Cash Repayments: A Smart Investment Strategy?

There are several ways that investors can get their money back from a company. The most common method is through dividends, which are payments made to shareholders out of a company's profits, usually paid out quarterly. Another way is through share repurchases, where a company buys back its own shares from investors, reducing the number of outstanding shares and increasing the value of the remaining shares. This is usually done when a company has excess cash. Companies can also repay investors through debt refinancing, where a new loan is taken out to pay off an existing loan, or by selling equity, issuing debt, or using cash flow from operations. If an investor has contributed money to a business in exchange for a stake, they will typically receive a proportion of the profits as the company grows. In the case of debt-based fundraising, investors are repaid in installments, often including interest.

Dividends and capital growth

Dividends can be paid in various forms, including cash, warrants for stock purchases, or additional stock shares. The payout frequency can vary, with some companies offering quarterly, monthly, or yearly dividends, while others may provide irregular special dividends. Dividends are often viewed as a reward or income for shareholders, and they can be an attractive option for those seeking long-term growth in their income and capital.

Capital gains, on the other hand, represent the increase in the value of an investment over time. This can include assets such as stocks or real estate. Investors typically realise capital gains when they sell their investments and take profits. Capital gains can be further categorised into short-term and long-term gains, depending on how long the asset was held before being sold.

In the context of paying back investors, both dividends and capital growth can play a role. Dividends provide a direct return to investors, often on a periodic basis. Capital growth, on the other hand, refers to the appreciation in the value of the investment itself. This can be important when investors sell their shares, as they may be able to realise a higher price than their original investment, thus benefiting from capital growth.

It is worth noting that the decision to focus on dividends or capital growth depends on various factors, including the company's financial health, market conditions, and investment objectives. Additionally, the repayment of investors may also involve other methods, such as share buy-backs, repayment schedules, or preferred rate repayments.

In summary, dividends and capital growth are both important aspects of investment returns. Dividends provide a direct cash flow to investors, while capital growth represents the potential profit from the sale of investments. The choice between focusing on dividends or capital growth depends on the specific circumstances and goals of the company and its investors.

Debt refinancing

There are several types of refinancing options:

• Rate-and-Term Refinancing: This is the most common type, where the original loan is paid off and replaced with a new loan agreement that requires lower interest payments.
• Cash-out Refinancing: This occurs when the underlying asset that collateralises the loan increases in value. The borrower can withdraw the increased value or equity in the asset in exchange for a higher loan amount and interest rate.
• Consolidation Refinancing: This involves obtaining a single loan at a lower rate than the average interest rate across multiple credit products, and using it to pay off existing debts.

Refinancing is often done in response to shifting economic conditions, such as a change in interest rates, to obtain more favourable borrowing terms. It can help lower fixed interest rates, reduce payments over the life of a loan, change the loan duration, or switch between fixed-rate and adjustable-rate mortgages.

It is important to note that refinancing will usually result in a temporary drop in an individual's credit score, and it may increase the total interest payment over the life of the loan if the loan term is reset to its original length.

Repayment schedules

When establishing a repayment schedule, it is essential to consider the investment structure and the investor's preferences. For instance, an investor may opt for a short-term investment with a defined repayment date or a longer-term partnership with periodic instalments. In the case of a loan, the repayment schedule will typically involve paying back the principal amount plus interest in regular instalments.

The specifics of a repayment schedule can vary depending on the nature of the investment and the investor's expectations. For example, a small business owner might agree to repay an investor's loan with a fixed interest rate, adhering to an amortization schedule. This ensures that the business owner repays a consistent amount each month, gradually chipping away at the principal amount and interest.

It is worth noting that repayment schedules are just one aspect of investor repayment strategies. Other methods include dividends, share repurchases, debt refinancing, and ownership buy-outs. Each approach has its own advantages and considerations, and it is essential to carefully evaluate the terms of the investment agreement and seek appropriate advice to determine the most suitable approach.

Share transfers

However, share transfers may not always be the best option. For example, if an investor is only interested in short-term gains, they may prefer a straight repayment. Additionally, share transfers may not be suitable for investors who want to increase their stake in the company. In this case, a debt-based investment or convertible debt may be more appropriate.

It's important to note that the method of repayment will depend on the type of investment and the terms of the agreement. Companies should have a plan in place for how they will repay investors to avoid potential issues.

Equity and share ownership

Equity investments are a common way for start-up businesses to raise capital. In this scenario, investors contribute money to the business in exchange for a stake in the company, typically receiving a proportion of the profits as the company grows. This type of investment offers established professionals the opportunity to provide valuable input and expertise, which can be worth significantly more than the cash they have contributed.

When it comes to repaying investors, there are a few options available, including ownership buy-outs, repayment schedules, preferred rate repayments, and share transfers. In an ownership buy-out, the business purchases shares back from the investor based on the equity they own and the business valuation. A repayment schedule, on the other hand, is well-suited for business loans or temporary investment agreements with an assumption of repayment. Preferred rate repayments give priority to investors, who receive repayment according to pre-agreed conditions. Finally, share transfers involve repaying a loan by exchanging debt for equity shares, giving the investor a proportion of the business equivalent to their investment.

It is important to note that equity investments do not typically follow a repayment schedule. The absence of a repayment schedule means that investors can benefit from dividends and capital growth, and a share buy-out or repayment may not always be mutually beneficial if the investor's expertise remains valuable to the business.

One example of equity and share ownership is when a company offers to repurchase existing shares from investors at a negotiated price. This allows investors to sell at a premium, realising a return on their investment. Additionally, companies can increase the value of remaining shares by reducing the number of outstanding shares through share repurchases.

Another scenario involves a small business owner who requires additional funding to complete a build-out before opening. In this case, a friend is willing to invest, but the owner is uncomfortable giving up ownership. A possible solution is to structure a fair equity agreement, such as offering non-voting shares with a set distribution value, ensuring the investor can get their initial cash investment back regardless of the future value of the business.

Frequently asked questions