming wary of investing their money in stocks. Additionally, the financial landscape has become increasingly complex, with new financial products and decisions that can be challenging to navigate.

Young people are wary of investing due to the 2008 market crash and recent volatility

Young people are wary of investing in the stock market due to the 2008 market crash and recent volatility. According to a Gallup poll, less than half of young Americans are putting their money in stocks. The 2008 market crash, also known as the global financial crisis, was the most severe worldwide economic crisis since the Great Depression. It was caused by a combination of factors, including predatory lending in the form of subprime mortgages, excessive risk-taking by financial institutions, and the collapse of the United States housing bubble.

The impact of the 2008 market crash on young people's investing behaviour is evident in the Gallup poll results. In the two years leading up to the crash (2006-2007), 52% of adults under 35 owned stocks. However, in the years following the crash (2017-2018), this percentage dropped to 37%. This drop in stock ownership among young people can be attributed to the significant losses they incurred during the crash. Many young investors lost money, and even a decade later, some have not fully recovered financially.

The volatility of the stock market in recent years has also contributed to young people's wariness of investing. While there have been periods of strong growth, the market has also experienced major declines and increased volatility. This uncertainty makes young people hesitant to invest, as they fear further losses.

Additionally, young people's trust in the financial system has been shaken by the 2008 market crash. They have witnessed the negative consequences of unethical practices by financial institutions and the failure of regulatory systems to protect consumers. This has led to a general mistrust of Wall Street and a reluctance to engage in risky investments.

Despite these concerns, it is important to note that young people are not entirely averse to investing. Many are exploring alternative investment options, such as real estate or mutual funds, which they perceive as less risky than stocks. Additionally, the availability of new technologies, such as no-fee trading platforms and increased access to financial information, has sparked an interest in investing among young people. While they may be cautious due to the 2008 market crash and recent volatility, young people are still seeking opportunities to grow their wealth and secure their financial future.

Student loan debt and credit card debt make investing a lower priority

Young people are burdened with student loan debt and credit card debt, which makes investing a lower priority. Student loan debt in the United States has grown enormously in recent years and is now one of the largest forms of consumer borrowing. As of September 2023, 43 million borrowers collectively owed over $1.6 trillion in federal student loans, with private loans bringing the total above $1.7 trillion. This surpasses debt from auto loans and credit cards, with only home mortgage debt being higher.

The average student debt has increased by 39% from 2008 to 2022, as college tuition has grown much faster than income. The cost of college and resulting debt are higher in the United States than in almost all other wealthy countries, where higher education is often free or heavily subsidized. In contrast, U.S. states reduced funding for public universities and colleges after the 2008 financial crisis.

About one in five Americans holds student debt, with most graduates owing around $30,000 in loans. However, a small portion of borrowers, about 7%, hold a more significant share of student debt, with over $100,000 in loans. Additionally, the type of institution attended makes a difference in the amount of debt owed. Around half of the outstanding student debt is held by those who attended private schools, which enrolled only 23% of higher education students in 2021.

There is also a racial disparity in student borrowing, with Black college students generally taking on more debt than white students and facing more challenges in loan repayment due to lower levels of family wealth. Black, Latinx, and American Indian students are more likely to default on their loans than their white counterparts.

While student loans can be a sound investment in workers and essential for maintaining the country's competitive edge, they can hinder financial futures and prevent young people from reaching their financial goals. The burden of student loan debt, coupled with credit card debt, leaves young people with limited funds for investing, making it a lower priority.

Many young people lack the financial literacy to make informed investment decisions

The financial landscape is more complex than ever before, with new financial products and decisions constantly emerging. Innovations in technology, such as no-fee trading platforms and increased access to financial information online, have made it easier for young people to get involved in investing. However, the abundance of information can be overwhelming, and much of it is filled with jargon that can be confusing for those without a strong foundation in financial education.

Financial literacy programmes have often been absent from school curriculums, leaving young people without the necessary knowledge to make informed investment decisions. It is important for young people to have access to unbiased and accurate financial information, whether through school programmes, workplaces, or community gatherings. By improving financial literacy, young people can make more informed decisions about investing, retirement planning, budgeting, and debt management, ultimately leading to better financial well-being.

While some young people may be hesitant to invest due to concerns about market volatility or past crashes, others may be deterred by a lack of disposable income or unexpected expenses. However, investing even a small amount when young can have significant benefits due to the power of compound interest. Starting early and establishing good savings habits can help young people work towards their financial goals and better prepare for their future.

Young investors have a higher risk tolerance, which can lead to higher returns

Young people are increasingly investing in capital markets, with 70% of retail investors under the age of 45. However, financial literacy rates among this demographic are low, hovering below 50% globally. This demonstrates the need to improve access to financial information and education for young people.

Young investors are seeking high returns, with less regard for the potential impact on their mental health. They are more likely to be influenced by social media and news trends when making investment decisions, chasing high-risk, high-return assets. This is particularly evident in the rise of investments in cryptocurrencies and forex, which are often not understood to be regulated and can pose higher risks to their money.

While taking on higher risk can lead to higher returns, it is important for young investors to approach risk judiciously and to be aware of their risk tolerance. Financial literacy and education can empower young people to make more informed investment decisions, improving their financial well-being and long-term wealth creation. This includes understanding the importance of long-term goals, diversifying investments, and managing emotions when investing.

Overall, while young investors have a higher risk tolerance that can lead to higher returns, it is crucial for them to balance risk with financial literacy and long-term planning to make informed investment decisions.

Young people may be more focused on growing their wealth than previous generations

Young people are becoming more focused on growing their wealth than previous generations. This shift in mindset can be attributed to several factors, including:

Uncertain Financial Future

The prospect of an uncertain financial future has motivated individuals to explore investing as a means to grow their wealth. The financial landscape has become increasingly complex, with individuals facing the burden of financially preparing for different life stages. The shift from pension systems to employer-backed retirement plans, for instance, places greater responsibility on individuals to plan for their retirement.

Technological Innovations

Innovations in technology have played a pivotal role in sparking interest in investing among young people. The emergence of no-fee trading platforms and increased access to financial information online have lowered the barriers to entry for young investors. Markets are becoming more democratized, and investments that were once the domain of wealthier individuals are now seen as a pathway for young people to grow their wealth.

Education and Financial Literacy

While financial literacy rates among young people remain relatively low, there is a growing recognition of the importance of financial education. Young people are realizing that investing early in their careers can have significant advantages due to the power of compound interest. This knowledge is driving a greater focus on wealth accumulation and long-term financial planning.

Shifting Priorities

The priorities of young people today differ from those of previous generations. While previous generations may have focused on traditional methods of wealth accumulation, such as real estate ownership, younger generations are exploring alternative investment options. This shift in priorities is evident in countries like China, where a significant proportion of educated young adults consider investing a key part of their life plan.

Impact of the 2008 Market Crash

The 2008 market crash had a lasting impact on the investment behaviour of young people. While it initially led to a decrease in stock ownership among younger Americans, it also sparked a wariness of investing in volatile markets. However, as markets have recovered and shown strong growth, young people are once again turning to investing as a way to grow their wealth.

Frequently asked questions